News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by rayiner on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:19AM (#17653863)
Do democratic politicians have some sort of training in maintaining the farce that more things should be handled by government, when governments in Illinois, California, New York, etc.--democratic strongholds where Republicans cannot be pointed to as the scapegoats--are on the verge of bankruptcy?

I don't think, deep down, republicans think the current system is better. They just don't trust whatever replaces it won't be much worse. It's easy to say "if we were just like <X European country> we could offer universal healthcare and also save money!" But <X European country> probably has trains that are vastly better than ours despite costing less to operate. They have schools vastly better than ours that they spend less money on. Clearly there is more to the equation.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by intended on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:21AM (#17653873)
It doesnt matter. These are just the general American talking points.

Fortunately since this is a global forum, people can point out that the situation in AMerica is farce.

The basic stats are just solid - every first world country does better.

You guys have the worst of all worlds, and because of America's prediliction for everything market oriented, and the absurd partisanship - you have no solutions, and are ok with people getting cured in the ER.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by richmarr on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:43AM (#17654158)
Not to mention the fact that companies can write off insurance contributions against tax, and individuals can recieve that benefit without paying income or payroll tax on it. In effect that's a subsidy in favour of the middle classes and 1% to the tune of "between $174 billion and $429 billion over a six-year period".

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/07/health/health-insurance-t...

(Edited to include the missing point about income/payroll)

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by harryh on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:49AM (#17654226)
You say this like it's some special provision in the tax code, but it's not. Companies pay taxes on profits, not revenue. And insurance contributions (like many many other things) are an expense that reduces profits.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by richmarr on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:56AM (#17654298)
Yep... thanks, wrote that too quickly, I'll update
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by harryh on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:01PM (#17654339)
Ah, I was wondering if you meant to mention that health care benefits are (in most cases) not taxable and I see with your edit that you did. I agree with you on that point. It's a big problem.

Interestingly, McCain proposed fixing this during the 2008 election and was slammed for it by Obama.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by andybak on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:22AM (#17653878)
Is it possible both accusations are valid? i.e. "A plague on both your houses"...

Maybe it's your political class that's broken.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by harryh on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:48AM (#17654209)
I think that is part of it. I also think a lot of it has to do with size & diversity.

- The US is ~4x more populous than Germany (most populous in Western Europe)

- The US is ~15x larger than France (largest in Western Europe)

- The US is significantly more racially diverse than any country in Europe which is a huge advantage in many ways but also comes with more challenging governance particularly when you factor in the US's legacy of slavery & racism towards blacks (~12% of the population).

- The US also has greater financial inequality (much, but not all of which is due to government policy of course)

I could list a few more bullet points, but you get the gist. The US is just bigger and more complicated that other places. It makes us harder to govern efficiently.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by improbable22 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:15PM (#17654449)
Quite a few US states are bigger than EU countries which manage to run their own decent systems. (e.g. NY: 19 million, Switzerland: 8 million.) What's the argument against letting them run it?

Maybe there have to be some federal ground rules. But having wider experimentation would seem like a good thing, for discovering good ways to run a system.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by harryh on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:24PM (#17654516)
It could work but you'd probably have at least a moderate free loader problem with it being so easy to move from state to state.

There would be nothing to prevent a healthy person from living in a low tax/no gov't health care state until they get sick and then moving to a high tax state/state paid for care.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by komali2 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:15PM (#17655002)
There would be as much to prevent that as exists today. Very few people actually move from their hometowns, no matter how bad things get.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by harryh on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:51PM (#17655337)
The issue is that a big % of medical expenses come from a small % of people. It would only take a relatively small number of these people moving to make a big difference in expenses. And it's the people with the highest expenses who would have the most incentive to move.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by komali2 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:24PM (#17655679)
Sounds like, if true (I was under the impression that a big % of medical cost is due to artificial cost inflation due to the existence of insurance companies), the people costing the system the most amount of money are the least able to move, because they're, you know, dying. Or have some other debilitating condition that requires them to stay with the doctors that know what's going on.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:52PM (#17656469)
You're slicing the expense on a different axis than he is. Stipulate any amount of overhead and overpricing due to a given health care regime (fully public and managed like the VA, public/private like Medicare, private insurance, whatever). Within that regime, a very small percentage of health care consumers will make up a disproportionate amount of the expense. It doesn't matter how you fund it or how efficiently you deliver it, because the disparity is on the demand side. 5% of BCBS TN's customers made up over 75% of their total expense!

Those customers are perfectly capable of moving. Many of them are simply chronically ill, with things like kidney disease. But anyone who's been on a plane in the US lately can tell you that the elderly have no trouble getting around, either.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by danharaj on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:23AM (#17653904)
Republicans in New York have had significant power in the Senate for quite some time.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by nicoburns on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:32AM (#17654010)
The European countries invest in public services. And have no qualms collecting taxes to pay for them...
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by brookhaven_dude on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:25AM (#17653927)
I wonder if you just proved his point by supporting Republican politicians.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by dnomad on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:30AM (#17653992)
You're really disconnected from reality of you think California and New York, the two most dynamic and wealthiest states that actually fund directly and indirectly most of the other states, are on the verge of bankruptcy. Try coming back to the real world and examining the facts. There's a very good reason why certain states are high tax and high growth while others are welfare operations that unfortunately can leverage their two senators into a kind of ransom business model.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:56PM (#17654801)
California and Illinois have two of the worst fiscal conditions in the country, ranked #43 and #49 (by GMU) among states respectively, based on cash on hand vs. immediate obligations, debt to income, and liabilities to assets. California's unfunded guaranteed pension obligations alone add up to almost half its personal income. Don't even ask about Illinois.

New York isn't much better. It's #39. New Jersey, home to a huge percentage of the NYC workforce, is #50!

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by dnomad on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:30PM (#17655740)
California is the 5th fastest growing state economy. This is despite already being the largest state economy by far. That is simply remarkable and to call such a state of affairs "verge of bankruptcy" is just stupid.

Further the noise around pension obligations is mostly meaningless alarmism from people who don't know any better. If California is on the verge of bankruptcy why is California's bond rating at AA-? Why is New York's bond rating is AA+? Why are investors all over the world, particularly sovereign wealth funds, in fact standing in line to loan money to these high-tax, high-growth US states? Ex-real estate and ex-China, these economies are in fact the engines of growth for pretty much the Western hemisphere.

We'll see how long it lasts though. The thesis here is that when you combine the nonsense alarmism around debt and the cherished American belief that governments can do no right you get a recipe for enormous underinvestment and malinvestment. And Americans are so disconnected from reality that they probably will vote for any idiot who starts crying about "fiscal responsibility" and cuts public investment in these economies.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:54PM (#17655944)
Those bond ratings are a measure of short-term solvency (if it heads off another unproductive exchange: the ratings agencies work with a very different of "long term" than GMU does). California does reasonably well (11th nationally) on that axis. We're talking about long-term structural solvency.

I don't understand what California's bond rating has to do with the impact of its unfunded pension obligations.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by dnomad on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:07PM (#17659352)
The idea that bond investors only care about "short-term solvency" and therefore ignore unfunded pension obligations doesn't make any sense at all. I don't even... Also this idea that California, the 5th largest economy in the world, is ranked "11th nationally" in terms of debt ratings doesn't make any sense. Nobody actually compares an economy like California (GDP 2.5T) with Arizona (GDP 2.5B). There's so much wrong here -- from the pure ideological nonsense that California is "on the verge of bankruptcy" to the idea that bond investors only think 6-10 years into the future -- that it's really not worth continuing this conversation. (It's also quite clear that the legion of downvoters, hard pressed to actually defend their ideological nonsense, can always just suppress the facts. So much for free speech uber alles.)
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:12PM (#17659370)
That's literally what a bond rating measures: whether a particular bond is likely to be repaid. A short-term bond is generally anything that comes to maturity before one year, and long-term is anything else.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by dnomad on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @01:46AM (#17660005)
> short-term bond is generally anything that comes to maturity before one year, and long-term is anything else.

Yeah that's now how any of this works. First, average muni bonds duration is 10+ years. Short-term debt is inherently safer than long-term debt but all investors will look far beyond a particular bond. Especially when dealing with sovereign entities who can't go bankrupt they are much more concerned about the risk of default (on anything, not just bonds). That's actually what the credit ratings measures -- a comprehensive evaluation of ability to service all debts. They are not at all bond-specific.

Logically, if investors really did believe these states were doomed then they would also be forced to conclude that the states themselves know they are doomed (all information is public) and at any moment the states will take measures before they are destroyed to prevent their own destruction. These measures will inevitably be some form of default. So if you're lending money to an entity who everybody knows will default at some point in the future it would be naive to think any one particular debt instrument is safe. Defaults, by their very nature, are very unpredictable. That's why investors will demand a real risk premium even for extremely short-term debt (30 days) from borrowers with low credit ratings. This isn't economic theory btw, this is economic fact, supported by two centuries of market data.

Suffice to say, Cali and NY bonds are actually set to out perform so the market does not believe that either state is going to default in the next 10 years or even the next 30 years.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @12:21PM (#17663956)
Bond ratings are assigned to individual bonds.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by komali2 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:57PM (#17656520)
If we really are talking long term structural solvency, I think it's bad faith to start arguing any given state is "objectively worse" than any others - obviously we don't know, because we can't even predict the recessions that keep happening every ten years. (we being the majority of the population and law makers - obviously some people are screaming their heads off about it, fruitlessly)
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @04:47PM (#17656958)
I didn't start arguing that. The Mercatus Center at GMU did. Mercatus has an ideological bias (and not one I share), but they're serious people with real reputations. It's also a little weird to suggest that the fiscal outlooks of different states aren't comparable. Some states have pension obligations that consume an outsized fraction of their projected income, and others don't. What's complicated about that?
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by komali2 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:01PM (#17654336)
Your first point needs expansion before it can be accepted.

Whether or not California is "on the verge of bankruptcy" is questionable. There's a lot of pension to pay out, sure, but the United States is over a trillion dollars in active debt about to add hundreds of billions more, and nobody describes the USA as "on the verge of bankruptcy."

Furthermore, you automatically assign this "on the verge of bankruptcy" aspect to a political party in power, ignoring the very important fact that you just named three states with the biggest, oldest metropolitan areas in the nation. And just because I'm expecting "but HOUSTON!", as a former houstonian, I say let's just hold tight and see what happens when the oil runs out, because the last time it did I was juggling hundreds of unemployed engineers living in houses they couldn't afford driving an hour to get to one interview.

You'll note in my post I never tried to argue the Democratic party was better - although if we want to I can argue about the value of leftist policy until I'm blue in the face. I will say this - if I walk into my house and the stove is on fire, but my dog has crapped ok the carpet, I put the stove fire out first.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by gremlinsinc on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:03PM (#17654881)
We could spend a lot less money on un-needed things. For one, why are we the police of the world? What if we shut down ALL military bases abroad, docked most of our carriers except in times of war, put half the military on reserves.

What if we capped politician benefits across America at what the average American's is?

One big thing is-- if we ended Healthcare's ability to 'lobby' washington... made it illegal to spend healthcare money in lobbying endeavors, they could divert that to r/d and other worthwhile endeavors...

All insurance companies are --are companies that take our money and pay medical companies...couldn't the medical companies become the insurer?

What if instead of single-payer hospitals would take 'subscribers' locally, they'd pay 6% of their income. Make it a requirement that every American needs to signup with a hospital, and that all hospitals need to take anyone regardless of income or lack thereof.

Hospitals would then have a guaranteed monthly residual income they can track/chart and use to figure out their budget. We'd no longer be wasting ANY money on insurance CEO's, etc...

When traveling your host hospital pays the guest hospital, or other providers. The hospitals could work with each other to bring prices/costs down.

There are solutions and there's ways to pay for things, like maybe dropping progressive income taxes for consumption/vat instead... a vat would be paid by anyone in the country regardless of legal status, citizen or immigrant. So everyone would contribute.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by rayiner on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:22PM (#17655067)
> What if instead of single-payer hospitals would take 'subscribers' locally, they'd pay 6% of their income. Make it a requirement that every American needs to signup with a hospital, and that all hospitals need to take anyone regardless of income or lack thereof.

Unrealistic ideas are easy to throw around. In Germany, health insurance premiums are a mandatory 15.5% of income. Are we ready to impose a new 15.5% tax on everyone?

> We'd no longer be wasting ANY money on insurance CEO's, etc...

> What if we capped politician benefits across America at what the average American's is?

Feel-good moves that would save little real money, because at the end of the day what costs money are the salaries for all the middle class people involved in the health care system (doctors, nurses, administrators).

> progressive income taxes for consumption/vat instead... a vat would be paid by anyone in the country regardless of legal status, citizen or immigrant.

Except the people who want universal healthcare want the tax system to be even more progressive.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by MagnumOpus on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @05:23PM (#17657303)
> Are we ready to impose a new 15.5% tax on everyone?

If at the same time pre-tax salaries increase by 15-30 percent when the employer no longer has to pay $16k for insurance, most employees would probably prefer it. (Apart from people earning 6 digits -- and in Germany those people can opt for private gold-plated insurance instead, too.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by tptacek on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @05:49PM (#17657537)
How does this math work? Those numbers are for salaried employees at large companies, but most Americans work for smaller companies. The new tax has to make the system work for everyone.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by gremlinsinc on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @06:03PM (#17657663)
I want universal healthcare, but I want to use technology/common sense and end bloated programs. Military for instance could be cut in half or more (close the bases, keep the carriers, but dock unless during war). Focus on domestic defense, and let the rest of the world figure out their own shit.

End income tax, move to consumption tax/vat. (A modified version that would be sort of a negative tax). Basically, you'd have basic income making everyone who has a physical address (must spend some of the $$ on residence) would receive a check for whatever the poverty level is divided by 12.

Then everyone is a tax payer and pays consumption tax, we'd also have a land value tax, which would be more even on what land is 'worth' regardless of if you're using it for it's total 'worth'.. E.G. -- 2 people own same amount of land, same location, one builds a skyscraper, one doesn't, they both pay what the land/property would be worth if the area was 'fully developed', encouraging people to not just 'hold' land but 'use' it, or pay as if they did, so they might as well develop or sell it to someone who will.

We'd have to figure out ways of getting more off the top of the pile, as consumption does take a bit from the lower classes and funnels it up, but they're getting it back in terms of GBI + Healthcare.

Consumption tax could be tied to a citizen ID, ID = 10%, no ID = 15% tax rate. Could work in a +5% for college grads who used free education grants, until they're > 30 to pay for free college (State/Community schools). This way they pay back when they shop, but it's not permanent and it hurts a lot less than normal loans/etc...and doesn't affect credit. Or could just have a 'twenty's' tax of +5%, whether you go to college or not you pay an extra 5% from 20-30 to on goods, to pay for those who 'took' the advantage to go to school.

I like to believe that there's 'out of the box' ways to do things... I'm a social democrat with some techno-libertarian ideas, I feel the government needs to work and support all people, but it needs to do so in a way that can eliminate the most 'bureacracy' as possible, and drive down costs. I'd be happy if govt could be ran completely by AI and have maybe 10 people over-seeing / auditing the machines.

I'd like to see bills submitted like github issues - small, easily enacted/reversed 'pull requests' that only change small bits of law/codes. Instead of 10-100+ page omnibuses, everything would need to be < 5 pages (or something rudimentarily agreed upon - I'm not a lawyer/politician), and it must only effect a specific item or items that relate to each other. No combining other things for political 'fancy' or posturing.

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by nradov on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @06:40PM (#17657924)
I'm no fan of high military spending, but an aircraft carrier kept at the dock is worse than useless. Carrier operations are tremendously complex and the crews need constant practice in realistic scenarios (foreign deployments, fleet exercises with allies). When those skills and institutional knowledge are lost they take decades to rebuild.
Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by gremlinsinc on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @06:57PM (#17658054)
Firstly the wars/fighting our military is currently 'engaged' in is mostly useless. We haven't 'won' a war since ww2.

Carriers are like bases that can easily be deployed as needed. Maybe keep 2 or 3 carriers off the coast not necessarily 'docked', to run maneuvers to keep 'training' up, reserves could come and run ops maybe every few months to stay 'fresh'... Ideally, we'd not need to call any up until WE are under direct imminent threat.

Furthermore, I think a lot of our future wars will be fought with technology, drones, robots, and not need as much military personnel anyways.

Our military budget should be on par with Russia, instead we're equivalent to the next 7 largest militaries combined. There's no need for that much expense (except to pad lobbyist coffers).

Re:Why Americans Spend So Much on Health Care–In 12 Charts by nradov on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @07:16PM (#17658161)
So for carriers you are essentially proposing the status quo. At any given time only about ⅓ are actually deployed. The others are docked for refit, or doing training close to bases. If they're going to deploy at all the costs are about the same regardless of where they operate. And to maintain proficiency they have to constantly practice operating in all over the world. These are not skills that can be picked up in just a few months. A carrier is not even remotely like a floating base; it's an order of magnitude more complex.

I am all for fighting fewer wars. But until that actually happens our carrier forces are over stretched.