News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by dagw on Thursday October 07, 2010 @10:12AM (#1767868)
Are you sure you're not mixing together minimalist and frugal? I have an acquaintance whom I'd consider very minimalist, however everything she does buy is top of the line and very expensive. When she goes out to eat, it's Michelin star restaurants. When she travels she considers 4 start hotels slumming it. At the end of the day minimalist and frugal or pretty orthogonal.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by city41 on Thursday October 07, 2010 @10:14AM (#1767877)
Frugal implies you are sacrificing quality or desire in the name of money. Minimalist implies you find joy in simpler things and a simpler life and therefore don't need or even want outlandish luxury.

I'm just as content sleeping at a Best Western as I am at a 5 star hotel. My Scion gets me to the grocery store just as well as a BMW would, etc. I'm not sacrificing anything, I simply don't feel a need for excessive luxury.

And I agree with the OP of this thread. Thanks to my minimalist lifestyle I too have plenty of leeway to do whatever I want for quite some time. It's a great feeling.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by roel_v on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:11AM (#1768091)
"Scion gets me to the grocery store just as well as a BMW would"

This is not a good example of minimalism and in contradiction with your earlier statement that "Frugal implies you are sacrificing quality or desire in the name of money" (I infer you were contrasting with minimalism here)

A BMW is a lot higher quality than cheap cars, not necessarily 'excessive luxury'. It can be simple, depending on the configuration. One can find minimalist joy in a very expensive BMW. 'Just getting to the grocery store' is not about minimalism, it's about frugality. It's not because something is expensive that it's 'excessive'. Actually simple, high-quality products are often more expensive then cheap trinkets. To have a lot of leeway, one leads a frugal lifestyle to save money. A minimalist lifestyle isn't necessarily a cheap lifestyle.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by city41 on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:41AM (#1768215)
I suppose we could debate this all day. My point is to me the luxury of a car is not very important. Indeed it's not important at all. I feel other people also feel that way, but feel like they "should" buy a BMW just because they can afford it. I'm not sacrificing anything here because the extra luxury I don't have and the status it would represent are both irrelevant to me.

I've made no real sacrifice with the Scion. It's made by Toyota and is a very high quality, dependable car. It will serve me well for many years. That's all a car needs to be in my eyes.

For things that are important to me, sure, I buy the best I can afford. But only a very small number of things are truly important to me. I suppose my definition of minimalism is just truly getting what you need, nothing more or less. I feel no need to "keep up with the Jonses", and overall just don't feel compelled to "be a good consumer".

I agree a minimalist lifestyle is not necessarily a cheaper lifestyle. I totally agree with that. But I do feel a minimalist lifestyle can be cheaper if your desires and needs just happen to work out that way, which in my case I generally feel they do.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by roel_v on Thursday October 07, 2010 @01:05PM (#1768488)
Yes, it boils down to a definition matter, which isn't very interesting.

I try to live my life in a 'minimalist' way, because I feel less clutter makes for a more serene life. Still, making money is quite important to me, if only for the security it represents. On the other hand I also sometimes wonder if I'm spending enough to optimize life joy; I drive a small Citroen Saxo but I'm regularly annoyed by the small amount of space in it, and the inconvenience that it has only 3 doors. I guess my point is that it's surprisingly hard to walk the line between stinginess (a generally negative trait) and minimalism (a generally positive trait).

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by potatolicious on Thursday October 07, 2010 @04:32PM (#1769387)
I'm reading a design book right now, and one of the interesting concepts it brings up is that people work better when they enjoy the tools they are using.

BMW drivers are often happier (driving) than other drivers, and more relaxed (and by extension, a bit safer) in their cars than drivers of other brands. The effect of satisfaction, quality, and usability is not well understood but we do know it's significant.

I'm an amateur photographer, and I do know that I take better pictures on some cameras than others. On the el-cheapo digital SLRs, I find that the small size, the poorer button placement, the lack of a satisfying weight to the contraption, etc, all lends itself to annoyance. A quality camera feels right in the hand, has just the right weight to it, and feels good to use, and that does impact the things you do with it.

A lot of what people in this thread would qualify as "excessive luxury" IMHO is not as irrelevant and excessive as one would think at first glance.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by slantyyz on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:32PM (#1772201)
While I do agree with your points in general, it's important to keep in mind that everything is relative.

On the point about the cameras. If the photographer has a decent level of talent, then the gear definitely matters. Less so if they don't.

I know a lot of gadgety people who like to show off their expensive cameras. Their photos, however, aren't worth showing off at all - it wouldn't have mattered if they used a 5DMK2 or a lowly Rebel XSi. Boring is still boring no matter how sharp the picture is.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by potatolicious on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:11PM (#1772356)
Indeed. That's part of my own logic for myself when considering "luxury" aspects of things. I'm not an avid driver at all, and it's not at all a big part of my life - so if I were to buy a car, "good enough" may very well be just that.

Whereas if I drove every day, and would spend a lot of time in the driver seat, I'd be much more inclined to buy something nicer (as opposed to merely functional).

In this case, photography is important to me, and I spend a lot of time doing it - so it's important that I have a tool that not only works well, but feels satisfying to use. After all, it's not a very good hobby if I'm constantly being frustrated by my equipments' usability.

Likewise, it's important for me to have a really nice coffee mug - given that it's part of my daily routine and I spend a lot of time interacting with it.

What I see is that many people over-optimize and fail to account for this effect - and they skimp on things that they do use heavily, resulting in a quality of life loss that they're probably not even aware of. (e.g., daily commuters, people who spend tens of hours in a car weekly, but driving a "good enough" beater, when they can easily afford better... or hackers who buy cheap/poorly made keyboards/mice even though they spend hours with it every single day).

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by elblanco on Thursday October 07, 2010 @04:08PM (#1769291)
"I suppose we could debate this all day."

In other words, the concept of minimalism is multi-faceted, complex, full of myriad options, and above all...not a minimal concept.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by gaius on Thursday October 07, 2010 @10:51AM (#1768010)
OK but minimalist could also be a Patek Phillippe Calatrava instead of an all-singing all-dancing Casio Pathfinder...
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by hugh3 on Thursday October 07, 2010 @06:47PM (#1769829)
In other words, if you feel like congratulating yourself on your minimalism, you can pretty much justify anything as minimalist.

Personally I'd say that the minimalist wristwatch option is none at all. I don't think I'd be happier with no wristwatches, though. While my wristwatches bring me only a minimal amount of pleasure, congratulating myself on my lack of wristwatches wouldn't bring me much pleasure either.

I prefer "vaguely appropriate scale"-ism to minimalism. No wristwatches is too few, ten is too many. Pick something in between and stop fretting.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by tome on Thursday October 07, 2010 @01:38PM (#1768660)
Very good point. Sometimes minimalism is a lot more expensive.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by fragmede on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:08AM (#1768081)
Minimalism implies the things you have are truly things you actually need, and not just the latest fashionable fad of the week.

If you're hosting client meetings, the Best Western isn't going have as nice a set of facilities as a 5-star hotel. If you're on a race track, your Scion sucks compared to a BMW, etc. You are sacrificing. The important point is you're cognizant of the sacrifices (a BMW time around a racetrack is irrelevant to your Scion getting you to the grocery store). A macbook pro is a luxury, but absolutely justifiable if you do development on it all day long.

Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by city41 on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:45AM (#1768229)
For sure, if I'm hosting client meetings then I have an honest need for the better facilities. But if I'm just going out of town and just need a place to crash, the Best Western is more than adequate.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by robryan on Thursday October 07, 2010 @10:49AM (#1767999)
I think in attempting to be frugal though some people can actually spend more. While the minimalist will get one of something and probably go for a good one to last the person being frugal might go for the cheapest one, or buy a set of cheap things covering themselves for bad quality, they may end up spending more in the long run when things don't last.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:25AM (#1768148)
I love some of the frugal websites that are completely focused on price. You get list after list of special offers where you can get stuff for next to nothing but it's all utter crud. Some items, however cheap, are a false economy.
Re:A minimalist lifestyle does not make you a better person by frossie on Thursday October 07, 2010 @02:54PM (#1768988)
At the end of the day minimalist and frugal or pretty orthogonal.

I think that is certainly true in the abstract, but I suspect in the average specific case minimalism correlates with saving money. For the average person, their biggest expense is their home. If you have less stuff and can comfortably live in a smaller place, there is a lot of saving there.

Also, there is the lifetime cost issue. One good screwdriver may be expensive, but probably compares well with 10 crappy screwdrives that wear down or break that you buy over many years.

I think the interesting part of the OP was the point that digitisation does enable a new kind of minimalism - one that does not require as much compromise as it did before. I can give up 10 bookscases worth of books without having to give up reading whatever I like, whenever I like. This was certainly not the case 30 years ago.