Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by cornellwright on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:28PM
(#17619181)
Also I wonder how they authenticate the "alums" who sign up. Who's to say it's not someone posing as a founder from a YC company after setting up a plausible gmail address?
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by tlrobinson on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:41PM
(#17620860)
From the website:
How do you verify that reviewers are YC alumni?
At this point, we personally invite them to volunteer as reviewers. We may add more verification steps such as Twitter and/or AngelList account linking in the near future.
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by aloukissas on Thursday July 26, 2018 @04:50PM
(#17620978)
Verification is a hard issue, as one can imagine. We're exploring dropping the double-blind review part (making it optional) if both parties consent to that.
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by rpm33 on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:16PM
(#17620120)
Bang on! "I’m an investor, can I access your user base? The short answer is maybe.", sounded very shady. Not sure I can trust them with some very personal information.
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by aloukissas on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:42PM
(#17620322)
Hi there! I've really tried to be very upfront that we'll _never_ share any info (even emails) without prior consent. If this is not clear in the FAQ, this is a failure on my end.
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by pbreit on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:18PM
(#17619095)
Yeah, I'm surprised there wouldn't be any mention at all of at least one person who is involved.
Also, is it free?
Re:Show HN: YC Review – Get your YC application reviewed by ...
by aloukissas on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:43PM
(#17620330)
Yes, it's a free, no-hidden-agenda, community effort.
My read: "we're not YC alum ourselves", since that would obviously be the first thing they'd say to engender trust.
Funny how that changes how I think about this. If they are in the YC family already, definitely more trust. YC alum abide by a certain code. If these guys aren't YC alums -- just some random guys -- then very different implication.
I personally wouldn't use this unless these guys are verifiably YC alums themselves. Otherwise, if you're an applicant - would you really want to trust some random dudes with your plans for world domination? If you're a YC alum - do you really want to pour time into something with unclear motivations and actors?
My $0.02. Probably being too cynical.
Edit: Ooof, the "I’m an investor, can I access your user base? The short answer is maybe." doesn't make me feel any better. Seems pretty counter to the YC spirit for there to be a side-hustle on paying-it-forward / helping each other.