News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by qume on Saturday August 11, 2018 @02:17AM (#17738616)
Hey respected downvoters - pure means homogeneous. Can you please explain to be what ultra homogeneous means?

When discussing scientific concepts being haphazard with language seems like it should be called out, especially when the source is a respected publication like wired.

Simply take a few seconds to let us all know the error in my ways please.

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by gh02t on Saturday August 11, 2018 @02:36AM (#17738661)
In this context "pure" is meaningless (truly 100% pure silicon is impossible to obtain in quantity), whereas "ultra pure" is a technical term that refers to a specific level of purity. The meanings are context dependent.

It isn't haphazard, it's actually hyper specific and the terms have clear definitions in context. And in this case they are defined in the article.

[dead]
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by close04 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @06:20AM (#17739125)
A pure metal is never 100% simply because that's practically impossible. Yet the term is perfectly correct when used in the right context. Now that you know it's context dependent you can maybe stop insisting it's wrong.

Pure or ultrapure simply mean different and very clearly defined levels of purity for every field they are used in. Including some that stretch your concept of pure, like pure quantum states. Please don't try to redefine it.

You're going into deeper and deeper mud while trying to walk out clean from this.

[dead]
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by close04 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @09:28AM (#17739591)
Sure... those fields should redefine their terminology because 2 guys on a forum can't understand what the words mean...

I hope you understand how many words from the dictionary you have been using wrong all this time. Off the top of my head, sphere. A word that describes absolutely no real-life object, as every single point on the surface of that object would have to be precisely the same distance from the center.

Want more? Clean. Spotless. Weightless (in most real life situations). Equal or same (again, in most real life situations). Or maybe some more special examples like second/minute. Defined either circularly as a reference to the other or very roughly as "depending on the periodicity of the radiation of a caesium-133 atom".

You go rewrite the technical dictionary while I think of a few more examples ;).

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by windows_tips on Saturday August 11, 2018 @10:01AM (#17739688)
A minute is simply 1/1440 of a "day".

Edit:

>2 guys on a forum

More than two guys. OED too.

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by gh02t on Saturday August 11, 2018 @12:47PM (#17740407)
That depends on whether or not you define "day" as mean solar day or as 24 hours; either way you need some sort of ultimate reference in order actually define a meaningful unit. A more stable definition is as 60 SI seconds, since the second is defined relative to a very precise physical reference (level transitions in cesium).

It is for a similar reason that the pound and yard were redefined in the 1960's as an exact multiple of the kilogram and meter, so as to be able to benefit from the exactness of physical definitions for those units (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_yard_and_pound).

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by close04 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @12:57PM (#17740454)
And as shown above OED deals so exceptionally well with all concepts... down to the second. Where it sends you to SI to get the proper definition. Can you show me what OED says for ultrapure?

How about secret and top secret? Ultraspherical and hypergeometric? And don't forget the cleanroom.

Try to put that "wit" into understanding that in highly specialized fields the terminology might get different meanings and none of it is wrong.

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by perl4ever on Saturday August 11, 2018 @02:35PM (#17740941)
What if there is a leap second on that day?
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by close04 on Saturday August 11, 2018 @03:18PM (#17741098)
Depends, what does the OED say about leaping seconds? This may turn out to be just wrong. :D

Anyway, I just realized that purest is also in the dictionary. So purest is good, ultrapure is bad... And if pure is 100% then purest is... 100er%?

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by upandatom on Saturday August 11, 2018 @02:34AM (#17738654)
Pure is not 100%. The article talks about 99.XXX percentages depending on application.
[dead]
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by acqq on Saturday August 11, 2018 @04:06AM (#17738843)
> the word pure _literally_ means 100%

Only to you, if you observe it out of the context. The practice is completely different, and the OP article wasn't incorrect.

http://www.thequartzcorp.com/en/applications/silicon-metal.h...

"For silicon metal to be used in solar and semiconductor applications it must be extremely pure. For solar applications, the metal must be 99.9999% Si, while semiconductor applications require 99.999999999% purity. No quartz product can be purified above 99.999% SiO2, which means silicon metal must go through successive purification processes before it can be used."

As you see, the common use in the industry of "pure" is somewhat as "went through the process of the purification," therefore if it is purified more than what is commonly referred to as "pure" then it's "extremely pure" or can even be called "ultra pure" (edit: note, in the sense of "purer than what is typically offered as pure" and not in the sense of "more than what anyway doesn't exist").

In practice, anything "completely" purified, so that "not even single atom of the impurity remains" simply doesn't exist. There's no absolute, only different achieved levels of what is commonly called "pure": See e.g. "Purest silicon sphere ever created":

https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/purest-silicon-sphere-ev...

The common usage, that you object to, reflects the reality.

[dead]
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by tabletopneedle on Saturday August 11, 2018 @07:51AM (#17739327)
For example, cleanroom has classification that implies some amount of dust particles/impurities in the air. The technicians don't talk about the number of dust particles allowed, they just consider class 5 suitable for some applications whereas others might need class 4.

Class 4 cleanroom makes sense, as does "Ultra pure" as long as industry sees it as a standard.

Another example: UHD makes as little sense as FHD in terms of display resolution. I mean, Full must mean it's at maximum possible amount of high definition? Well we just know it stands for 1920x1080, and we know UHD or 4K is larger.

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by dang on Saturday August 11, 2018 @06:17PM (#17741864)
Please don't do flamewars on HN and for heaven's sake not nitpicky pedantic ones.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by sanxiyn on Saturday August 11, 2018 @03:53AM (#17738807)
Your argument is valid but uninteresting, hence my downvote. You should mail WIRED for such corrections instead of posting comments to HN. WIRED won't read your HN comments.
Re:The science of ultra pure silicon by jsjohnst on Saturday August 11, 2018 @02:44PM (#17740981)
I would argue it isn’t even valid. Words have meaning in context, not isolation. There were lots of examples of words misused from their most exact dictionary definition given in this thread, which I’ll leave as an exercise to scroll up if you want to read. This was instead a pointless pedantic rant by a few folks.