News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by ariehkovler on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:09AM (#17704898)
Really interesting. Makes me think of Daisyworld and the Gaia Hypothesis.

Daisyworld is a model Earth covered in black and white daisies, that either absorb or reflect light. In the model, black daisies need less light because they absorb more, increasing the Earth's heat absorption. White daisies absorb less so need more light, but also reflect more light back, increasing the surface albedo of the planet and lowering its ambient temperature.

Because of this, there's a feedback loop were even if the sun gets a little hotter or colder, the successful daisy would spread and either warm or cool the Earth in response, effectively acting as a stabilizer. Gaia theory suggests that the world is full of these stabilizing systems.

Anyone who ever played SimEarth in the 90s, it was based on this theory and even had a Daisyworld simulation built in.

In this case, the paper is suggesting that seaweed grows much faster in response to raised CO2, and then sequesters some of that carbon underwater.

One question I have is how sequestered the undersea carbon really is and whether it will have other, unknown effects on the deep see ecosystem.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by pjc50 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:18AM (#17704936)
We know that there are a number of homeostatic (self-regulating) processes that affect the proportion of CO2 in the atmosphere; if it wasn't homeostatic it would have drifted off to an extreme long ago. The key question is how well and how rapidly these mechanisms can respond to an increase in CO2 levels.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by bumholio on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:38AM (#17705019)
The homeostasis might work in a limited range under which the biological world evolved in the recent past. Exceeding that range could quickly turn to a runaway geological event of rapid climate change, a state transition in a complex and unpredictable system.

Take for example the great oxidation event happening 2.5 billion years ago. As oxygen excreting algae began to take over methane producing organisms, oxygen started to build up in the atmosphere - first slowly, as there were lots of stuff to oxidize, like methane and iron. Eventually, these naturals sinks were saturated and oxygen levels reached the critical toxic point for the other species, leading to a runaway die-off where more and more oxygen was released and methane - a strong green house gas - rapidly disappeared from the atmosphere. This shock was so massive it produced the 400 million year Huronian glaciation - a whole planet freeze unlike any since.

So I have full faith life on Earth will eventually restore the feedback loops and get the temperatures back in the sweet spot. I have less faith that this will happen soon, or that most species, humans included, can survive such a massive transition event.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by masklinn on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:12AM (#17705421)
> So I have full faith life on Earth will eventually restore the feedback loops and get the temperatures back in the sweet spot.

Or just broadly adapt to the new state of things, historical data suggests that atmospheric CO2 levels did reach ~1000PPM up to the Cretaceous, with complete lack of continental ice sheets and temperate forests at the poles.

The current sweet spot is a sweet spot for us and the ecosystems we grew up in as a species, it's not a life-wide sweet spot.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:56AM (#17705643)
Yes, the comment you replied to seems to imply that the earth is an organism that seeks to maintain a particular balance. There may be homeostatic processes, but they're not part of a grand plan to preserve life on earth.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jonbarker on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:59AM (#17706097)
Agreed, homeostasis is something we observe in evolved organisms, not in planets whose inhabitant organisms became self aware and industrialized suddenly.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by vinceguidry on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:33PM (#17708687)
We are the grand plan. Let's just hope we fulfill our role.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by acqq on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:23PM (#17710380)
If the role is "get the carbon, that was for hundreds of millions of yeas trapped in the crust, back to the atmosphere in just a hundred or so of years and perish," yes, we’re success up to now.

A recent comment of a recent article about who's the most responsible:

https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/08/nyt-mag-...

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:47PM (#17708818)
"Wake up to find out that you are the eyes of the world."

edited to say:

It's interesting that on a long enough time-line, all life on earth is destined for extinction, e.g. the sun expands and vaporizes the earth. So, in the long run, our technological prowess is likely the only hope for our furry (and not so furry) friends.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by qubex on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:26AM (#17705480)
“The Return to Cretaceous World” just doesn’t have the same cinematic draw to it.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by bumholio on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:51AM (#17705609)
I believe the "Cretaceous Greenhouse" would make quite a good movie, considering the massive inland seas that formed during the period over the continental shelf. The majority of people on Earth would have to move house to higher altitudes.

It's mind-boggling to consider that we increased the CO2 levels from 280 to 410 ppm during the industrial age. We went a quarter of the way to the Cretaceous super-greenhouse of 1000 ppm, with most of the change accumulating in recent decades. And we are accelerating.

It's hard to see how most complex ecosystems would survive that kind of change in just a century or so, evolution is simply not that rapid. Forget moving house, imagine a world where the only functional natural ecosystems are bacterial.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by masklinn on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:14AM (#17705759)
> I believe the "Cretaceous Greenhouse" would make quite a good movie, considering the massive inland seas that formed during the period over the continental shelf. The majority of people on Earth would have to move house to higher altitudes.

Many breadbasket lands are also fairly low-lying. The northern china plain is mostly under 50m. Even if it doesn't get covered in water, saline intrusion will seriously hurt it, as it's already starting to hurt countries with extensive coastlines and river deltas like Vietnam or Bangladesh.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by wrycoder on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:32AM (#17705874)
I’m reading the three Wikipedia pages “Ice Age”, “Geologic Temperature Record”, and “Carbon Dioxide in Earth’s Atmosphere”. They are imo not tendentious at this time and give a fascinating introduction to the extremely complex geologic climate. For example, it’s remarked that the high temperatures in the Cretaceous were likely mostly due to the formation of Pangea and the resulting change in ocean circulation.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by 21 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:50AM (#17705604)
> I have less faith that this will happen soon, or that most species, humans included, can survive such a massive transition event.

This stuff doesn't happen in a year. And we have a bunch of ways of ego-engineering, what's missing is an acute need and the economics/political incentives, which again, an acute need would provide.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by ebikelaw on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:27PM (#17708061)
This is the most true typo ever.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by rbanffy on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:49AM (#17707692)
> I have full faith life on Earth will eventually restore the feedback loops and get the temperatures back in the sweet spot.

Venusians thought that and look at where they are now.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by eanzenberg on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:52PM (#17708858)
Is 3deg C or 10deg F until 2100 that massive of a transition event?
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by pyrale on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @03:05AM (#17713770)
The last ice age (ie a sheet of ice covering a large part of NA) was about 4ºC or 12ºF colder.

So yes, that is a pretty massive thing, especially happening over a lifetime.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by lurquer on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @04:01PM (#17718939)
The freezing point of water creates a discontinuity in the effects of temperature change. That is, a ten degree swing that results in water freezing (or melting) for most of the year is far different than than a ten degree swing in a range far above (or below) 32 degrees.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by bumholio on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @03:48AM (#17817074)
On the other hand, a positive 10 degree global increase will include regions where water freezes regularly. This will either completely change the climate of those regions, or would mean that temperature swings in the rest of the world will increase much higher to compensate.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by scythe on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:18PM (#17707965)
The big cycle is caused by the reaction of magnesium silicate with carbon dioxide. Mg silicate is the chief component of Earth's mantle. As temperature increases, silicate rocks are worn away faster by rain and wind, and absorb more CO2. This CO2 eventually sinks down into the mantle as magnesium carbonate, where it is very slowly re-released by volcanoes (the majority of Earth's carbon is in the mantle). As CO2 is sequestered, the Earth cools, and the weathering of silicate rocks slows, especially when they are covered by glaciers. Then the release of CO2 by volcanoes starts to outpace the absorption by olivine, and the atmosphere warms up again.

Eventually as the Sun gets brighter, the equilibrium amount of CO2 in the atmosphere is expected to drop below the requirements for plant life, and the Earth will die. By heating the atmosphere, we hasten the arrival of the next glacial cycle, but we are (thankfully) at low risk of starving the biosphere.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by JulianMorrison on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:43AM (#17705974)
Also it may be homeostatic with multiple attractors, push too hard from one and you pop over into the one next door.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by azernik on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:33AM (#17707542)
This is actually not at all what the paper is saying.

It's saying that a natural carbon-sequestration process we already knew about is more effective than we thought. It says nothing about the way seaweed growth changes with increased carbon levels.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by mistercow on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:37PM (#17709849)
In other words, it sounds like the above commenter is suggesting that seaweed might unexpectedly save us. But the actual point is almost the opposite: this means we’ve been relying on something all along that we didn’t know we needed to protect.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by azernik on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:52PM (#17711186)
I hadn't thought about it that way! Although I'm actually not sure in which direction it changes their priors - I'm not sure if this adds to the negative-carbon side of the scales in models taking this into account, or if this was already factored into some kind of separate measurement of total natural carbon sequestration and so the loss of seaweed now adds a bigger positive-carbon term.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by red75prime on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:39PM (#17708191)
> Gaia theory suggests that the world is full of these stabilizing systems.

Or stable feedback loops exist longer (because they are stable) and that's all there is to it. Life managed to almost kill itself a couple of times during Huronian glaciation.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by matt42 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:07AM (#17705713)
>> Gaia theory suggests that the world is full of these stabilizing systems.

Earth may have tricks to save its ecosystem, one of them could be temporarily increase temperatures and sea levels, just enough to end humanity.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jules on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:14AM (#17705760)
It is exceedingly unlikely that raised temperatures or sea levels would end humanity. Even if all ice melts there would still be a lot of land, and humans can and do currently survive in hot climates. The habitable zone will just shrink a bit, but it will also expand in other places. Siberia + 5 degrees is still cold.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by enraged_camel on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:41AM (#17707047)
No, this is very wrong. It’s not about having land to live on and being able to continue to breathe on it. Of course we would be able to do that.

The issue is all the parts of the ecosystem we have come to rely on. Animals, plants, insects... the entire global economy and our ways of live are tightly intertwined with everything else and even small disruptions can have enormous repercussions, especially on more vulnerable populations in the world.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by mbostleman on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:21PM (#17707981)
This description is full of hyperbolic generalities. The available land example may or may not be comprehensive, but at least it's specific.

I think the biggest problem that I have about everything climate change / global warming is that we are making laws to force (don't forget that force means pointing guns at people regardless of the warm and fuzzy intentions used to sell it) entire populations and their economies in the absence of so much specific knowledge. That doesn't make me a denier because accept / deny is not really the issue. Just because I accept the general premise doesn't mean that I trust the depth of the understanding to the point that I am willing to turn a gun on my neighbor to either reduce their liberty and / or confiscate their personal property in the name of said premise.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by DanBC on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:22PM (#17708002)
> (don't forget that force means pointing guns at people

I'd love to know where this comes from, because it's clearly fucking bollocks but is trotted out in many threads.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snerbles on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:09PM (#17708447)
Ultimately though, the state derives its power from a legitimate monopoly on violence.

If an entity continues to defy the laws and softer enforcement doesn't work (fines levied, assets frozen, etc.), eventually the state must use physical force to maintain the rule of law.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jschwartzi on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:34PM (#17708139)
It comes from a very explicit reading of Ayn Rand, who frequently likens law and regulation to the explicit use of force. To be fair, it's true but the literal statement of the fact misses a lot of the nuance of living in a civil society.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by mbostleman on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:00PM (#17708353)
Of course it's true, no need for your generosity of fairness. Just don't obey the law and see what happens. Continue to do so and eventually you'll be looking down the barrel of a gun. Pointing this out is not Randian. It's just reality.

There are no nuances of living in a civil society when solutions are implemented by law. If it's by law, then it's by gun. I don't know of any law that works otherwise.

I think the nuance you're referring to is when people's minds are (actually) changed such that they work together on a common goal. There becomes a natural supply and demand of a certain behavior. But most of the effort that I see is not convincing people to support a certain shared goal per se, but rather to join a tribe to crowd source the passage of laws.

The more important thing to me - and the point I meant to make, though I didn't fully articulate it - is that pointing a gun at someone (or indeed entire sectors of an economy) should be reserved for situations in which there is a very high bar of confidence in the detailed facts and predictions of the outcomes. While we may all agree that global warming causes climate change and even that it is anthropomorphic, it doesn't appear to me that we have a level of specific knowledge to say that "a reduction of carbon emission by x will result in a climate of y in the year z". If we don't have that, then I question both the morality and practicality of what appears to be a witch hunt in the form of policy making.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:08PM (#17708998)
Even in a fully laizes fair community you would sooner or later be “looking down the barrel of a gun” for some reason or other. Laws at least makes it a bit easier to predict what reasons that would be.

But regarding the need for knowing exactly how things works and who should have rights to do what. I could equally argue that your contribution to raising the CO2 concentration of our shared resource, the atmosphere, is not sanctioned by me. So why is it not you that should prove it is safe before asking me to just accept your doing so?

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:20PM (#17709130)
> I could equally argue that your contribution to raising the CO2 concentration of our shared resource, the atmosphere, is not sanctioned by me.

Then I suppose you should do us all a favor and stop breathing because your breathing is not sanctioned by me. (Just kidding, it is :))

Seriously though, that's just the way it's always been. We're born into the world and we act w/out permission to survive. I don't have to prove to anyone that the next step I take is safe. But if it harms you in some way, then yes, I'm liable.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by CuriousSkeptic on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:07PM (#17710200)
I guess there is a fundamental difference in how we see the commons. I take the view that it is not simply “there” as a first come first serve basis, but rather something we have an equal right to, the basis from which private property must be derived. Locke started here.

But I think the breathing thing is actually a good retort. Where do the principles meet...

I guess in the case the differenence is between drinking from the well and pissing in it. It might very well be safe, but certainly not nice

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @11:06AM (#17716534)
> I take the view that it is not simply “there” as a first come first serve basis, but rather something we have an equal right to, the basis from which private property must be derived. Locke started here.

I think I'm with you there. I don't have a problem paying property tax because as a person born on this earth, you're also entitled to my land. I'm paying a tax for the privilege of it being mine.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jschwartzi on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:33PM (#17708128)
What if your neighbor was dumping liquid radioactive waste on your land, right outside your house? Greenhouse gases should be considered harmful pollution, and because they eliminate vast swathes of habitable land they should be treated similarly to other forms of toxic waste.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by mbostleman on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:14PM (#17708487)
I understand your general comparison to toxic waste. The problem is not the comparison, it's the level of specificity. If someone is dumping an amount of say Parathion on my lawn, it is well within our ability to accurately determine the nature and amount of damage to me and my property given the amount and frequency of the dumping. And given that, it's a short step to monetizing the damage. In terms of accuracy, can we say the same for carbon? I don't believe we can. So while there may be a valid comparison at a high level, when it gets to actually determining damages to individuals or society, we just aren't there imo.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jschwartzi on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:23PM (#17708584)
I realize the simulations we're using to extrapolate the potential damage are just that -- extrapolations. However, we've been using the actual effects of the existing warming to improve those simulations. These simulations are increasingly indicating that we will raise sea levels by several meters, and that vast swathes of temperate land will become uninhabitable. While we don't know for certain this will happen, the hazards posed in the event that it does happen mean we need to take steps now.

If it could be reasonably expected the dumper knew Parathion were toxic at certain levels in the groundwater and they continued to increase those amounts, it would be reasonable to sanction them before the levels become unsafe. If you only apply sanctions after the damage is done, the sanctions don't really do anything. The best thing to do is to try to mitigate the risk rather than waiting for more information.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jamroom on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:06PM (#17708420)
I agree 100%. For some reason environmental discussions always have to include the "cost" to business in the decision whether we do anything about it.

I imagine if I told my neighbor that I felt it was cost prohibitive to pay for trash pickup service, so I was just going to dump my trash in their yard, they'd have a problem with that. Why do we allow companies to pollute water, land and air that doesn't belong to them?

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by jules on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:18AM (#17715652)
That it would hurt vulnerable populations who live in a region that becomes uninhabitable is undoubtedly true and I didn't argue against that, but that is not the end of humanity, which is what you claimed.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by hcurtiss on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:27PM (#17708057)
Maybe, but none of those things necessarily end humanity.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:44AM (#17705980)
The earth is not a superorganism or entity that prefers one state to another.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by cududa on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:13PM (#17710273)
It’s always funny to me when people say “we’re killing the planet!” Uh no, we’re just making it uninhabitable for ourselves and some other species. Earth doesn’t give a damn either way
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by CodeCube on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:40AM (#17706455)
Like a fever :)
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by swarnie_ on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:13AM (#17705751)
The Great Filter in effect.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by cup-of-tea on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:16AM (#17705774)
This is surely the case. Nobody really thinks humans have the ability to wipe out all life on Earth do they? We might be able to destroy ourselves, but life will probably continue at least until the Sun turns into a red giant. Life on Earth has survived far more catastrophic events than anything we can manage.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by FooHentai on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:26PM (#17712753)
>Nobody really thinks humans have the ability to wipe out all life on Earth do they?

'all life on earth' as in down to microorganisms, amoeba etc? No, I would hope not. Short of wiping out the atmosphere in it's entirety, PLUS destroying the surface of the entire earth do an as-yet-unknown depth sufficient to reach every existing colony of microorganisms etc, humanity's destructive abilities don't extend that far, yet.

But do humans have the ability to wipe out all sophisticated life on earth i.e. all plants, mammals, fish, and so on such to turn the clock back on a few billion years of evolution? Yeah I certainly believe that's within our abilities, and indeed likely if current activities continue uninterrupted.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by eganist on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:21AM (#17705799)
Any large system can be undermined by a small actor imposing a miniscule change. It just depends on which component of the system is disrupted.

Granted your options dwindle as the disparity grows, but so long as a component is accessible to an actor, the system can be impacted.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by cup-of-tea on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:23AM (#17705811)
Can you prove that? I don't believe it.

Are there any theories supporting the end of all life on Earth?

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by samfriedman on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:15AM (#17705767)
Something I think of often when people say things like "we need to stop climate change and save the world!" The world will be fine, it's not going anywhere: humans and the species we like on the other hand...
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by _carl_jung on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:37AM (#17706426)
"The world" is a synecdoche in that context. These people don't literally think we're going to make the earth disappear.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by older on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:21AM (#17705797)
Are you George Carlin?
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by samfriedman on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:04AM (#17706669)
Ah, yes, that's where I first heard that thought! Thanks, just a bit of cryptomnesia.

https://youtu.be/BB0aFPXr4n4?t=144

Side note: something I've never seen before on that Youtube video: it links the Wikipedia page for climate change right under the video. An attempt to battle misleading videos perhaps?

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by rement on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:31AM (#17706946)
The Wikipedia links are a new initiative Google is doing to combat fake news and misleading information [0].

0: https://youtube.googleblog.com/2018/07/building-better-news-...

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by eanzenberg on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:55PM (#17708893)
Humans will be fine. Dumb humans on the other hand...
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by wklauss on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:27AM (#17704977)
> Because of this, there's a feedback loop were even if the sun gets a little hotter or colder, the successful daisy would spread and either warm or cool the Earth in response, effectively acting as a stabilizer. Gaia theory suggests that the world is full of these stabilizing systems.

There are several mechanisms in place on earth to stabilize changes in atmospheric composition and temperature (otherwise an sporadic eruption of a volcano or glacial eras would have thrown things out of whack long time ago). I don't think this is an hypothesis. We have seen some of them in action in recent years, like the advanced rate of reforestation due to larger levels of CO2 in the atmosphere.

The problem is we don't know what would happen if we push these to the limit or what their limit really is. And they are very complex in the way the interact. For example. Warmer oceans and larger levels of CO2 will make phytoplankton grow faster, absorbing more CO2 in return, but it will also accelerate the growth of zooplankton, that feeds on it. This creates a bottleneck.

So TL;DR: yeah, it's cool we have these mechanisms around but the goal should still be to keep things as close to the baseline as possible (and we have been really bad about it in the last century)

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by smittywerben on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:21AM (#17706845)
> close to the baseline

More like don't do one of these on accident... :-)

"One of the major questions is whether the Siberian Traps eruptions were directly responsible for the Permian–Triassic mass extinction 250 million years ago.

A recent hypothesis put forward is that the volcanism triggered the growth of Methanosarcina, a microbe that spewed enormous amounts of methane... altering the Earth's carbon cycle.

This extinction event, also called the Great Dying, affected all life on Earth, and is estimated to have killed about 95% of all species living at the time"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberian_Traps

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by zerealshadowban on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:20AM (#17705453)
What specific baseline do you pick, and why? are there multiple variables involved in that "baseline"? have these variables changed over the 10k years preceding the Industrial Revolution? together or separately? what about these same variables over the last 200k years?
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by snikeris on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @08:23AM (#17705808)
Good questions. You also have to consider the variables that have changed since the Industrial Revolution. There are more people on earth to feed and provide a modern standard of living. We should work to reduce the costs on the planet for these things, but we can't eschew the progress we've made in order to return to some arbitrary baseline.

See: ecomodernism

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by zerealshadowban on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:31AM (#17706376)
Yes, one would most likely have followup questions once the baseline and its variables are made explicit.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by dwc on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:47PM (#17708264)
> One question I have is how sequestered the undersea carbon really is

Depends on how you interpret "sequestered". In the sense that it's locked away somewhere for a long time, like organic matter frozen into tundra, it's not very sequestered. But as long as there's lots of seaweed there'll be a lot of carbon taken up. Even though individual plants may die and release their carbon on a relatively short timeline, new growth will take up carbon.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by drubio on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:12AM (#17706758)
> In this case, the paper is suggesting that seaweed grows much faster in response to raised CO2, and then sequesters some of that carbon underwater.

Makes you wonder about news like this seaweed deluge in the Caribbean and how it's related to an increase in CO2

"In 2011 it was the first time we'd seen it...says Professor Hazel Oxenford, an expert in fisheries biology and management at the University of the West Indies...It came as a complete shock and no-one had a clue what to do with it."

"For us, the worst year we had for sargassum still remains 2015'..says Carla Daniel of Barbados Sea Turtle Project"

"Now it is happening again and everything suggests 2018 could be the worst year yet."

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-45044513

https://www.riviera-maya-news.com/first-seaweed-barrier-to-b...

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by kokey on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:15PM (#17708507)
Also reminds me of Richard Lindzen's Iris hypothesis, which suggest that temperature increases in the tropics will reduce cirrus clouds and thus let more heat escape from the atmosphere.

Lindzen and his theories are controversial, but I do think there may not have been enough focus on possible negative feedback mechanisms like this.

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by bjourne on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:50PM (#17708833)
But that would also mean that much more sunlight would hit the surface of the earth and not be reflected by those clouds.
Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:31AM (#17706944)
> Gaia theory suggests that the world is full of these stabilizing systems

Doesn’t it go considerably further, into almost suggesting the Earth is a spiritual or conscious entity?

Re:Seaweed could be scrubbing more carbon from the atmospher... by ghostbrainalpha on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:21PM (#17709711)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaia_hypothesis

No.

If it did, then it wouldn't be a theory, it would just be a religious belief.

Although, I would agree that many of the people working on the theory, would privately believe something like that.