This is actually a great example. We continue to reduce the lead in our water and environment, and kids in Flint today have all-time record low levels of lead in their blood.
There is no amount of lead that is safe, and this is not meant to let Flint and Michigan officials off the hook. But it's relevant to point out that kids in Flint today have dramatically, orders of magnitude lower levels of lead in their blood than kids born in the 1980s.
You'll be pleasantly surprised by his work. It suggests that if there is a natural arc to history, it involves the expansion of our "circle of empathy". Progress, in Pinker's definition, involves improving living standards for everyone. His is a counter to the "things are getting worse so we should keep more for ourselves" argument.
> My grandparents grew up without electricity or plumbing, not even a telephone.
> Infant mortality when they were born was 10% for children under the age of 1.
> There was no healthcare.
> There was no retirement/social assistance.
> There was no welfare.
> Many of grandads peers died in brutal wars.
> Epidemic diseases (aka spanish flu etc.) were still common and would wipe out a lot of people.
> There was no right to vote for women. There was no transparency in governance.
> There was no concept of 'worker safety' - people did unbelievably dangerous things. My grandfather worked in a lumber camp in dead winter, cutting down and hauling trees surrounded by others doing the same.
> There was no higher education for regular folk.
> They were white as can be yet faced intense racism as 'dirty Germans' (i.e. two world wars).
> Heck there wasn't even anything made of plastic ... can you imagine!
... I could go on and on ...
Life is incredibly better (materially, maybe not socially) for almost everyone, most of us wouldn't survive two weeks in Victorian-era conditions.
This is one of the problems we see on the left from time to time.. for example someone suggesting that men can't have an opinion on gender equality, or what not..
(note. the problems on the right in American politics does however seem objectively worse by a few orders of magnitude)
It's about getting the people with the right experience and weighting people's opinions based on experience. For a long time mens opinions have been overweighted in gender issues hence the push for rebalancing.
But if you want to change the mind of other thinking people, it's better to argue the merits of the message than debate the identity of carrier.
There may be an interesting question here about the tension between, on the one hand, the benefit of anonymous publication to stop positive or negative associations with the author from affecting how their work is received, and on the other hand, the need for full disclosure when an author advocates for certain policies that they might gain undue benefit from.
I think your original comment suggested that because he was privileged, and because he had noticed that the situation for many people in the world is better than it has been before, that therefore he didn't care (or people like him might not care) that others still suffer from problems that we could prevent. I'm not sure if optimism reduces empathy, but I suppose that is something to consider.
Statisically he may be right for certain measurable factors but it seems a little naive or callous when he's clearly not directly effected by the worst issues in the world.