News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by thaumasiotes on Monday August 06, 2018 @09:22PM (#17703220)
Being underground also protects you from excessive heat, excessive cold, wind, rain, and snow.

Being underground won't protect you from the noise of the mechanisms, but neither do the walls and roof of a train. Being on a train is loud.

Large crowds will cause heat within the system that will likely need to be managed, but -- like the noise -- this is equally true of trains.

How are any of those things an advantage of trains over a system of underground walkways?

Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by nine_k on Monday August 06, 2018 @10:13PM (#17703423)
I just happen to ride a lot of above-ground trains. E.g. much of the New York City subway goes above ground, sometimes pretty high, in Brooklyn and Queens. Same applies to quite a few cities (e.g. London and Moscow, off the top of my head).

But okay, let's imagine out underground walkway. Since it's underground, you can't walk on and off where you want; you only walk off where there's way up to the ground. This eliminates much of the allure of the system. Now you want to plan ahead and be ready to get off when you're next to the exit. If you missed your exit, you have to move to the next exit, or maybe cross the tunnel and go to the band of the opposite direction, and walk back a bit.

Please notice how the low-speed bands then need to run the whole length of the tunnel, adding little to the carrying capacity: few people want to travel at the speed of walking when traveling at the speed of a train is a few meters across.

If we let only the faster band(s) through the length of the tunnel, and limit the slower bands to the exit areas (pretty long and wide), we'll face the problem of walls: our band is moving fast, and nothing separates it from the walls. So we sort of need inner walls on the band. But they need doors to allow people in and out in the exit areas. And the doors need to be shut when the band is in the tunnel. It starts to look like a... train? Only an endless train with a peculiar way of boarding.

This endless train also has a downside: if anything goes wrong, the whole band/train has to stop, it cannot be re-routed. What if we segment the band into individually routable parts? Only then they'll have to stop at exit areas to allow safe getting on / off them.

Well, we have reinvented the subway.

Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by thaumasiotes on Monday August 06, 2018 @10:56PM (#17703583)
What does anything in this "response" have to do with heat, cold, wind, rain, snow, or noise?
Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by rfrey on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:27PM (#17703673)
Why did you put the word response in quotes?
Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by nine_k on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:03PM (#17709558)
"I just happen to ride a lot of above-ground trains" implies trains being exposed to wind, rain, snow, cold, and heat. Same would apply directly to passengers if the moving walk bands were above-ground.
Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by thaumasiotes on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:40PM (#17703715)
To imply that nine_k's non sequitur comment doesn't deserve the term "response", in that it doesn't actually respond to anything I said. Why is it posted under my comment?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes

Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by baud147258 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:26AM (#17704968)
>Being underground won't protect you from the noise of the mechanisms, but neither do the walls and roof of a train. Being on a train is loud.

More recent trains can be quite protected from mechanism noises. The line I'm taking more often has received brand-new trains and I usually don't hear the noise.

Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by mwilliaams on Monday August 06, 2018 @10:05PM (#17703392)
Trains aren't (all) loud. I just rode an Amtrak yesterday. It was surprisingly quiet.
Re:Why does it take so long to mend an escalator? (2002) by Symbiote on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:04AM (#17704388)
Tight curves tend to be loud, as is old track, or track that isn't welded into very long lengths. Locomotives are quieter than having motors on each carriage.

In much of Europe that makes trains quiet, except metro trains with tight curve.

People excluded, I think non -metro trains are usually quieter than cars.

I've only used one train in the US, which ran on jointed (not welded) track so made the 'clickety clack' noise, but presumably that varies and the North East is better.