News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by frisco on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:23PM (#1765140)
People seem to be intepreting this as "OMG now we can build a new social network and convert users easily!"

Users still aren't going to leave Facebook. Facebook realizes this, which is why they can do this now. Your mother's cousin is on Facebook. She won't be on Diaspora or (X). That said, this is pretty cool for its own reasons. Like waterlesscloud said, it looks like they "want to be the source of all social interactions on the web without having monolithic control."

This is definitely a smart move for Facebook -- be willing to give a little on data portability to position themselves as open.

Facebook has a gigantic ecosystem. Thousands of sites use Facebook Connect to provide social context and are predicated on everyone interesting have a Facebook account. A social network is a very complicated webapp -- probably the most complex many of its users interact with on a daily basis -- and literally hundreds of millions of users don't want to have to re-learn that. Remember that we're talking about here: take, for example, the http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/facebook_wants_to_be_yo... incident. They have such tremendous inertia that even being able to one-click import your data to another app isn't likely to damage them.

This move is kind of like Jobs saying, "all smartphones have problems. We're not perfect. But we're trying to do the best of anyone." At least for the moment, it's changed the discourse from "wow Facebook supports developers terribly" to "hey, Facebook's not entirely a walled garden!": what Scott Adam's called the "high ground maneuver".

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jlgbecom on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @04:11PM (#1765659)
The combined size of social networks that aren't Facebook is over 1.5 billion people, probably more.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_social_networking_websi...

Facebook has the most users in one place, but the dust is nowhere near settled on where everyone will end up.

This bodes very well for a decentralized solution. I doubt Diaspora will be the first (I think Appleseed (http://opensource.appleseedproject.org) is much more likely), but ultimately, it will be an easily implemented protocol with mature cross-platform libraries that'll really take it down.

This is a good PR move on Facebook's part, because it willfully misinterprets people's frustrations with Facebook. It's not that you didn't have a local copy of your data, it's that you had no control over your data when it was out in the wild. This will take some wind out of the sails of the decentralized solutions, but the armada is still coming.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by joe_the_user on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:34PM (#1765948)
Scanning your link,

It seems like the majority of the non-Facebook figure comes from Chinese language sites. Since social networking sites will quite likely be segmented by language for the foreseeable future, I don't think this really counts. In the English-language world, Facebook has serious network effect and you would be hard-pressed to combine all of FB's competitors into anything.

I agree dispersed social networking is coming... I'm not sure if "control" of data is the way to phrase the "problem"... Still, creating a dispersed network where each contributor controls where their data goes is a very hard problem.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jlgbecom on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:42PM (#1765977)
Sort by Registered Users. You don't even need the Chinese language site (QZone).

Habbo + MySpace + Bebo + Orkut + Friendster + Hi5 = 679 million. Assuming 50% cross-over (which is a very high estimate), that means 340 million unique users, for just six social networks.

And that is nothing to sneeze at.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by joe_the_user on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:55PM (#1766021)
I was mistaken.

The sites I hadn't heard of aren't Chinese language sites but failed English language sites. But they are still failed sites. I don't go to my two Myspace pages, ever.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by eli on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @06:02PM (#1766042)
Orkut is not really competing with Facebook. It's huge in Brazil, but has very few English speaking users left.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by bbgm on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @06:34PM (#1766131)
And in India, where Orkut used to be big, almost everyone I know has migrated to Facebook, so those numbers include a large number of accounts no one is using
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by lhnz on Thursday October 07, 2010 @06:29AM (#1767389)
The thing is, I doubt a decentralized social networking approach would really be allowed by the Chinese government. This kind of solution can only really gain ground in very open countries if at all...
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by mnutt on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:29PM (#1766519)
Is anyone trying to solve the data control problem right now?
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by gecko on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:29PM (#1765931)
I don't want to take this too far off-topic, but: why Appleseed? I hadn't heard of them until just now.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jlgbecom on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:34PM (#1765943)
Tons of working features, a more well-defined roadmap, (much) more experience, and it's way easier to install (LAMP vs Rails). Also, Appleseed is a full social platform, that allows you to build components and extend it. Diaspora is more of a single application, it doesn't have any kind of modular framework to build off of. I don't think Diaspora will ever be dead in the water, but it just has so much catching up to do, and not small stuff, big architectural stuff that doesn't really benefit from the "many eyeballs" advantage of popular open source.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by ugh on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:39PM (#1765969)
My sister is in four social networks other than Facebook. I don’t think it matters. (Five if you insist on counting MySpace.) She would pick Facebook if she had to.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by frisco on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @04:42PM (#1765761)
> The combined size of social networks that aren't Facebook is over 1.5 billion people, probably more.

How much of that overlaps with Facebook? Approximately 500 million? Also, they're measuring total registrations: FB has probably close to a billion registrations on their 500 million actives. All that statistic tells you is that FB has room to grow.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jlgbecom on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @04:48PM (#1765791)
Let's assume there's total overlap, meaning everyone who has a non-FB account also has a FB account. Now let's assume all of those smaller, but substantially sized, networks started inter-communicating. Who would stay on Facebook? Why would you stay on the centralized network with 500 million people when you can spend all your time on the open network with 1.5 - 2 billion people?

As for active versus registrations, we can't be sure of that from anyone, but rest assured, a decentralized network has much greater potential than Facebook does. Especially in the rest of the world where Facebook isn't nearly as popular.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by Qz on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:07PM (#1765857)
500 million vs 1.5 billion is a meaningless metric regarding which social network people will use. They will use the one their friends are using, and no one has near enough friends for those gigantic numbers to have any relevance.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jlgbecom on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:29PM (#1765933)
If it's such a useless metric, why is it always brought up as a clear example of Facebook's unmovable dominance?
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by Qz on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:55PM (#1766685)
It's a useless metric in regard to an individual person's decision to use facebook as opposed to something else. People don't care that facebook has 5 million users, they care that their friends use it. If all/most of their friends started using something else, they would too, regardless of whether that new network had 5 billion people or 5 hundred.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by jonmc12 on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:42PM (#1765543)
The majority of MS windows users don't use Linux either, and the fact that Linux did not run MS apps did not keep a community from pushing forward what an OS and app ecosystem can do.

I'm not thinking 'OMG now I can convert users!', I'm saying, 'Cool, I can possibly evolve what a social network can do for me and a group of friends, while working with the FB ecosystem.'

Facebook will have to build features for the masses - we can build social networks for the subsets of users. We can convince users to download their piece of the social graph by offering a unique niche experience, and getting creative about what it means to interact socially online for the subsets of the masses.

Today's announcement was more than a 'high-road' PR stunt. To extend the linux analogy, FB just made it easy for each user to create a virtual machine where we can run a niche social network side by side with the gigantic ecosystem that is facebook.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by zipdog on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:39PM (#1765213)
This is what I was thinking. FB has reached the marketshare where it's fairly safe for them to relax the control they hold, because even if a variety of open rivals appear, using the data that FB releases, FB will still be the centre of the action.

Alternatively, there may be a parallel to IBM giving away the PC specs, inadvertently pushing the monopoly down to the OS and weakening their market position (though creating a tech boon for everyone that made the market so much bigger).

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by eogas on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @07:44PM (#1766302)
>Your mother's cousin is on Facebook. She won't be on Diaspora or (X).

All the more reason to use Diaspora or (X).

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by chrischen on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @08:34PM (#1766408)
Yea as facebook becomes more mainstream the hip people will need a new place to go.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by eogas on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:01PM (#1766463)
Exactly. Just as tumblr is to blogger and Vimeo is to youtube, Diaspora will become the hipster alternative to Facebook. Totally called it.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by chrischen on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:30PM (#1766634)
Well not necessarily Diaspora...
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by Jun8 on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:44PM (#1765248)
frisco, very well put! "Wind makes a small fire expire but makes a large one bigger", as you state, I guess FB now feels they're pretty much invincible in their user stickiness, so they don't feel threatened. In fact, as people build other services off this data, they'll have even more visibility (if that's possible).
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by avar on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:33PM (#1765187)
They might leave Facebook if something comes along that's much better, and importing your data is one click away.

The biggest advantage Facebook has is that it has your data, being able to export it changes the game.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by ugh on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:41PM (#1765233)
You’ve got it backwards.

The biggest advantage Facebook has is that 500 million people have an account. Facebook would be utterly useless if nobody was using it. Network effects make Facebook hard to beat, not your data. They need your data only to make money but they get your data because you and your mom and everyone else have an account.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by avar on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:42PM (#1765539)
That's what I mean, they have the data of 500 million people. But if those people want to move on having an easy export feature will make things much easier.

When everyone moved from MySpace to Facebook they had to re-do their profile in the new system. Hopefully when FooThingy replaces Facebook importing will be just a click away.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by scott_s on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:56PM (#1765605)
I don't think you agree with his point. Most people have no desire to move on from Facebook not because moving their data is a hassle, but because everyone they know is on Facebook.

Everyone didn't move from MySpace to Facebook. Facebook pulled in many, many new people.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by avar on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @04:34PM (#1765739)
I really didn't mean to speculate on whether Facebook would be replaced by something else. Maybe they'll become big enough that nothing will ever replace them.

But if something does replace them having an API to export the existing data will be critical to the adoption of the new system.

Even if all your friends use Facebook now, having an export API is the difference between them clicking on one link (and "approve") to move your data to the new system, and having to start all over again.

Lowering the barrier of entry will do a lot to increase competition in this area. Hopefully Facebook will institute meaningful data export policies like Google has done.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by trustfundbaby on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @06:47PM (#1766164)
I think the data is one part of the equation ... its definitely a 'nice to have' feature on the next shiny social media app, but you have to remember a lot of the data posted on facebook by people isn't all that valuable to them anyway (except maybe photos and notes).

I think the benefactors of stuff like this are sites like flickr, blogger or tumblr, since it seems you can export out your photos/notes and start a new photostream/blog.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by mkinsella on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:35PM (#1765502)
That's what people said about MySpace
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by tptacek on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:45PM (#1765555)
At its height, how big was MySpace compared to where Facebook is at now?

Somebody has always said something like this about some predecessor.

Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by philwelch on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:55PM (#1765598)
And people have been making your point ever since Facebook opened up to the general population. But MySpace, even in its heyday, wasn't nearly as big as Facebook was a year or two ago.
Re:Facebook Now Allows You To “Download Your Information” by Goladus on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @04:45PM (#1765775)
It's not the number of people using it that matters so much as who those people are and how they use it.

Myspace was most popular among high school kids, indie music culture, and people looking for dates. Many people in their 20s and 30s started using it to keep in touch with old friends and make new contacts but it never grew beyond that. By the time they implemented the news feed, it was too late. Facebook had already gotten the momentum.

Now, people (and organizations) of all sorts have Facebook profiles and pages. Families, adults, colleagues, friends, new acquaintances, all use Facebook to stay connected. Sure, the kids will almost certainly find something new to play with soon, but that won't matter anymore.

Facebook is huge, and now pretty clearly shows enormous potential to continue growing.