News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by timcederman on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @01:17PM (#1760544)
Ad-soaked bully? Like who?

I'm still a fan of Adioso.com's UI (another YC alum), and the TripAdvisor/Bing/Kayak experiences, from memory, are fairly subtle with their advertising.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by danilocampos on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @01:29PM (#1760575)
Like the incumbent travel sites that everyone's mom uses: Travelocity, Orbitz, Expedia, Hotwire, Priceline.

http://blog.danilocampos.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/Hipm...

Here's Travelocity, for example.

Bing's flight search isn't bad, in that it's minimalist, but they're not doing anything terribly exciting beyond the Farecast action they acquired.

TripAdvisor can die in a fire. I'm never, ever using any of their products again, thanks to the constant (user-hostile!) "book a flight to this place right now damn you!" pop-ups they used to do on the browser and, worse, on the iPhone. They would try to get me to book a flight to a place where I already was, searching for things to do or places to stay.

It's just asinine, jackass behavior and representative of everything that's wrong with online travel sites.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by timcederman on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @05:05PM (#1761487)
And it also monetizes like crazy. The product team there recognises it's a problem, but it's hard to argue with millions in revenue at stake. All sites start out idealistic, and then start making compromises in order to survive.

The actual flight product itself at TripAdvisor isn't too bad (apart from auto-selecting Orbitz as an alternative search so they can do some flag-planting). It's the main site that does all the pop-unders and in-line pop-ups. Try going direct to flights - http://www.tripadvisor.com/Flights

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by danilocampos on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @06:47PM (#1761888)
Windows monetizes like crazy, too. As did Blockbuster. As do highway robbers.

Companies can monetize at the expense of goodwill all they want. It doesn't impress anyone but their accountants and investors.

Meanwhile, users grow resentful. Companies with a user product should value the user first and configure their business accordingly — it's just the only viable long term play.

If you do crappy things to the user for short term cash, that becomes your long term play because you become dependent on the money. And in the long term, you lose to the guy who doesn't treat users like crap.

Edit: >All sites start out idealistic, and then start making compromises in order to survive.

And if Zappos had taken this advice and compromised by screwing their customers for cash, would they have sold for a billion dollars?

I mean, a billion dollars, all for not being a dick to users or cutting corners at their expense. Thats the value of ideals you won't compromise.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by timcederman on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @01:19AM (#1762836)
You can't provide a single counter example and pretend it's the rule.

Have you built a product like these and dealt with these tensions? It's a really hard problem to balance for 99% of companies. Because a few get away with it doesn't mean it's right for everyone else (or that those that get away with it are intrinsically better).

You lose your argument when you resort to ad hominem stuff like "highway robbers". Working on a large consumer internet site is full of necessary compromises.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by blhack on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @01:27PM (#1760562)
You're right about this. Kayk et al aren't saturated with ads, but they don't feel nearly as...something as hipmunk.

Clean? Maybe? Shiny? I don't know but every time I've shown the site to any of my friends or coworkers they remark that it's pretty.

Hipmunk vs Kayak or bing is the difference between a cheap casio watch and a nice, heavy, automatic winding watch with a pretty window on the back of the dial. They both tell the time, they both sit on your wrist, but the latter just...feels nicer.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by Psyonic on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @02:00PM (#1760693)
If that's all hipmunk has going for it (shiny?) than I wouldn't bet on them. Nasty interfaces often win (i.e. craigslist). The guys who started kayak are ex-orbitz people, so they've been around awhile and have data on what works.

Don't get me wrong, I'm rooting for hipmunk. I would love to see them succeed. But they need more than shiny.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by blhack on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @03:45PM (#1761140)
>Don't get me wrong, I'm rooting for hipmunk. I would love to see them succeed. But they need more than shiny.

I'm not just talking about the interface, I'm talking about the experience overall.

Re:Hipmunk Closes Hyper-Competitive Angel Round, Sans The Us... by danilocampos on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @01:36PM (#1760595)
Thoughtful. I think what you're grasping for is thoughtful.

Hipmunk is very v1, but nonetheless you can tell how much thought has gone into the presentation of flight data. The agony sort, for example, is so blindingly obvious once you see it in practice, but no one bothered to give it any thought until now.

Simplicity is actually really hard. They got it to work.