News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by annamargot on Sunday July 29, 2018 @09:44AM (#17638087)
How does this affect the theory of evolution?

In the 90s in high school, we were taught that random mutations create diversity among a species and then natural selection chose the winning mutations. Do they still teach that?

Is behavior and environment generally accepted to be a factor in mutations nowadays?

The random thing always struck me as inefficient.

Edit for clarity.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by zzbzq on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:16PM (#17638826)
It's actually complicated.

In the 19th and 20th century, scientists debated how evolution and speciation could take place. The Darwinian side said it was purely chance-based mutations combined against selective pressures--natural selection. The Lamarckist school suspected this was statistically unlikely and posited that organisms had the ability to pass down acquired traits. They debated fiercely, and the Darwinists declared victory based on Occam's razor because no mechanism was ever discovered whereby acquired traits could be transmitted.

In the 2000s, the U.S. saw some political controversies in which creationists tried to have their anti-evolutionary religious views included in classroom science. The debates around that issue helped solidify a new dichotomy of science vs. religion when it came to the discussion of evolution. During the same era, the study of epigenetics was becoming popular. Owing perhaps due to the aforementioned political discourse of the era, the public at large has allowed epigenetics to be subsumed into the existing theory of evolution as if it is no change at all. From a different perspective (a la the Lamarckists of centuries past,) it represents the possibility of a diametrically opposed paradigm shift.

In these comments there are already comments dismissing epigenetics matter-of-factly as just a part of natural selection. In the purview of scientific history, it's the opposite of natural selection.

To answer your question, the reality is this is very different than what you were taught in the 90s, except that we've rewritten history for science to save face and pretend we knew this all along, and to forget that this sort of thing was explicitly rejected by the Darwinian victors 100 years ago.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by opportune on Sunday July 29, 2018 @01:08PM (#17639110)
Epigenetics and Lamarckian evolution are not mutually exclusive with natural selection, even historically. Lamarckian evolution is natural selection, simply through a non-genotypic mechanism, which epigenetics could be a part of.

Also, the heritability and stickiness of epigenetics is still not well known. It cannot be the main driver of evolution over long intervals (i.e. hundreds of thousands of years) because it is limited in the changes it can make: methylation, for example, can only affect the expression of genes, but it cannot alter them, nor can it introduce new genes.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by xyhopguy on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:11PM (#17639456)
I personally believe it's all integrated together. Sure methylation alone isnt going to effect the genotype of an individual, but thats not day it won't trigger some translocation event, expose LTRs, or some other mechanism of changing the genome. In everything I've seen thus far, I'd guess that it's all a complicated and interwined mess. How do you distinguish evolution and selective pressures of an individual from populations anyway?
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by mirimir on Sunday July 29, 2018 @04:29PM (#17640100)
Right. Whenever someone claims that it's gotta be one way or another, it's best to be suspicious.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by kyberias on Sunday July 29, 2018 @01:21PM (#17639189)
> To answer your question, the reality is this is very different than what you were taught in the 90s, except that we've rewritten history for science to save face and pretend we knew this all along, and to forget that this sort of thing was explicitly rejected by the Darwinian victors 100 years ago.

Yeah, don't answer questions if you don't know the answers.

It is not that different. There still is DNA and epigenetics has not proven Darwin wrong or Lamarck right.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by tasty_freeze on Sunday July 29, 2018 @01:20PM (#17639181)
That is the cartoon version. The raw stuff of evolution is variation and selection pressure. Mutations are an important long-term contributor to variation, but most variation isn't due to mutation. Eg, my two parents had five sons, and while there are some similarities, there are a lot of differences too. None of the variation was because of mutations.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by 13of40 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:07PM (#17639433)
Sorry for the ELI5, but if the differences aren't due to [genetic] mutation, how do they get passed on to future generations?
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by Bromskloss on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:16PM (#17639480)
I think the point is that variation is created by taking some material from the mother, and some from the father. A _mutation_ also creates variation, but refer to things like replications errors and "bit flips" due to, say, radiation.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by 13of40 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @03:20PM (#17639791)
But those aren't differences in the same way that mutations are. The chromosomes passed on by the grandmother are identical to those received by the granddaughter, unless you're talking about spilicing genes between chromosomes. The morphological differences in the daughter are from the genes being expressed differently in the context of her body and the father's DNA. (Or so 90's science class would have me believe.)
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by gus_massa on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:32PM (#17640386)
Each person has two chromosomes of each kind and they are mixed during the formation of the egg and sperms. For more details see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromosomal_crossover

So, ignoring mutations, the next generation gets a never before seen chromosomes that are a puzzle of the chromosomes of the mother and another never before seen chromosomes that are a puzzle of the chromosomes of father.

I still can't find how common is the crossover, but in one link I got about 70 crossovers during the formation of the egg (with a lot of variations), that is approximately 3 crossovers per chromosome. I guess the crossover rate for the sperm is similar.

There is an exception with the X and Y chromosomes in males, that can't crossover, so the Y chromosome is inherited without crossovers, and it's much easier to track the male ancestor line in the Y chromosome. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-chromosomal_Adam

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by gonvaled on Sunday July 29, 2018 @03:37PM (#17639865)
The daughter has some genes from the mother, and some from the father. Which genes are selected from which progenitor is random.

To have a big pool for recombinations, inbreeding is to be avoided and populations must be big enough.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by ratacat on Sunday July 29, 2018 @04:50PM (#17640197)
My cryptological brain can't herp but replace here... The "selected at random" with "selected in ways we don't understand"
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by HeadsUpHigh on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:12AM (#17644158)
There are parts of the cell that are noise-based. I'm talking about quantum level noise so in many ways it's as random as it gets.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by pygy_ on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:24PM (#17640356)
> Which genes are selected from which progenitor is random.

IIRC that's not completely true. In mammal females, there is competition at the chromosome level to determine which member of each pair will end up in the first polar body (which is discarded) and which one ends up in the secondary oocyte (which then splits up to become the ovum and the secondary polar body).

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by erikpukinskis on Sunday July 29, 2018 @04:56PM (#17640227)
Think of the male RNA like an STD that the baby has inside its cell walls since... well, the beginning.

Like a virus that doesn’t need a penetration mechanism because it’s literally Trojan horsed into the egg.

A virus without a penetrator is basically like a cassette tape of DNA.

Derpy egg plays random cassette tape, baby’s DNA is... well the books are cooked as they say. Traits, emerge.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by ganeshkrishnan on Sunday July 29, 2018 @10:20AM (#17638253)
We have much more information than the 90's school which in turn had information few decades outdated.

Some new stuff include: epigenetics, the role of 'junk dna', small RNA etc.

Overall I am very enthusiastic about epigenetics

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by zawerf on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:11AM (#17638511)
I wonder where you can find erratas based on the edition of education you got. (e.g., if you grew up in the 90s you should know pluto is no longer a planet)

Mostly interested in basic scientific knowledge (say high school level) that has been updated.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by abathur on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:59PM (#17639062)
Good point. A thoughtful, digestible source of such updates might even help undercut one source of inter-generational alienation.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by derefr on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:58PM (#17639058)
You might be able to do something automatic using Wikipedia article version history for articles that have been “complete” for s long time. Diff them over long time-scales, generate “release notes”, summarize.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by krick on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:43AM (#17643741)
Lately I wanted to update my understanding of plant taxonomy to discover, that with the latest advancements (APG) kind of arbitrary, but neat taxonomy I've been taught in school is "officially" abandoned, and currently we don't seam have any (recognized) sufficiently simple to remember taxonomy at all. I wander what they teach in schools now.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by Mirioron on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:47AM (#17638688)
That would be a great project.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by ccozan on Sunday July 29, 2018 @01:10PM (#17639124)
Great for people who might wake up from a coma. Or frozen.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by mrexroad on Sunday July 29, 2018 @06:01PM (#17640526)
... as well as those who return to a subject decades after formal education.

... or those trying to have an meaningful conversation with someone from another generation. I honestly have no idea what my parents were taught in school. I’ve often wonder how much of this plays into the narratives that get exploited in politics.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by zaarn on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:56AM (#17643525)
While it's a very simplified version, basically yeah.

Nature doesn't really care about efficient, if you want proof of that just look into various places in our body. All over the place you seem completely idiotic design that is merely a result of nature just choosing the lazy, quick and dirty route over the efficient one.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by annamargot on Friday August 03, 2018 @08:12AM (#17679179)
That’s interesting. Could you name a few examples?
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by zaarn on Friday August 03, 2018 @09:01AM (#17679441)
IIRC from my biology book, the nerve for controlling the voice box goes from the brain, down to the heart, loops through the aortic arch over the heart and then goes back up to the voice box.

In giraffes this nerve can be 4 meters long.

The likely reason for this layout is that the nerve originally routed to the gills, which were on the height of the heart until the neck extended and the heart moved lower in the body.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by TangoTrotFox on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:36PM (#17639579)
I think there's a related issue here that's always kind of nagged at me.

We have evolved many characteristics which are handy, but which seem unlikely to have had enough of an impact on survival to have become so ubiquitously propagated by natural selection alone. For instance the ability to digest milk as well as white skin are both relatively new adaptations. But the advantages they offer, for the locations where they evolved, are pretty mild.

Fair skin could have had sexual selection factors in play helping its spread, but being able to digest the milk of lactating animals? It just doesn't seem like a mutation that would provide enough benefit to become ubiquitous through the mechanisms of natural selection alone, yet it did. And both of the above evolutions are relatively recent, making it all the more difficult to reconcile things through random mutations filtered by natural/sexual selection alone.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by dTal on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:56PM (#17646981)
The key is sexual reproduction. You're not selecting for a single trait at a time, you're selecting for all of them. Yes, the ability to digest milk as an adult was unlikely to have contributed to the reproductive success of the very first individual it arose in. But it didn't need to; it only had to not prevent reproductive success. Over a few generations the gene spread to dozens, then hundreds of individuals, sheerly from being along for the ride. At that point, statistics can begin to take over - even a tiny advantage will gain a foothold if given enough people to prove itself over.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by ratacat on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:23PM (#17640351)
Disclosure: I'm fairly dubious that we as a modern discourse fully understand the reality of life, and propagation, shaping of life.

I have a lot of reservations. And I often times find myself rather disgusted by the attitude and approach of many people in the scientific worldview.

That being said, I do believe there are some interesting numbers out there about how much more efficient dairy is than just simply eating your animals. It also produces a relatively large amount of fat, which is is incredibly important (for your brain, and much else) and is one of the more difficult parts of a diet to attain in most ecosystems.

There could possibly also be advantages related to the ease of lactobacillus fermentation.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by torstenvl on Sunday July 29, 2018 @04:19PM (#17640058)
I'm confused by your viewpoint. How is a fuller ability to extract nutritionally-complete food from your environment in winter not an advantage you'd expect to be selected-for?

People who are malnourished produce poorer sperm. People who are malnourished are not looked on as good mates who can bear children or provide food for the family. People who are malnourished die earlier, perhaps starving to death before reproducing (or reproducing as much).

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by TangoTrotFox on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:25PM (#17640359)
Think about your usage of the word word people - as opposed to the singular. In a purely random natural selection driven system, propagation relies on the success of a single mutated individual until we get to very large populations where randomness could more regularly yield similar mutations among different people. Because of this, in the purely random natural selection system the magnitude of an effect is extremely important. Let's imagine we can somehow quantify exactly how likely a specimen is to survive in a certain area per year, we'll call that value x. Imagine x is some percent per year. How much would a random specimen suddenly developing lactose tolerance increase that percent?

In the case of something like Darwin's birds, the percent improvement from beak changes would be very substantial. That mutation would open up entirely new, and vast, resources of food available at all times and completely independent of everything else. In the case of milk, you need a lactating animal to start with. That already implies you have multiple sources of food in extremely healthy shape. That little catch there already ensures that this mutation would not provide a substantial benefit in a one-off scenario.

By contrast, imagine our mutations are not entirely random. And that our bodies, somehow, trend towards more desirable mutations over time -- meaning we don't see just a one-off instance of favorable mutations but them tending to occur over and over again. In this case your language of "people" would be entirely appropriate. Over time, even a small survival edge means a lot and, given enough samples, we'd certainly expect this trait (and any trait for that matter) to start to 'stick' in any area where its net effect on survival was basically anything above 0.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by pjscott on Sunday July 29, 2018 @07:09PM (#17640889)
I'm not seeing the issue here. As you say, let's talk about this at the individual level: picture yourself as a prehistoric pastoralist raising cattle. They eat plants you can't digest, and from them you get milk and meat. Everybody knows that you can't just drink the milk raw -- the lactose in there will really do a number on your digestive system -- but processed milk products like cheese make up a major part of your diet.

... Except that you can digest the lactose. You don't feel sick after drinking milk, because you have a mutation that breaks the normal mammalian mechanism for reducing lactase production in adulthood. Sounds nice, right? But maybe not something that'll bring a huge reproductive advantage to you and yours; more of a cool party trick to show off to your neighbors.

And then one year there's not nearly enough rain. Famines have always been pretty common, alas, and here's another one. Now consider this: processing the milk so lactose-intolerant people can digest it loses about 40% of the calories. You can drink it straight because of your freaky mutant milk-drinking powers, and your neighbors can't. You get a lot more food at a time when people are dying from lack of food. Is this sounding like an evolutionary advantage? The sort of thing you might pass on to the kids you'll have because you didn't starve?

The ability to digest lactose as an adult is potentially a really big deal if you happen to live in a culture that already uses processed milk products as a major source of calories.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by TangoTrotFox on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:29AM (#17642458)
Dairy products would not have made up a substantial portion of a regions diet until lactose tolerance had emerged. Lactose intolerance extends to all dairy products, not just milk. And again, you need lactating animals to produce consistent dairy products. Animals do not naturally lactate unless they're feeding their young. And animals also do not naturally produce the freakish amount of milk that we're able to extract now a days from millennia of artificial selection and, in the US at least, using a lifelong cocktail of all sorts of different drugs.

To be clear, I do agree with you that in certain uncommon scenarios lactose tolerance could provide a tangible, though not enormous, advantage. And that's the problem. A different shaped beak for a bird entails a never-ending constant, and enormous, advantage. Lactose tolerance is something that's pretty irrelevant by comparison, yet it would become ubiquitous.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by torstenvl on Sunday July 29, 2018 @07:34PM (#17641003)
In a purely random natural selection driven system, propagation relies on the success of a single mutated individual

That is flatly incorrect. Whoever convinced you this is true has a fundamental misunderstanding of natural selection.

Any time environmental pressures change such that a particular phenotypical expression leads to more reproductive success, that is natural selection. A mutation is utterly unnecessary.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by TangoTrotFox on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:36AM (#17642487)
You have the context of what you're responding to right above you. The discussion is about mutations. How a single mutation would propagate in cases where mutations were entirely random as opposed to those where mutations were, in some way, less than random.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by acqq on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:08PM (#17640285)
You are on Hacker News, have you never tried some genetic algorithms? Then try to calculate how many parallel “computers” are available on Earth, and how often, and for how long. It all fits.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by extra88 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:12AM (#17638513)
Behavior and environment are largely how natural selection operates, it has never been thought otherwise. More colorful bird is selected as a mate, thicker fur survives the winter, etc.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by annamargot on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:27AM (#17638596)
I should have specified. I meant with regard to the mutations specifically.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by chiefalchemist on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:32PM (#17638924)
New mutations create new possibilities. What the article seems to say is, there's quite a bit of info embeded in genes, but there are additional factors that twigger which traits are called into play. It's a very sophisticated system.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by delinka on Sunday July 29, 2018 @10:20AM (#17638249)
"The random thing" is indeed efficient. That's why it takes millions of years to evolve from single-celled organism to what you see on the planet today.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by annamargot on Sunday July 29, 2018 @10:46AM (#17638395)
Yeah, that’s what my teachers said too. “Millions of years. End of conversation. Put your hand down, son.”

It always seemed a little dismissive of the potential of our now very complex organisms to use feedback if only purely random mutations were at play.

Instead of random mutations full stop, how about informed best guess mutations targeted at potentially stressed areas of the body.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by aperiodic on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:10PM (#17639452)
Somewhat related, Leslie Valiant believes that if evolution performs a random search in genome space, it is computationally impossible for it to have led to the complexity that it's produced in only a few billion years.

He's written a fascinating paper exploring what other algorithms besides random search could perform the computational task required and are also biologically plausible: https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/handle/1/2643031/valiant_...

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by annamargot on Friday August 03, 2018 @08:44AM (#17679341)
Very cool. Thank you
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by delinka on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:13AM (#17638524)
While I suppose "informed best guess" might be possible, I don't see how this 'intelligence' makes it into the process. Liver more stressed in this particular organism? Tweak the DNA in the reproductive organs. I don't think we even have a theory that could explain how that should work. Maybe we'll get there one day.

But I suspect, as has been demonstrated in labs with bacteria, that it really is random. When their environment begins to show signs of contamination, the bacteria's inner workings don't use an "informed best guess" when mutating for reproduction - the random changes result in bacteria suited for death with exposure to the contamination, and bacteria that are more resistant to the contamination. Guess which ones survive to pass on the trait.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by dahlueblojen on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:16AM (#17638544)
To be fair most grade school teachers just have a bachelor's in their subject

(if you're lucky) (also don't include masters of education, that's about teaching, not the subject matter being taught)

that they aquired a decade or so ago. It's not surprising if what they know is well what they were taught and not what is most current.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by jedberg on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:43AM (#17638669)
That's very dismissive of teachers. Yes it's true, some teachers are lazy like this. But you got a few things wrong.

First off, if you teach at the middle or high school level, you have to have a masters in the subject you teach. It's called a single subject credential.

Secondly, just like college professors, who continue to learn about new developments in their field, a lot of K-12 teachers, and especially 7-12 teachers, do that too. They also read papers and also attend conferences to learn the latest developments in their field.

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by extra88 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:30PM (#17638909)
> if you teach at the middle or high school level, you have to have a masters in the subject you teach.

That’s not true, some states don’t require a Masters in any subject, let alone in one relevant to what they’re teaching.

https://study.com/articles/High_School_Teacher_Requirements_...

https://teach.com/become/teaching-credential/state-requireme...

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by dahlueblojen on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:10PM (#17638799)
I'm highly suspicious that your first claim is not true for all U.S. pubic schools (or even a sufficiently significant portion). I'm sure it's the case in some States.

2nd case is probably fair, though I think a lot of people, myself included, have has experiences with teachers that definitely didn't pay attention in those seminars if they attended. (And in my case that's just with 1.5 years of middle school)

Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by extra88 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @11:16AM (#17638545)
That would require an intelligence to be informed and to make a guess. There is none.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by CuriouslyC on Sunday July 29, 2018 @02:54PM (#17639669)
Would you consider yourself an informed intelligence making guesses? What makes you different from the rest of the universe? Do you think the scale at which we exist is somehow special?
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by extra88 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @03:14PM (#17639764)
Yes. Lots of things; I’m warmer, I contain more matter by volume than average, and I emit information in response to queries, even stupid ones. Yes.
Re:Dads Pass on More Than Genetics in Their Sperm by ratacat on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:05PM (#17640269)
Is it possible that the information emitted by the universe to queries simply escapes you.