Re:Phoebus cartel
by mirimir on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:59PM
(#17620432)
Maybe there is no "free market". But without Phoebus, customers could have chosen between shorter-life bulbs that were more efficient, and longer-life bulbs with lower replacement costs. How is that bad?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
[dead]
You're being sarcastic, right?
It doesn't matter what the "unwashed masses" lack. What matters is that they have the choice.
Your argument is tantamount to "I have this gun, so I know best how to maximize the utility of your wallet."
First off, that's a false analogy.
That being said, it's 50/50. Yeah, obviously people should be allowed to make their own choices but you also have to realize that people like 'us' (20-40yo tech career westerners) live a far different life and probably employ much better personal criteria than others do. It's not inherently a false statement but it shouldn't be used to take power from people.
Long story short I agree with you but a lot of people don't fully understand the ramifications of their actions.