TLS is fine enough for messages in flight, but a lot of messengers store message archives on their servers, and there may be tens of thousands of employees who have potential access to that; not sure if that's really what anybody's mom needs.
At which point you have essentially decayed to conventional PKI and don't get any the security properties that you were supposed to get from the fancy Signal protocol (i.e. PFS).
I think it is a pretty elegant solution to key distribution, even though I wouldn't plan any bomb attempts without first validating the fingerprints.
The upside is that users can communicate with each other without needing both endpoints online simultaneously (which is fairly hard to guarantee, given all the battery saving stuff in mobile OSes and lack of 100% network coverage).
The downside is the key cycle time is much longer than they would be if all communications were done with both parties online, but it's still much shorter than a conventional PKI (ex PGP).
Regular key rotation is good practice when using PGP or similar - have a master key that you use only for signing subkeys, generate a new subkey every month (say) and destroy the ones older than 2 months each time - though admittedly UI/tool support for doing this is limited.
If you're getting bi-directional communication with your partner, you're getting key cycling. The server can only delay key cycling in a session by delaying one direction of communication.
The server can't hand out the same pre-key to multiple users, because the client will delete pre-key pairs on first use, with the exception of a "last resort" pre-key. The server could exclusively hand out the last resort pre-key to all users attempting to contact you, and refuse to accept new pre-keys. Then the first flight of messages from users establishing a new session would not be PFS, but any messages sent once you respond would have PFS.
Adding, of course, the server could also hand out incorrect keys and man in the middle all the steps; so long as users don't verify the keys. And a malicious client and server could conspire to include the correct keys for verification and the MITM keys for transport. This would be visible in the shipped code, but if the backdoored client is only distributed to a limited set of users, it wouldn't be subject to random reverse engineering like the normal client is. But I assume everybody downloads multiple copies of apks from different networks and compares to ensure they're byte identical ;)
That implies the client has to have a code path for sending multiple messages without cycling. And it forces a tough choice between losing messages that are received out of order and not destroying keys quite as quickly as nominally expected.
Maybe it's fine, but for me it pushed the complexity threshold over the point where I could feel any confidence in it. I'm comfortable with traditional PKI. I'm comfortable with the online-only OTR/axolotl ratchet. But I'm very dubious of having this many edge cases.
> The server could exclusively hand out the last resort pre-key to all users attempting to contact you, and refuse to accept new pre-keys. Then the first flight of messages from users establishing a new session would not be PFS, but any messages sent once you respond would have PFS.
Assuming there's no way for the client to end up on the initial-message codepath.
Again, yeah, maybe it's fine. But it all just feels so hacky and fiddly. These edge cases aren't where anyone studying the protocol is going to spend any time, but it's security-critical that they be implemented right.
If you have a successful compromise of one message, a missed message is all it takes for the ratchet to self-heal and you have lost the ability to decrypt future messages. It is PFS+ in a sense.
How confident are you that the server can't trick the client into downgrading to a new trust-on-first-use exchange? I'd also ask what happens when one party sends multiple messages while the other is offline - eventually you must exhaust your preshared keys, at which point you have no good options - presharing more keys compromises forward secrecy, encrypting without more exchanges compromises forward secrecy, and it's very difficult to make it clear to the user what the tradeoffs are. And again, whatever approach you choose opens the door to downgrade attacks (particularly if we're assuming that the OWS servers are hostile - Signal fans always claim that you don't have to trust the server at all but then don't really commit to that when talking about these edge cases. If we really aren't trusting the server then we should assume the servers are under attacker control when analysing these edge cases)
> I would say that the goal of signal was more about making an encrypted secure messenger for my mom than making crypto nerds safe from targeted attacks by nation states.
Slurs against those who disagree with you do not improve your case.
Are there any messengers that don't use TLS left? (Even IRC servers tend to use it these days). Your mom is adequately served by transport encryption. The Venn diagram of people who need more security than transport encryption and people who can safely use phone numbers as identifiers looks like: OO