News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by walrus01 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:47AM (#17609657)
Building a rover that can drill more than a few inches deep is presently a huge technical challenge. If you look at drill rigs used by humans for water wells and such, the rover will need to be 8x larger and heavier than the current Curiosity.
Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:29AM (#17610021)
>If you look at drill rigs used by humans for water wells and such, the rover will need to be 8x larger and heavier than the current Curiosity.

Not necessarily. The hole will be stationary relative to Mars so you could just send a little base station with radio and power that drops a paper towel roll sized module with an unspooling data/power link cable and your science stuff into the ice. It can either bore its way through like a TBM (hard but good scientific value since you can measure environment on the way down) or just have it heat itself and let gravity drop it through (no moving parts but less scientific value since you're altering the environment around the probe). When you hit water stop unspooling the cable and just hang it there by the cable.

I'm sure college students in Maine or Montana would be able to pool their ice fishing expertise and come up with some working prototypes if given a sufficient quantity of beer.

It's fun to play armchair engineer.

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by larkeith on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:39PM (#17610590)
Huh, that's a good point - a large enough RTG on a data uplink cable would make its own way down through the ice, given time. There would be a lot of crosscontamination between the various ice layers and the lake though, so that's unlikely to fly (or sink, as the case may be).
Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:02AM (#17609798)
See: Armageddon, the movie.

Maybe we just need to go full Bruce Willis. Somebody get Ben Affleck to sing Leaving on a Jet Plane.

In seriousness, it sounds like a fascinating problem. If anyone has seen the drills they use to make holes for piles for new condo/office towers—they're probably wider than needed in this case (not actually sure of that)— the drill (bit?) is extendable, but the rig itself is enormous. Those are mobile units.

Otherwise something like a semi-permanent or permanent unfolding oil-rig type machine would be needed?

None of this helps with the weight problem. I wonder if there's a more clever option.

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by AstralStorm on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:40PM (#17610606)
Use a digging rig combined with multiple explosive charges perhaps. Essentially a small shape charge version of solid boosters will work.

It would be similar to preparing a shallow mine.

After the hole is made you get to clean it up to obtain decent samples though.

Whether this would save size or mass is to be seen, a digging drone would preferably be small though very sturdy and dense to survive landslides.

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:57PM (#17610769)
Right— I now remember some conversation surrounding a similar problem on Titan(?).

I think a drilling drone was proposed, but communications posed complicated. That is, communicating to a base rover to route to Earth. I could picture some kind of high-tensile wire on a spool connected to the digging drone. It might not be the highest speed communication, but if it at least proved reliable, that could work, no?

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by pvaldes on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:53PM (#17610738)
> Building a rover that can drill more than a few inches deep is presently a huge technical challenge. You need a rover of 8x mass.

1- make a rover of standard weight and size an put it in the desired place, as before. Deploy a light but strong flat platform around.

2-Look around. What do you see? Probably a lot of heavy rocks.

3-Pick some rocks of the appropriate mass, or a bag of sand

4-Load stuff of your choice over rover or put it in the flatform or in a special area designed to be filled until reaching the desired weight. Yes, like a truck.

5- Now that your rover is 8x heavier, start drilling

6- Finished?. Now remove the bags of sand or the rocks one to one.

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by NegativeLatency on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:47PM (#17611224)
Sure, but you now have all kinds of extra mass to lift to orbit (not the sand, but a beefier rover). You could launch more payloads and assemble in orbit.

It starts to become complicated...

Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by pvaldes on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @03:03PM (#17611877)
I can't see why. After you remove the load again. Rover weight would be the practically the same as before. Maybe a little heavier, but not much.
Re:Liquid water 'lake' revealed on Mars by lxmorj on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:52PM (#17614750)
Not contesting the point, but shouldn't Martian rock be significantly less dense due to less gravitational compression?