News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Friday August 03, 2018 @03:57PM (#17683093)
Criminal to ensure that regular citizens of America and NY can actually drive down the street?

These taxes are basically a way to exclude vast numbers of people from the city and embolden systems that cause economic asymmetry.

A 'pure market' solution would involve the streets being largely empty save a fleet of limos paid for by a tiny fraction of the population.

A lot of New Yorkers would be happy to pay a price to make sure that you can't drive your car anywhere near them.

How about: every few avenues and streets make them 100% public transit and have tons of 'no driver' trams running all the time so that anyone can get anywhere really fast? Get rid of all large cars? And cabs are not a particularly efficient use of space.

Besides, living in NYC already comes with so many de-facto taxes ...

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by jacobmoe on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:12PM (#17683226)
If inequality is your concern, guaranteeing that everyone sit in gridlock together is about the worst possible way you could go about it. Taxing people who want to drive and using that money on public transportation is an obviously more effective way of addressing "economic asymmetry", particularly in NYC where driving is already not the norm. Driving isn't a right, especially not in NYC. You could apply your logic to anything and get the same result: scarcity.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by bilbo0s on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:28PM (#17683355)
I agree.

Only I think the tax should be indexed, and increase semi-exponentially based on the price of your vehicle.

That would satisfy both sides of the argument. The wealthy would pay WAY more for their ego-mobiles. The poor and middle class would be paying next to nothing for their Honda Civics. And all the money collected would be made available to improve public transit.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CydeWeys on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:59PM (#17683561)
The price of the vehicle doesn't matter; a Lexus takes up as much space as a Sentra. Vehicles should be taxed on factors that matter. In Manhattan, that means they should be paying congestion charges for using limited roadway, parking fees for using limited parking space, and emissions charges relative to emissions. Yes, that means that a "luxury" Tesla would be taxed less than a Sentra. I don't care. I don't have a car at all, but I do have lungs. Same for most Manhattanites. Get these gasoline and especially diesel burners outta here.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by bilbo0s on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:24PM (#17683750)
Look, there is a congestion tax for people too, only we implement it as "rent".

Guess what, you live in a large, crappy place in the worst parts of the Bronx, you pay less than the guy who lives in the tiny apartment in the luxury building in Manhattan. The small apartment likely even uses, less water, less power, less heat, and fewer city services like police and fire.

But so what?

You know why we do it that way? Because it only makes sense to do it that way.

Sorry, but of course it should be based on price. All things of this sort are.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by closeparen on Saturday August 04, 2018 @01:21AM (#17685492)
The community in most urban areas has soundly rejected market allocation of housing, at least for new construction.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by econ4all on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:47PM (#17683479)
The problem with these "progressive" modifications is that they complicate a simple idea, add points of contention and ultimately kill the whole thing.

Just pass the tax in it's simplest form and then see if further adjustment is needed, the perfect being the enemy of the good and what not.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by bilbo0s on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:03PM (#17683592)
There really can be no points of contention here. I mean, everyone is paying the same tax as you, providing they drive the same car. You own a stretch limo, fine, so long as you want to pay the tax. And everyone else owning that limo would pay the same tax as you. You own a tiny Civic or Corolla, fine, you pay the same tax as everyone else who owns that tiny car of yours.

I mean really, what's to argue? You could argue whether there should be a tax at all I suppose. But not much else.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by jacobmoe on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:55PM (#17683532)
I agree in general, but think you might have it backwards in this particular case. Simple is better, but if the only way to ensure it gets through is to make it more complicated, then let's add the modifications.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Saturday August 04, 2018 @04:25PM (#17688308)
Making the tax different based on the type of car is not the kind of 'complexity' that risks the nature of the tax. In fact, that's pretty easy.

Getting 'right of way', building permits, hiring firms, planning massive construction projects involving 'new technology' etc. etc - this is 'complicated' beyond the threshold that I would trust the NYC government.

But some kind of tax on cars is within feasibility.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by econ4all on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:57PM (#17683556)
Gotcha.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CalRobert on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:57PM (#17683548)
We charge "congestion tax" on human beings in the form of rent. Are you opposed to that? I'd rather some of the space used on hulking metal boxes be used for humans instead.

Also the streets would get plenty of use. By people. Like we used streets for thousands of years before people in autos showed up and almost literally said "stop walking in MY street or I will kill you" and we decided it was OK, for some reason.

http://www.thisiscolossal.com/2018/05/footage-of-city-life-i...

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Saturday August 04, 2018 @04:26PM (#17688311)
Roads are public spaces, living spaces are not.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CalRobert on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:23PM (#17692032)
I was referring to streets, not roads. Also, automobiles are an appropriation of public space for private use (parking, denying others use of the street while you're driving on it, etc.) so I hardly see that as a counterexample.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by pteredactyl on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:06PM (#17683179)
Let's give the state more money to solve all our problems! They have a great track record too!
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:20PM (#17683297)
Ok then take away the 'state run' subway in American cities and see what happens? Or take away the 'state managed' roads and highways?

The state is not hugely efficient, but when it comes to these things, it's largely construction unions and the not-overtly-but-kinda-corrupt construction firms etc.. Doing any city work costs gazillions unfortunately.

But some forms of public transit (subways, maybe not buses) are as priceless as the highway system.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by pteredactyl on Friday August 03, 2018 @09:08PM (#17684830)
I don't think it'd make much a difference. But I didn't say take away all money from the state...

Funny how that's the knee-jerk these days.

From my experience Roads and subways are not being adequately maintained. At least in the big cities. But I do know every few years we pass a multi-billion dollar referendum for the BART that goes to... mostly pensions.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by chrisdhoover on Saturday August 04, 2018 @12:01AM (#17685313)
And when you point that out you get abuse. There is a very cover your ears and chant nah nah nah I can’t hear you! Then they counter that baby boomers are shit.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by TheCoelacanth on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:54PM (#17683947)
I agree. We should get rid of all state spending on roads and simply not allow people to drive in Manhattan.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by pteredactyl on Friday August 03, 2018 @09:06PM (#17684822)
Maybe we should. Open it up to the market. What's it cost now, 5 million a block of road?

For the record, I did not say take away all money from the state, but I understand why you'd think that.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by JumpCrisscross on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:02PM (#17683148)
Why not just apply the congestion tax to paid drivers while removing street-side parking? I don’t want to live in a city where there is zero chance of block-to-block motorised transport.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by tomatotomato37 on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:18PM (#17683274)
Yes, because taxing minimum wage drivers in dying industries and only allowing car ownership to those who live in million dollar condos with underground parking is the perfect way to improve the lives of the common New Yorker
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by rubbingalcohol on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:05PM (#17683169)
How about don't live in a big fucking city if you don't like a lot of noise?
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by jacobmoe on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:14PM (#17683242)
People who live in big cities are a lot like people who live anywhere - they generally try to fix problems and improve the place they live in. Some noise is inevitable. Excessive noise is a problem that can be fixed.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by rubbingalcohol on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:22PM (#17683314)
Given that the top complaint filed relates to construction noise, I can't imagine a way to fix that unless they don't allow construction.

I live near an airport and have neighbors who are always bitching about airplane noise. I'm not sure what they expected when they bought a house next to an airport.

Filing these sorts of issues under "user error."

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by codyb on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:16PM (#17683256)
People enjoy discussing potential solutions to problems and weighing the varying contrasting viewpoints presented in other comments.

This is a large community filled with engineers, researchers, and folk from all sorts of other interesting backgrounds who like to solve problems.

It's only natural that the comments on such an article would include such comments, so I guess my question is, why did you feel the need to post that valueless comment?

Did you think GP didn't know he has the freedom to move?

Anyways, as for the article, the huge influx of ride sharing vehicles has slowed traffic something like 15% in some parts of Manhattan. The trains are a disaster which they need to fix and expand.

I support taxing more heavily ride sharing services as they've already squeaked out of the medalion system and are clogging the roads. I'm not sure how you accomplish. Or limits to the numbers of cars riding around at any given time.

Expanding and fixing the MTA is a huge project that should be started immediately. Crippling the nations largest city with a terrible public transit option is death by a thousand cuts for a place like New York. Everytime someone can't get where they want or outright chooses not to the businesses they'd have visite suffer.

We should tackle this issue head on and from several angles to encourage the efficient transportation of citizens through the metropolis and allow them some solace at times.

Constructions a big one in terms of noise, it just goes on forever too. I'm not sure there's a way to solve that and the city needs a bit more construction to dampen housing prices. If there was a decent way to encourage actually affordable housing developments that'd be fantastic.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by rubbingalcohol on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:25PM (#17683337)
My issue here is that the "problem" as posed is stupid and so all "solutions" are trivial and irrelevant, particularly the suggestion to tax everything until only super rich people can afford to drive. That's the neoliberal fantasy of a "public/private partnership" at its finest.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CalRobert on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:00PM (#17683567)
How about don't live in a big fucking city if you don't like a lot of congestion?
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CalRobert on Saturday August 04, 2018 @02:40AM (#17685690)
To clarify, if you care about pleasant motoring and not pleasant walking, the city may not be for you.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by rbranson on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:14PM (#17683244)
I’m pretty sure the traffic as well as the cost of parking and bridge tolls already excludes vast numbers of people from driving into the city.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by CydeWeys on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:02PM (#17683581)
There are no bridge tolls on most of the NYC bridges -- just the bridges and tunnels to Manhattan.

Unfortunately driving still isn't nearly expensive because way too many people are doing it. Raise the tolls more and get rid of all the free on-street parking while we're at it. All the side streets are full of cars that are only moved twice a week for street-sweeping and it makes no damn sense. Make people pay the actual cost of keeping a car in the city and there'll be a lot fewer of them, and the majority of people will be better off.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by jacobmoe on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:19PM (#17683280)
I sold my car after I had to move my registration and I saw how much I'd be paying for insurance. Luckily, it's New York, where you don't _need_ a car. I just can't understand how anyone is against this, unless you personally enjoy driving in the city for some reason. There are too many cars on the road, in other words, there is a scarcity of space in the city. Scarcity can always be traced back to the same thing: prices are too low.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:24PM (#17683324)
"Scarcity can always be traced back to the same thing: prices are too low."

And prices (i.e. the supply curve and the demand curve) are function of relative economic power.

If you want to sell the roads to the highest bidder, the 'expensive cost' of driving you had will go up 10x and you will never be able to drive in NYC because it will be a privilege of a class of very few individuals that you will never be a part of.

Like I say enough people would be happy to pay a price to make sure you can't drive near them.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by jacobmoe on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:40PM (#17683435)
> people would be happy to pay a price to make sure you can't drive near them

And I would be happy to receive their money and use it to fix and expand the subway.

This is obviously a larger discussion of ideology. I'm a left-of-center liberal and generally don't enjoy arguing from the right, but there are economic facts that I find to be just inescapable.

Of course I _want_ everyone to be able to drive whenever the want, but history and simple logic show that when you have a state of scarcity, societies need to pick one of two choices: higher prices or rationing. Rationing, in this case, either means the government telling you when you can or can't drive (I recall that Bogota had a system where license plates ending in odd or even numbers get to drive on certain days of the week), or just letting everyone sit in traffic, the equivalent of the bread line. It just seems screamingly obvious to me that taking money from rich people to drive in the city and using that money to fund the MTA will lead to the best outcomes.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:40PM (#17683855)
I don't see that it's 'ideological' to have accessible, regular public spaces.

Also, the opportunity for great efficiency in transport ... either public or private I don't care that much as long as it works well.

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by TheCoelacanth on Friday August 03, 2018 @05:57PM (#17683968)
Right, there should be accessible public spaces: sidewalks, buses and subways. The kind that can actually be provided in amounts sufficient to allow everyone to use it. Roads are inherently too limited in space to be usable by everyone in Manhattan. The people who get the privilege of using that space should be paying a fair price for it.
Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by sonnyblarney on Friday August 03, 2018 @09:08PM (#17684827)
"Roads are inherently too limited in space to be usable by everyone in Manhattan."

This is simply not true.

With a little bit of intelligence things can be changed. Such as: allowing only smaller cars, getting rid of taxis or limos, having very fast 'above ground' public-ish transport etc..

Re:New York Becomes the City That Never Shuts Up by TheCoelacanth on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:10PM (#17685164)
No, that is pure fantasy. Manhattan is already insanely congested with only 25% of commuters traveling by car. There is no way you could possibly get four times that number into the same amount of space.