News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by tjohns on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:00PM (#17710122)
Assuming you own your own home.

If you live in an apartment complex or otherwise only have street parking, you likely don't have access to electricity. Or at the very least, would need to negotiate with the landlord to have a new outlet installed -- which is going to depend on how much you get along with said landlord.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by fpgaminer on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:30PM (#17711009)
Not a problem in California at least:

"Assembly Bill 2565 would give tenants the right to install an electric-car charging station at their residence, provided the tenant submits a written request to the landlord and pays for the installation costs."

(Passed already)

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by gav on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:39PM (#17711081)
At a cost of at least $1000 for a charging station and installation, I can’t see many people wanting to pay for this if they are renting.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by nostrademons on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:15PM (#17711368)
The demographic that would currently buy an electric car in California can easily pay for $1K for a changing station. If you're going to spend $30K on a Leaf or plug-in Prius or $50K on a Model 3 (vs. $18K for a Corolla or Fit), $1K is a drop in the bucket. It's also a tiny fraction of rent in Northern California, roughly 12 days worth.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by prostoalex on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:03PM (#17711724)
The new Hyundai Ioniq PHEV can be bought for $25k.

In any case, most people don’t just shell out a random $30,000 they have burning a whole in their pocket, they finance the purchase over 5-6 years. Sudden out-of-pocket $1,000 is kinda a big deal, especially if one plans on moving out in a year or two.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by nostrademons on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:08PM (#17711752)
I must be living in Silicon Valley too long, because a large number of people I know - amongst the tech crowd at least - do in fact shell out a random $30K they have burning a hole in their pocket.

(Lest I get accused of being way too out of touch, I do know people for whom affording even a $200 car repair is out of reach, and something they'll put up a GoFundMe over. These people do not drive electric cars. If you can afford the ~$5K in interest that financing a car over 6 years will cost you, you can afford the $1K charger. If you can't afford this, you buy a used Ford or Chevy rather than any of the cars we're talking about here.)

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by prostoalex on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:14PM (#17711784)
The way I see it that with 0% financing deals aplenty there’s virtually no incentive to pay cash upfront. Might just as well stick that $30k into some high-yield savings account and set up automatic payments from there. Builds credit history, too.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by nostrademons on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:22PM (#17711831)
The last couple times I've been car shopping the 0% financing deals come with a jacked-up list price. You may get the loan at 0%, but the way that works is that they quote a higher price to begin with and then the 0% financing (assuming good credit) was their "concession" in the negotiation. We bought our cars for under dealer price, paying by cashier's check, so I assume that the actual dealer price was even lower (otherwise they wouldn't be willing to sell us the car), particularly since the lowest price they would go with financing was a couple thousand higher (credit scores in the 800s).
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jjeaff on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:37PM (#17712520)
This is exactly right. And i reiterate this often, TANSTAAFL. (There ain't no such thing as a free lunch).

No one is loaning you money interest free. You are just paying for it in the purchase price or through other fees.

I will admit there are rare cases where strange incentives may make it cheaper or the same price to buy with credit, but these are very rare, and are only applicable if you artificially limit your available selection of vehicles to brand new. Even though you could get virtually the same car with 10k miles on it for much less.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by prostoalex on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:58PM (#17712883)
For used cars there's always room for negotiating, but for new cars I felt the pricing was standardized through TrueCar (and their derivatives, like Costco Auto, Amex Cars, Overstock Cars). Is that not true?
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by nostrademons on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @12:05AM (#17713126)
There's the floor on prices that they will advertise to the public and then there's the actual floor on prices, and the latter can be significantly lower than the former.

Car dealerships have a number of incentives that can change their reserve price in strange ways. There's the advertising holdback and potential servicing cross-subsidies that sokoloff mentions, and then there are also monthly quotas and per-salesperson quotas. If the dealer is very close to their monthly quota and it's almost the end of the month, you can get a car below invoice price, because the manufacturer will give them a bonus for hitting the quota and so the marginal profit on the one car they sell you can be positive (including the bonus) even though the car itself sold at a loss. Similarly, if an individual salesperson is close to hitting their personal quota, they will let you have the car for the lowest price that won't get them in trouble with the dealer, because it helps them hit their numbers and gives them a bonus.

It's entirely possible that similar incentives exist for financing, and that's why people get zero-percent auto loans with cash back, and they're cross-subsidized by people who end up paying thousands in interest because their credit scores weren't as good or they didn't get as good a deal. But on average, the financing cost needs to be eaten by somebody, so on average you're likely to get better deals paying cash than financing. The dealer can also book all the cash immediately when you pay cash, which makes them somewhat more amenable to offer deals and opens up some other incentives for them to sell cheap (like getting rid of old model years near the end of the fiscal year and converting it to cash so their numbers look good and they can order more new model years).

(There can also be strange situations that make buying new more economical than buying used - I bought my Fit in 2009 for less than used 2007 Fits were going for, because the bottom had fallen out of the economy and oil had gone from $100/barrel to $50/barrel. The used car owners had paid ~$2000 over sticker price for a fuel-efficient car in a booming economy, while I paid ~$500 under invoice price because dealers were desperate to hit their quotas, and the dealer's beliefs about where the market is at adjusts faster than private owners' beliefs about where the market is at. Such situations are the exception rather than the rule, though.)

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by bgirard on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @01:59AM (#17713523)
I used the TrueCar price as a starting point for negotiation. I emailed a bunch of dealers asking them to beat the out-the-door price until I found the dealer offering my the best price. I walked in with a certified cheque and bought it after a short test drive. I got my car below TrueCar. The dealer claimed that I was getting it below invoice and he was only making money because of incentives. I brushed it off as a negotiation tactic.

I think it's easier to do this for a popular car so your mileage may vary.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toast0 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:31PM (#17713023)
In theory, you can get a 1 year old car for much less than new, but people who buy cars with the options I want* tend not to sell them after 1 year of use. Or like truck prices in the bay area, when I bought my ranger, it was about $2000 more to buy new than to buy a 10 year old truck. Or, occasionally I'm dumb and buying a new model, even though that's a bad idea because when things break nobody knows how to fix it yet.

* Or really, without the options I don't want.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by sokoloff on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:41PM (#17712254)
When I bought my LEAF in Dec 2014, I negotiated a price including a $2000 incentive from Nissan. Turns out that incentive was from NMAC (Nissan’s financing arm) and was only avail if I took a loan with them. Ok, what’s the interest rate? 0%. Wait, you give me $2K at signing and finance the car at 0% for 60 months? Ok, sign me up!

In terms of selling below their invoice price, they also get an advertising holdback that scales with cars sold, so they’re still making a small amount on the sales floor. The real money at a dealership is made in the service bays, not on the sales floor. This is what really sucks for dealers about electric cars. In 42 months, my LEAF has never seen the dealer again and I’ve only added washer fluid and changed the wiper blades once.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by mighty_atomic_c on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:47PM (#17712582)
Watch the range over time, though. The cells in even the latest Nissan Leafs do not have any charge or temperature conditioning for the batteries, so they are likely to age poorly basically anywhere with more than 1 season.

If you care for the batteries nicely (drive slow, don't slam accelerator, avoid winter), I'm sure they'll last a good long time, but the battery is a consumable that will need to be replaced sooner than most other major components, I think the Leaf has them under the rear seats, and may be a pain to deal with. If your Leaf has fast charging, it's advised to avoid using it too often because it will heat the batteries and may reduce charge over time.

I guess the skimping of quality here seems short-sighted, but every EV has some weird, questionable choices to cut down on weight.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by sokoloff on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:26PM (#17712747)
Concur all around. I think I’m down about 10% range in 3.5 years. Other family members own 3 different Smart electric drives and they’re down only 2-4% in the same timeframe. (Those cars have liquid cooled batteries, which appears to dramatically reduce long-term range loss.)
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by cma on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:20PM (#17712162)
If you expect to move apartments 3 times over the ownership period of the car, $3K is 10% of the purchase price for the Leaf.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toast0 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:33PM (#17713033)
If you buy a leaf off lease, 3k is 30% of the purchase price.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by panda888888 on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:57PM (#17719860)
Eh, not so sure about that. I live in Portland and 2011-2013 used Nissan Leafs go for ~$7k. They're not rich people cars anymore, at least not here. I assume the same is true in California.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jblow on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:13PM (#17712410)
You probably don’t need a charging station. Teslas can charge from a wall outlet, for example.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by Johnny555 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:43PM (#17712553)
The Tesla gives around 5 hours of range per hour of charging in a standard 120VAC outlet, so if your car is parked 12 hours overnight, your one-way commute has to be less than 30 miles.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by fred256 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:08PM (#17712920)
5 miles of range per hour of charging, presumably?
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jblow on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @03:11PM (#17718561)
Who said 120v? Plug it into a dryer outlet. My point was that you don't need all this big excessive expensive charging circuitry.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by ec109685 on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @12:52AM (#17713277)
You have weekends to catch up as well, where depending on life style, might keep the car parked in garage for longer period.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jdietrich on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:17PM (#17712703)
Here in the UK, EV chargers are heavily subsidised, on the basis that they're tantamount to a common resource. Installing a 7kW home charger costs as little as £150 ($200) after subsidy, with charger grants also available for businesses and local governments. It's a bit regressive considering the high cost of EVs right now, but it seems like a sensible step if you're aiming for ubiquitous charging infrastructure.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by fpgaminer on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:54PM (#17711204)
I'd be curious if there are loan options that would cover the cost. Then it's not such a crazy thing for renters to consider installing a charger. (I mean, they're already paying ~$30k for a car on loan; another $1k isn't much).
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jschwartzi on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:58PM (#17711237)
I move every 3 or 4 years, so I'd basically be paying each landlord to make improvements to their place and then leaving those improvements behind.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:23PM (#17711421)
If the landlord bought the charger station, they'd up your rent by what the market would bear for parking spots with EV-charging capacity.

So you install it at your expense, sell it at the depreciated price when you move out, and the landlord recovers the cost by upping the rent for the next EV driver looking for a new apartment. Or they don't, and you remove it and take it with you when you leave, paying the electrician labor again on both ends.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by prawn on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:27PM (#17711859)
I'll suspect that these people (and most people in fact) won't own their own cars. Those that do, in regional areas most likely, will have their own garaging and access to power.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by elif on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:17PM (#17711380)
if $1000 is rough, you can buy a $50 extension cable.

Source: I drag an orange 75 foot extension cable once per week and have used a public charger exactly once for novelty-sake.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by mikekchar on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:03PM (#17711723)
My wife wants a new car (I don't drive) and I'm looking into an EV. We live in an apartment building. The biggest problem I see is that there is no power I can connect a cable to that can be billed to me. The only external power in the building is used by the building for various things (mostly cleaning).

So there is going to be some cost to setting this up even if the landlord allows it (which he may not).

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by lgats on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:37PM (#17711533)
There are some losses with running that much power through a long extension cable - maybe 1-4% depending on the setup.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by prawn on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:28PM (#17711870)
Do you think that will be a significant factor in this discussion and dissuade people from EV ownership?
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by EdJiang on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:54PM (#17713092)
My parking garage in California charges $5,000 for charger installation. Plus you have to pay for the energy, at retail charging rates. Definitely not worth it.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by s0rce on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:37PM (#17712525)
What do you do if you park on the street. I've seen some people here just throw the cable across the sidewalk but I'm not sure thats really the best solution...
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by jdietrich on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:04PM (#17712649)
Medium-term solution:

EV chargers can be integrated into lamp posts or other items of street furniture. A city-wide network of charging points can be managed using contactless payment, with IoT sensors to indicate vacant charging points. Building out widespread on-street charging infrastructure won't be quick or cheap, but it's entirely feasible with existing technology.

There's also a reasonable expectation that some combination of car-sharing, ride-sharing and autonomous vehicles will significantly reduce the rate of private car ownership. Electric bicycles and scooters show tremendous potential for reducing the demand for car ownership in urban areas. Good public transit of course has a major role to play.

http://www.rolecserv.com/ev-charging/product/EV-Charging-Str...

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toast0 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:25PM (#17712998)
Autonomous vehicles makes owning a car even more convenient. I don't have to worry about parking, it can drop me off at the door, and then go park a mile away (or just circle around). I can get one for my child, so I don't have to drive him to school or let him walk/bike to school (it's dangerous, what with all the cars around).
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:15PM (#17712417)
Great. What if someone parks in your spot?
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by reaperducer on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:21PM (#17711400)
Assuming you own your own home

Pretty much every significant apartment building built in Chicago in the last decade has had EV chargers in the garage.

The problem is that there aren't enough EV spaces to go around for all the residents who have electric cars.

If you're renting a stand-alone home, isn't there an EV station you can plug into a regular outlet? Naturally, the charging time would be slower than a 220V connection or whatever is needed, but if it's charing overnight, is that not an option?

(Don't own an electric car yet, so I'm not up on chargers)

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by outworlder on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:33PM (#17711495)
Pretty much every EV out there comes with a "granny cable" that you can use to very slowly charge. It won't fully charge overnight (works out to about 4 miles an hour), but if you are topping off it can be adequate. I have used it many times, including one time where I actually ran out and had the car towed. Towed the dead car home, plugged in. Went to work fine the next morning and plugged there.

That's if you are in the US, actually, where most outlets are 110V. If you have access to 220V or you can rewire an outlet, then charging time should be similar to public level 2 charging stations. Beware that not all charges will support 220v and will blow up (but some can be modified).

110v is the biggest barrier for adoption everywhere, that and old electrical installations.

As an EV owner, I'd say that you need either a place to charge at work, or at home (great if you have both). If you do, then it is more convenient than pulling up at gas stations (more so if you are trying to get the cheaper ones in the likes of CostCo). If you do not, then relying on the public infrastructure is stressful and time consuming.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by sokoloff on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:46PM (#17712275)
US residential electricity is (typically) 240 V center-tapped to ground, so you can have 120V or 240V.

110V hasn’t been the standard since before World War II.

Slow charge for my LEAF is about 5 miles per hour from a standard outlet.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by reaperducer on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @06:58PM (#17711686)
Thanks for the detailed response.

One of the cars in my family only drives eight miles a day, and never on weekends. So I'm thinking about replacing it with an EV. Sounds like a granny cable might be all I need.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by outworlder on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:08PM (#17711750)
My commute today is exactly 8 miles (4 each way). With a 2015 Leaf, I could go for two weeks without even bothering to charge if I'm only commuting. Since I can charge at work for free, I do it every Friday. And it's fantastic.

My previous commute was 50 miles a day. Using only a standard 110v, I would top off every day, and that worked just fine. I could even forget once (but not twice in a row!). It took about 12 hours to charge what I used up during the day.

So yeah. Just grab an extension cord (make sure it is rated for the current), and plug into whatever outlet you can find.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by s0rce on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:39PM (#17712533)
Not to be a smart ass but a bike/e-bike also works pretty well for a 4 mile commute assuming you can ride a bike.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by Johnny555 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:38PM (#17712527)
Even if you down own your home, it's no guarantee.

I live in a condo with a detached garage, which is on the far side of another row of condos.

So getting power from my meter to the garage means trenching through a sidewalk, under a block of condos, then through about 20 feet of pavement. Alternatively, I could trench through 100 feet of pavement from the power vault where our complex's transformer is and have the power company install a new meter for me.

The garage has a light bulb + garage door opener circuit, but the panel that feeds it wouldn't support a single charge station, let alone enough for the 8 garages that the panel serves.

The HOA isn't interested in running enough power to let residents install an EV charge station in the garage, and I'm not interested in paying for it either. So unless I can get my neighbors to help share the cost, I'm not going to be able to install a charge station.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by emiliobumachar on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @04:10AM (#17714017)
Just a thought: a sufficiently smart EV and a sufficiently smart garage door could talk to each other to share a circuit. The car just stops charging when the door needs to move, which shouldn't add up to too much time.

Not practical for an individual to develop to solve their individual problem, but maybe it could become a selling point for any particular EV.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by tialaramex on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:24AM (#17714271)
The problem isn't "sharing" the circuit, the problem is that the EV charger wants power, as much power as possible, and the circuit to that garage has been sized to allow for just enough to run a bulb and some trivial electrics like a door opener. Say 150W.

If you divert that 150W to an EV charger, so little power will make no perceptible difference to the charge overnight. Maybe 3-4 miles per night. And in fact a smart charger might conclude the circuit is faulty and cease charging altogether at this very low input.

Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by rconti on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:06PM (#17711739)
That's not going to be a serious obstacle to that 5 million figure, though. It obviously hurts individuals plenty, but in aggregate, enough people own their own homes that adoption can be orders of magnitude greater than it is now before the renter issue is figured out.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:13PM (#17710269)
There are solutions for street parking (both standalone and equipment that can piggyback off street lamp installs). In this case, you do need municipal buy in for the installation and maintenance of this infrastructure.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by IshKebab on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:56PM (#17710726)
Yes the problem with that is you kind of need it everywhere all at once, whereas if you have a home with a drive you only need to install it when you buy an electric car and only in one place.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:10PM (#17710838)
You really don't. You just need to pace the installs to EV vehicle uptake (which you can monitor with vehicle registrations and the addresses vehicles are registered at). Install where cars are being bought and garaged (or in this case, street parked).
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by closeparen on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:30PM (#17711012)
What happens when someone else nabs that space?
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:33PM (#17711041)
Laws are already on the books that penalize non-EVs for parking in EV charging spaces. My statement assumes you'd overbuild in order to ensure spots (one EV in neighborhood? build capacity for 3 to charge).
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by closeparen on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:48PM (#17711155)
Street parking spaces aren’t reserved for individuals. Anyone else with an EV (visitor? neighbor who just bought one?) is equally entitled to those spots. You would own a car rather than rent or take public transit (esp. in an urban area) because you need it to be available and working every time, not just under ideal circumstances. Gambling your work attendance on getting a particular street parking spot the night before isn’t smart.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by mikeash on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:57PM (#17711236)
The better EVs available now will support a typical commute without charging for a week or more.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by perl4ever on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:31PM (#17711887)
There's a couple of spots by a charger in a plaza where I often go, posted as "reserved for hybrid/electric". Well, they didn't make it explicit enough, because someone with a non-plugin hybrid was using one of them, the last time I was there. It would suck if I had an electric car and someone like that was blocking me.
Re:Shortage of charging stations to become a bottleneck to m... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:32PM (#17711893)
Minor logistics issue to be fixed.