Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by protomyth on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:02AM
(#1764185)
True as far as you went, but most people are not charged with a fiduciary responsibility to other people. This does tend to take some wiggle room out of corporate behavior, particularly where shareholder lawsuits are a possibility.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by doki_pen on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:42AM
(#1764392)
I'll make no distinction. People act selfishly too, and there is no law against it. I might vote against welfare, then fall on hard times and plea for welfare. Am I breaking the law? Should the welfare office say "Well, sorry, you used to be against welfare so we can't grant your request?"
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by scott_s on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:34AM
(#1764349)
But being a hypocrite is not a crime. The original question was: what legal relevance does that have? I have the same question, although I suspect the answer is "none." Although anything that makes Oracle look bad might help Google by biasing a judge, even if only a little.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by sprout on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:59AM
(#1764472)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estoppal
Hypocrisy isn't a crime, but it can invalidate a claim if you publicly state one interpretation of law and later state another.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by chc on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @01:36PM
(#1764914)
IANAL, but I'm pretty sure estoppel only applies to legal facts and promises. Merely stating that you think things should be a certain way and then changing your mind when something else would be more beneficial is not grounds for estoppel. Unless Oracle successfully sued for openness or told somebody that it would not do this, I don't see how they could be estopped.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit
by meta on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:32PM
(#1764620)
I gathered it was related to the Unclean Hands (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unclean_hands) claim - but I am just a coder.
Edit: Because "The defendant has the burden of proof" that was included as (part of?) the proof they would need to provide
Corporations can even be convicted of criminal offences, and it would be stupid to not hold them to the same standards as real people.
I don't know were this trend is coming from (that companies shouldn't be accountable for anything other than making money) but it doesn't do any good.