My experience with the internet is that people just can't help themselves to point out when somebody is wrong - man or woman. Sometimes going as far to write what could be considered full essays complete with citations. Its just another anecdote but I don't think its at all obvious its because of gender. People just like feeling smart.
> Maybe women look at math problems differently than men.
> You are the goat!
I'm sure there were many others.
I believe the OP is right, but providing uncontroversial evidence of that is hard. You need a thorough classification of the feedback in a number of sufficiently comparable cases, involving both men and women, to provide hard evidence. And even with hard evidence in hand the conclusions could be ignored; cf. climate change.
This isn't a debate that can be settled by rational evidence.
It's just how the world works. We can all pretend like we don't have uncontroversial evidence and that we'll never know if her identity as a female really affected the response. That's pretty much the status quo. Or we can not be blind and see what's happening right in front of us.
You can actually use this to your advantage. There are plenty of knowledgeable people who would rarely or never respond usefully to a request for assistance who are quite happy to spend time pointing out your errors (and flaws) if you post something incorrect.
I'm honestly not sure if this is a dark pattern. Is it wrong to take advantage of the negative behaviors of poorly socialized people?
As always, there's a relevant XKCD cartoon:
https://xkcd.com/386/ ("Duty Calls")
Ascribing this all to gender seems like too broad of a brush, and with very little evidence to back it up either.
There were likely a multitude of motivations for people to write in and correct her, but isn't it natural for us to want to take someone down a peg when they are advertised as "all that" (in this case - smartest person alive), and they seem obviously wrong about something?
This is a statistics problem that many people who have had statistics training have been wrong about.
Seems like the setup for a perfect storm.
That exists in any field, sadly. Top draft picks are scrutinized every year in sports. Every presidential gaffe gets its own 'mightier than thou' correction article. Anecdotally, I knew a mechanic who couldn't wait to read ClickNClack to find any little mistake and claim superiority.
Based on what? I hear this only brought up in the media reaction of "men try and prove smart woman wrong!"
Secondly, what is the implied norm that the author wants - you can’t disagree with someone of a different gender who has a higher IQ than you?
But it's not just about gender. Consider the racism faced by so many Black mathematicians and scientists. And Indians, such as Jagadish Chandra Bose. Even Srinivasa Ramanujan, before his genius was recognized in the UK.
But recall that Black men got human rights in the US before women did. And that corporations also got them before women did. So it's arguable that sexism runs deeper than racism.
On the other hand, I cringe at "smartest woman". What does that really mean? It's like describing some hugely multidimensional thing with a few numbers. All we know is that she did extremely well at whatever tests were used. And we also know that many such tests are culturally biased.
"It was nothing to do with her being a woman!" they will cry, ignoring the unconscious bias that led them to such an angrily disproportionate response in the first place.
Also, more people probably would have second-guessed their intuition, at least for a moment, and perhaps there would have been a few less letters.
In fact, I'd say the zeitgeist of casting everything in an identity politics narrative is in the same exact vein. It's a nice, simple, and wrong answer, but it does sort out who has committed to the group (ie religion).
I'm certainly willing to posit that women are quite often on the receiving end due to many men immediately writing them off as lower status (likely in an attempt to keep from sliding further down the scale themselves), but I'm not signing up to drink divisive kool-aid that ultimately obscures the problem.
The "Gamers are Dead" articles were authored by many different journalists, not just women. Perpetuating the narrative that it was an attack on women is exactly they type of behavior that keeps Gamergate alive.
The circling the wagons of journalists defending this poor reporting and actually attacking gamers is what Gamergate was about.
It was nothing to do with ethics anyway, that was just the excuse. How ethical is it to participate in a sustained campaign of harassment?
But look at the real story here: thousands of men going out of their way to write letters- not quick 5 minute emails, but paper letters with envelopes and stamps- to tell a woman she was wrong. If it had been a man writing the article, would it have gotten the same reaction? I doubt it.
In my view, this is the crux of the gender problems we see in tech today. Certainly not as strong (one hopes) but certainly the same weird psychological problem that so many of us seem to have to some degree requiring men to tell women when they're wrong, but not care when men are. 'GamerGate' and the various witch hunts around that topic is a great example. It's fine if a man sucks at his job, but if a woman does and it's a role that society has labeled 'for men', suddenly it's an emotion-driven attack that must be defended vigorously.
We need to see this and watch for it if we're ever going to end it.