I understand that somewhere in a perfect universe, tech guys just make things right and money just flow in without those pesky marketing people ever involved. Unfortunately, in our universe if you don't do marketing and don't analyze user behavior your business is toast.
Standards & many applications that implemented them (including commercial) were attempted to be designed to make online computer use possible and beneficial. This is the domain of academics, committees, and concerned individuals creating the means of useful computing & communication, outside of parasitic desperation to inject unnecessary rent-seeking lock-ins into everybody's lives.
The average message posted to comp.lang.c before Eternal September was far batter than the average message posted to HN, Proggit, etc. But many of the former were written by academics, so you probably don't care.
It was extracted from tuition paid by undergraduate students and taxes paid by taxpayers.
And that money all eventually came from dirty capitalism.
And yes, it cost a lot of money to get online and/or host data back then, which was subsidized by piggybacking corporate and university internet presence. Nowadays it's dirt cheap to personally host & access tons of content, so there's even less need to monetize.
To that, all I can say is perhaps some regulation is required to level the playing field.
If the NY Times folds tomorrow due to bankruptcy, there are dozens of other papers where we can get the news. Their reporting is good, and I choose them over their competitors but losing them wouldn't be the end of news as we know it.
That's the case with most businesses---the marketing and sales are only needed to compete, whereas without them the product would still exist for consumers.
There's a sort of critical mass of "news" that can be made. We can't all be investigative journalists.
So whatever that would be here instead of the NYT might be different, it might not be worse. It could be just as good, just different.
Of course, it could be worse. It could be better. We can't know.
But you'd have to gut 1A to do it, and it would instantly be used for evil. Nope, just hell no.
Business just shouldn't be able to freely collect mountains of information. They can't be trusted to do it responsibly. Collecting data is a privilege and it can be revoked. If they insist on doing it, we'll find a way to avoid sending the data. If they lock us out for not sending data, we'll send fake data.
I'd go as far as to say that it isn't only unethical to collect this information, but that it's unethical not to take active measures not to share it.
In six months, the only thing we learned: half of the users that finish setting up don't continue to use the app. We could have learned that from server side logs without invading user privacy.
Another story: four employees of a large corporate running target marketing based on behaviour of customers logged in to their website.
Added revenue versus control: 60.000 yearly. Sub-0.1% conversation rates. The corp had been running these campaigns for at least five years.
My personal stories. Anecdata, I know.
There is SO MUCH BULLSHIT.
Edit: to clarify the first example, it's not a movie using the front facing camera, 'just' a screen grab