Re:Steven Pinker’s case for optimism
by toasterlovin on Saturday July 28, 2018 @06:29PM
(#17635399)
The relative social position of the person making the argument has no bearing on whether the argument is correct.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Spot on!
This is one of the problems we see on the left from time to time.. for example someone suggesting that men can't have an opinion on gender equality, or what not..
(note. the problems on the right in American politics does however seem objectively worse by a few orders of magnitude)
> men can't have an opinion on gender equality, or what not
It's about getting the people with the right experience and weighting people's opinions based on experience. For a long time mens opinions have been overweighted in gender issues hence the push for rebalancing.
I understand the feeling..
But if you want to change the mind of other thinking people, it's better to argue the merits of the message than debate the identity of carrier.
It's not about "identity". It's about experience with the issue which for many gender issues is often tied to identity. "Other thinking people" can also do better to recognize this.
I'm not saying he's wrong by the measures he uses. I'm saying he has the privilege of being able to look at things from a perspective which people who are not so well off do not.
Re:Steven Pinker’s case for optimism
by toasterlovin on Saturday July 28, 2018 @07:58PM
(#17635706)
FWIW, most of the improvements he talks about disproportionately benefit underprivileged people.