I found it to be a revelatory experience. The news, ultimately, is just stories. It's not a definitive or objective account of what's happening in the world, it's just industrialized gossip with a veneer of legitimacy. Without the sense of urgency that comes with newness, it's often remarkably dull. The news shows you the variance, but not the trend; someone who caught up on current events only once a year would probably have a better sense of where the world is headed than someone who checks the news every day. Some stories that were huge dramas at the time are now long forgotten; some stories that barely registered at the time eventually turned out to be part of a crucial change in society.
Or it may be that people have a hard time to figure out what matters at any given moment in time - you never quite know how a news item will play out - will it become part of History or will it turn out to be just another detail? go figure when it is happening...
Maybe grandparent is just right: when it is all happening people may be more honest than after the fact, when positions are clear and everyone has to justify his own stake in the grand puzzle.
It's called "the news", not "the importants". Unusual, shocking and lurid stories are much more likely to be newsworthy, but by definition they aren't representative of what is actually happening in the world. Our perception of the world is much more strongly influenced by emotive anecdotes than cold hard facts. Violent crime rates in the western world have been significantly declining for decades, but most people believe that the opposite is true; multiple studies have found a correlation between news consumption and the perception of high crime. It's very difficult for the news media to usefully communicate important but gradual trends - rising incomes across the developing world, wage stagnation in the developed world, the impact of climate change, demographic shifts, the erosion of civil society etc.
I think that most journalists are well-intentioned and genuinely believe that they are seekers of truth, but they operate in a system that reflects our innate perceptual biases, our acquired cultural biases and the commercial exigencies of media organisations.
Another useful experiment is to exclusively consume another country's news media for a week or two, preferably a country you know very little about. A week of reading a Ugandan or Nigerian newspaper provides a very different perspective on world events.
It's open source at https://github.com/dougkoellmer/swarm if anyone wants to throw money at me to continue developing it. :)
Perhaps a Google project like the books scanning they did? That would be really cool.
* it doesn't have to be non-profit tech org of course (I did mention google's book project after all), but finding a for-profit that would make things freely available might be a challenge in itself since the costs would not likely be low, either for development or infrastructure/maintenance.
The library systems in the last two places I lived both subscribed to services where when you put your library card number in, you could browse the archives of hundreds of newspapers, magazines and journals. Some of them going back into the 1800's.
There's also "Chronicling America" - it's a federal government (Library of Congress) web site that has full page scans of 500 different newspapers from 1836-1922. Free and open to everyone in the world: https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov
Does any library not have this stuff? It seems absolutely standard for universities, the main/research branches of public library systems, etc. Even my small suburban branch library had a microfilm collection and a few readers.
However newer libraries, particularly in affluent areas, are more likely to go to a digital stack since it will be more readily searched and comprehensively indexed.
If you have access to microfilm, instructive is an article from June 23, 1918 titled "Lenine ready to resign". Of course this was another false story - although he was shot two months later which caused an illness in him that caused him to slowly withdraw until his death five years after.
But there are many stories of this type. Ultimately, however, dominant communist power in Russia ended because Russian communists themselves decided to hold Multi-Party elections (to be even more tangential - some think Lenin would have had a coalition government of Bolsheviks and left socialist revolutionaries if he had not been shot and retired to Gorki).
The analysis shows how seriously misleading was the Times by its reliance on the offical purveyors of information. It indicates that statements of fact emanating from governments and the circles around governments cannot be taken as judgements of fact by an independent press. They indicate opinion, they are controlled by special purpose, and they are not trustworthy news.
Even more problematic than official sources, the authors continue, are the semi-official anyomous reports often relied upon.
All the more reason to shun official Information Ministers and Spokesmen, press briefings, and the like.
The quote comes from "A Test of the News", the researchers were Walter Lippman and Charles Merz, the publication The New Republic, and the date, August 4, 1920.
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.
https://archive.org/stream/LippmannMerzATestoftheNews/Lippma...
> I once read the New York Times from 1917 to 1922 on microfilm
You read ~1800 newspapers from 100 years ago?
Anyway, can you provide a basis that substantiates any claim in the parent? I don't mean one link to one article, which tells us nothing about an overall trend. Ironically, there is nothing like HN for unsubstantiated claims about Russia like the parent, which are ceaseless.
This was not the case when I did this thirty years ago.
> You read ~1800 newspapers from 100 years ago?
I concur with your observation that if you stop reading that sentence after the first few words, it makes less sense than if you read the whole sentence.
> Anyway, can you provide a basis that substantiates any claim in the parent?
I already did.
> I don't mean one link to one article
August 13, 1918 NY Times front page - article headline "Red leaders flee, reach Kronstadt, entire Bolshevist government escaping from Moscow". Of course history shows us that the Bolshevist government did not collapse in August 1918.
> there is nothing like HN for unsubstantiated claims about Russia like the parent, which are ceaseless
I have received ceaseless upvotes for my comments on the lies the Times has told about Russia over the past century, and I wish to thank the товарищи who gave them to me - from wherever they are in the world.
That doesn't establish anything in the original claim. First, the quote says the government left Moscow; it didn't say the government collapsed permanently. Similarly, saying De Gaulle fled France doesn't say that France's free government had collapsed permanently. It would have been false to say Mao and the Chinese Communists didn't flee to northwest China (the Long March); should the newspaper have reported that they were in Beijing? Are you saying the Bolshevik government didn't leave Moscow? Can you provide a basis for that? Second, it's just one headline and you had claimed a trend that lasted for years; one headline, even if mistaken, is not a sign of bias; nobody would say that newspapers are perfect and errors happen for many reasons. Finally, it's from a century ago; I don't see what it says about anything current; does the Russian government of 100 years ago tell us about the current organization? Does IBM of 100 years ago tell us how the current organization functions?
Thinking back on the experience, it was incredible. I could go grab a copy of a newspaper from any particular day in any year. I remember reading the actual newspapers from the early 20th century. Big historical events that are in history books, really take on a different meaning to you when you read them as they were reported in near-real-time. The ability of microfilm to snapshot history in a way different than say viewing a jpg or png, is fascinating.
If you are ever bored, and can find a library that will give you access, you should definitely check it out. It's an experience I think all hackers should have. Such simple yet powerful machines, built on a highly non-technical system of convention. Very cool. Sorry for the long walk down nostalgia lane.