News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by whatever1 on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:50AM (#17698672)
Bloody hell, this processor has more cores than the dual socket Xeon HPCs that my lab bought 2 years ago. Amazing. Honest question: Isn't the memory throughput an issue when you try to feed 32 hungry processors?
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by LeifCarrotson on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:18PM (#17698971)
Threadripper uses quad-channel DDR4-2666 memory. That gets you 80 GB/s memory bandwidth, which is possible because the processor sits in an enormous 4094-pin TR4 socket. Your Xeons were probably in 2011 pin sockets with DDR3-1866 resulting in 70 GB/s memory bandwidth. One Threadripper has more than double the pin count and slightly more total memory bandwidth than your dual Xeon machine.

Also, your the Intel setup has a 25 GB/s QPI bus between the processors. Threadripper runs an Infinity Fabric bus, with 42 GB/s between each die internally (aggregate 170 GB/s). While a couple of those internal dies are not directly connected to the memory, you should have little trouble sharing meals among those hungry processors.

Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by aeleos on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:42PM (#17699231)
Actually with this release threadripper 2 will support DDR4-2933 which should increase the memory bandwith and the throughput of the infinity fabric if I'm not mistaken (I am pretty sure infinity fabric runs at the ram speed)
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by dragontamer on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:52PM (#17699340)
Most people overclock RAM using XMP settings and hit 3200 MT/s easily (which also overclocks the infinity fabric).

I've seen some people hit 3466MT/s on higher-end more expensive RAM on AMD's 12nm stuffs (Ryzen 2). So that's probably the practical limit.

3200 MT/s on Hynix dies is probably a reasonable expectation.

Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by floatboth on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:55PM (#17701167)
> enormous 4094-pin TR4 socket

A lot of these pins aren't used on TR, since you only get half the memory controllers you'd have with EPYC

Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by LeifCarrotson on Monday August 06, 2018 @04:39PM (#17701602)
That's true. A staggering number of them are power delivery to start with - you don't waste anywhere near half the socket by dropping 4 memory controllers (!) but yeah, it's not EPYC.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by stingraycharles on Monday August 06, 2018 @01:04PM (#17699458)
Do you know whether Threadripper is affected by NUMA issues? Otherwise this could be an additional selling point for applications that need a lot of memory (e.g. databases, where you do not want the memory latency to be unpredictable depending upon which socket you are running on)
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by nimish on Monday August 06, 2018 @01:10PM (#17699514)
It is. Only 1/2 of the dies are connected directly to memory controllers.

For actual production workloads you want EPYC which has a memory controller for each die, meaning it's 8 channel.

Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by wbl on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:29PM (#17700904)
Depends on the arithmetic intensity. Higher intensity means less memory bandwidth needed to keep the cores happily crunching.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by elihu on Monday August 06, 2018 @06:57PM (#17702497)
For what it's worth, Broadwell E5v4 Xeons (which have been out a little over 2 years) use a 2011-3 socket and support DDR4-2400.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by Symmetry on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:59AM (#17698747)
Well, it's got four fairly fast memory channels but yes, you'll probably tend to be more memory limited with this guy - though the 64 MB of L3 should help in many cases.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by valarauca1 on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:01PM (#17698775)
For TR kind of. In the newer models only half the cores have direct access to a DDR channel. This shows in memory bounded benchmarks, but Epyc (server line) elevates this problem by have 8 (!!) memory channels, instead of the consumer TR’s 4.

Ultimately it depends on how cache friendly your workload is.

The 32c/64t is kind of a marketting gimmick selling binned Eypcs. If your doing memory bound HPC consider the 16c/32t model for roughly equal performance at a lower price.

Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by floatboth on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:59PM (#17701192)
EPYC fixes the problem by having 8 channels. All cores have direct access to DDR.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by deaddodo on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:07PM (#17700648)
Do we know if the 16c TR (2950x) will be full bandwidth or not? I'm assuming it'll still be halved due to die count/arrangement?
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by opencl on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:17PM (#17700778)
2950X is using two dies with 2 memory channels each, basically an update of the original Threadripper with Zen+ dies.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by deaddodo on Monday August 06, 2018 @04:34PM (#17701553)
That's what I was hoping to hear. Thanks!
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by CitizenKane on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:03PM (#17698796)
It's the unfortunate downside to these. Two of the dies don't have direct access to memory, but it seems like AMD didn't want to do a refresh of the pinouts and force socket updates. I suspect this will be left for the Zen 2 version of Threadripper. That being said, I imagine in most circumstances the performance should still be pretty good.
Re:The AMD Threadripper 2 Teaser: Pre-Orders Start Today, Up... by adreamingsoul on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:59AM (#17698744)
Yes, hopefully the motherboard manufactures take that seriously.