Re:Julia v1.0 has been released
by chriselrod on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:25PM
(#17720090)
I know it is not the default, but this package has no overhead over the default arrays according to recent benchmarks, and provides 0-indexed arrays:
https://github.com/JuliaArrays/OffsetArrays.jl
I confess, not being the default is a big thing. I've definitely had times where I thought "this would be easier with 0 indexed arrays", but it can then be harder to commit to adding a dependency and making that change vs just adding awkward looking "+1"s to all the indexes. Coming from math/science, there's lots of times 1-indexing makes more sense / is more familiar. It's normal there to start counting from 1, so it can be easier to translate.
It's non uncommon in mathematics to index from zero as well.
You get used to the 1-based indexing pretty quick. It's a non-issue. 1-based indexing is the standard in math, and also Matlab and Fortran. For the primary use-case of Julia, it makes sense. Julia REALLY tries to be easy for Matlab users, who still dwarf Python users in science.
> Julia REALLY tries to be easy for Matlab users
Not so much currently:
https://discourse.julialang.org/t/why-eye-has-been-deprecate...
When I started programming, all my languages with exception of Assembly used 1-indexing, so no, it doesn't scare all programmers.
Re:Julia v1.0 has been released
by geoalchimista on Thursday August 09, 2018 @12:57AM
(#17721720)
Even among scientists there are people who don't like 1-indexed arrays (me, one data point)! However, Julia 0.7 and 1.0 have the keyword "begin" so that you can basically program arrays in an index-agnostic way.
Really though, I think it has a better type system and a syntax that translates easier to mathematical expressions. Other than that, Python's breadth of packages will be hard to overcome.