There was actually a blog post making this argument a while back. I think it may have been submitted here, but I can't find it because news.yc only lets me see my last 180 saved stories. It goes through the numbers though and makes a pretty good case that getting "only" 2,000 subscribers is actually extremely difficult. (There was something vaguely similar submitted only a month or so ago, but the one I'm thinking of is from much longer back.)
Not to say that you are wrong, but what data do you have to justify that statement?