News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tox project by snvzz on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:31PM (#17692405)
Well, decentralized makes the whole push thing nontrivial.

Not that I understand IM on mobile. I'd rather use email.

Re:The Tox project by arendtio on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:10PM (#17693247)
The decentralization aspect is not the problem. XMPP for example is also decentralized but has quite good mobile support. The problem with tox seems to be that it is peer-to-peer. So the servers are missing which could buffer all those events for the clients.
Re:The Tox project by snvzz on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:02PM (#17694045)
>The decentralization aspect is not the problem. XMPP for example is also decentralized but has quite good mobile support.

XMPP is federated. Having servers make things easier.

Tox is full p2p, there's no servers.

Re:The Tox project by erk__ on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:31PM (#17694147)
Is that not more a difference between distributed and decentralized then, such as git is a distributed system even though it needs a central server in most use cases.
Re:The Tox project by arendtio on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:42AM (#17695808)
Here is my shot at defining various terms in this context:

- Centralized: Centralized networks have one central point which controls the network. That doesn't have to be a single server sometimes it is just that there is just one company controlling the network (e.g. WhatsApp).

- Decentralized: Is the opposite of 'centralized' meaning there is more than one central point. So all following types are 'decentralized'.

- Distributed: In general terms, it means that the network is (more or less evenly) distributed upon all participants. All participants have the same role and responsibility. There are various kinds of distributed networks. Git for example stores a full copy of all information in every node. Distributed Hash Tables use a different approach where every node is responsible for one explicit part of the information to store.

- Peer-to-peer (p2p): Is one form of a distributed network, which works (in general) without servers. So all the participants connect directly to each another (Tox).

- Federated: Is sometimes called a 'distributed network of centralized networks'. Two popular examples are e-mail and XMPP. All participant use their own centralized server, but that server cooperates with other servers to transfer messages across the network. Sometimes their implementations make a distinction between client-to-server and server-to-server protocols.

In general, the more centralized a network is, the easier it is to control. This can be good when it comes to spam, but also bad when it comes to censorship.

Re:The Tox project by snvzz on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:43PM (#17694192)
Federated is like email. There's foo.com and a bar.org email servers, users at foo.com can talk with users at bar.org just fine. XMPP works that way.

Distributed means there seriously aren't any servers. Addresses in tox are just public keys, and they're in a global namespace. The network is a distributed hash table formed by peers (the "clients"). There's no central point of failure.

Re:The Tox project by namibj on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:18PM (#17693870)
There is nothing against you taking toxcore and adding a push wrapper+app UI to it. Seems like you could make at least the app side of it non-free, if you'd wish to do so.
Re:The Tox project by nyolfen on Sunday August 05, 2018 @02:57PM (#17692842)
yeah, i don't disagree, i realize it's difficult to engineer around. but it's a pretty big mark against it in terms of wide adoption.