News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by tenaciousDaniel on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:17PM (#17605023)
It may be easy enough to identify someone as Richard Spencer as a white nationalist, but the issue is with knowing where to draw the line. That line is not clearly drawn right now.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by prolepunk on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:21PM (#17605055)
How about we start with whoever is calling for extermination of people with identifiable characteristics such race/religion/etc or using a number of well known dog whistles against those groups, should be banned. The sarcasm/satire/meme defense is not a real thing.

It's not that it's hard identify Nazis, it's that they make Facebook money and that's why Facebook is not willing to deal with them.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:36PM (#17606070)
> How about we start with whoever is calling for extermination of people with identifiable characteristics such race/religion/etc or using a number of well known dog whistles against those groups

The issue with this approach is what constitutes a dog whistle seems to be growing rapidly, and largely relies upon the imagination of the person judging.

On a related note, I'm curious where you are encountering all these nazis you speak so passionately about, and what definition you're using for nazi.....might the deciding factor be the detection of a dog whistle, which is why you seem to encounter so many?

Or for a more concrete approach to the question: I an an unambiguous opponent of open borders - does that make me a nazi?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:52PM (#17606154)
The only exception would be if you're a NIMBY talking about the "borders" of your neighborhood. Social media critics have to worry about home values, too.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:11PM (#17606230)
Just to confirm I'm not misunderstanding you (and the downvoters, presumably).....if I am opposed to the complete removal of my nation's borders, you consider me to generally support: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazism

Is that correct?

If so, do you realize the implications of that belief?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Friday July 27, 2018 @11:03AM (#17626455)
See irony, dude. My comment highlighted the hypocrisy of your downvoters, in an amusing way. They're happy to have immigrants in the county, because fast food. They're much less happy to have them in the neighborhood, because racism.

That isn't to say that I agree with you. Although it's true that immigrants as a percentage of overall population have increased since the 1960s, that increase is slowing and we're only now approaching the percentages we had at the turn of the century. Immigration back then has been a long-term benefit to the nation, and immigration now will probably be the same.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Friday July 27, 2018 @11:45AM (#17626799)
> See irony, dude.

More likely a misunderstanding on my part, and now on yours if you believe this is irony.

> That isn't to say that I agree with you.....< immigrants as a percentage of overall population have increased since the 1960s, that increase is slowing>

I'm not saying anything about immigration levels, I am talking about this increasingly popular idea that a lack of support for open borders is inherently racist. It is lazy, stupid thinking, and the prevalence of this sort of thinking seems to be growing, even on relatively highly objective and intellectual sites like HN. This sort of thinking has consequences.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Friday July 27, 2018 @09:54PM (#17631040)
Don't worry, I detect zero irony on your part. I've been called "racist" (by family members!) for not believing the Russia fairy tale. This despite loudly proclaiming my antipathy to Trump and my opinion that a vote for anyone other than Stein or Johnson was wasted. This week our heroic investigators are reading tweets!

So, there's sort of a sliding scale of ridiculousness in racism accusations. When you say your objections are to "open borders", a ridiculous fancy that cannot possibly happen in the next decade, it's somewhat natural to wonder what you're really against...

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:50PM (#17639016)
> a ridiculous fancy that cannot possibly happen in the next decade

There is a growing number of people who believe borders, and border enforcement, are literally racist. I am protesting against that movement.

> it's somewhat natural to wonder what you're really ag

If(!) my previous statement doesn't change your mind on this, then you might want to adjust your dog whistle detector, or even better, reconsider the utility of that mode of perception entirely.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Monday July 30, 2018 @04:58PM (#17647965)
You're protesting against what people believe? What does that even mean? Do you expect everyone to believe what you believe?

Ocasio-Cortez is one candidate for the House. In this fall's elections, she will be as potent a symbol for the right as she is for the left. There is no chance that the resulting Congress will vote to eliminate borders, and there is even less chance that the current president would fail to veto such a vote. You're crying about something that cannot happen. That isn't rational. Why aren't you rational?

We have our suspicions. Please note, these are suspicions based on an entire thread of increasingly unhinged whinging. In my first comment I made a joke in your support. In my second I explained the joke and observed that immigration isn't so bad. Only after you displayed a real commitment to a weird paranoia about racism did I start pressing that button.

Some people aren't clever enough for dog whistles.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:44PM (#17649284)
> You're protesting against what people believe? What does that even mean?

It means, when and where I encounter people propagating a false claim (that enforcing the law as written, regardless of race, is racist....that opposition to open borders is racist.....claims that people are calling for extermination of people with identifiable characteristics such race/religion/etc or using a number of well known dog whistles against those groups), I will point out the lies, as there seems to be a growing problem of people believing absolute nonsense without thinking, just because they've heard it so many times.

> Do you expect everyone to believe what you believe?

I expect people to make an attempt at sorting out lies vs the truth. Do you honestly think I "expect everyone to believe what I believe?"

> There is no chance that the resulting Congress will vote to eliminate borders

The fact that I've made no such claim is abundantly clear by simply reviewing this comment thread. Here, I'll give you a handy tip on how to self-detect when you've made an error in thinking: take what you think I said, and then post an excerpt from my words where I said it. You'll find you can't do it.

Another thing to look out for in your own behavior is obviously emotional based statements and insults, such as: "You're crying about something that cannot happen. That isn't rational. Why aren't you rational?"

> We have our suspicions.

What does this refer to?

> Only after you displayed a real commitment to a weird paranoia about racism did I start pressing that button.

Shameful. You very well know a large portion of the public is very vocal about their belief that enforcing existing immigration law is "racist". Or, will you continue your disingenuous, dishonest claims that you have no idea what I refer to? Then try this: https://www.google.com/search?q=trump+border+racist

PS: Cool it on the personal insults. Stick to the facts. Check your emotions at the door. Think.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by jessaustin on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:15PM (#17650278)
'mistermann I just took a look at your recent comments here on HN, and I think you've failed the Turing Test. People keep telling you to focus, to consider, to be more open-minded. Instead like an automaton you post screen after screen of your intensely personal impressions of others' impressions of your impressions of whatever-the-hell-it-was-we-were-talking-about-but-we've-all-forgotten-now. You complain when anyone uses humor or shorthand or exaggeration, all of which are human expressions that might confuse or upset a machine. You complain when anyone narrows or broadens the subject of discussion. You model the mental states of others in a rigid fashion: you're far more likely to say people are lying than that they simply have a different opinion than you.

I'm not sure: what is the HN policy on the participation of rudimentary AI? You may not be tall enough for this ride. Great nick though.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by mistermann on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:51AM (#17650841)
I can answer questions, and provide specific references to back any assertions I make.

Can you?

You've made several accusations above, can you substantiate them, without changing the subject?

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by maym86 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:21PM (#17605054)
It's easy to start drawing the line at the low hanging fruit. Let's start with holocaust denial which Zuckerberg raised last week. This argument that it's complex doesn't mean we can't do something and act in the most agregious and obvious cases.

Facebook already censors for business reasons and draws lines. Why can't they do it in other places and make it clear where they are. Their objections are based on free speech but are likely really about cost - they don't want to spend money to do it.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by vkou on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:29PM (#17605111)
The same can be said about pornography, and Facebook has no issue with drawing a wobbly line on that subject. They ban porn, they ban maybe-porn, and they sometimes ban things-that-are-probably-not-porn-but-let's-be-safe-and-ban-it-anyways.

They don't want pornography on their website. That's all there is to it. It speaks a lot about their position on it: "Not on our platform."

That they refuse to draw a line about holocaust deniers speaks volumes. Specifically, it speaks that they are perfectly fine with being a platform for white nationalism.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by sah2ed on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:09PM (#17605360)
> They don't want pornography on their website.

They wont allow it because they thoroughly understand the effects of positive feedback loops if they had allowed a tiny bit of porn even partially. See Tumblr.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by bonaldi on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:29PM (#17605464)
But they deny any such effect at all when it comes to fascist content. Dynamic is exactly the same; appeal is thankfully more limited.

This whole situation is risible. Did everyone ignore the real meaning of “meme”? Some ideas are like viruses in more ways than one. It’s time we brought hygiene and basic plumbing into the information Wild West

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by brandonmenc on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:33PM (#17605137)
> That they refuse to draw a line about holocaust deniers speaks volumes. Specifically, it speaks that they are perfectly fine with being a platform for white nationalism.

Whites are far from being the only people who deny the Holocaust.

Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by vkou on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:41PM (#17605188)
White nationalist groups are not the only ones who do, but they are the most popular, influential, and scariest ones.
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by drak0n1c on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:24PM (#17605450)
Please cite sources on popularity, influence, and scariness before you ascribe total responsibility to a single sub-group. The fact that multiple governments and millions of people around the world endorse Holocaust denial ranks higher on the threat scale to me, as a Jewish American, than the far fewer and less locally-popular white nationalists here in the west.

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/05/th...

[dead]
Re:Departing Facebook security officer advocated for shifts ... by drak0n1c on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:03PM (#17605918)
You wouldn't say "He isn't marching with Black Lives Matter, who want to make America a communist dictatorship" just because someone claimed to see Black Bloc anarchists at a BLM event or because a Maoist offered words of support, would you? If a partisan pundit claimed that their activities and attitude enables extremists, and that was all that was needed to label them extremists too, I would dispute that characterization as well.

Proud Boys oppose white nationalism as one of their core rules and a number of their NYC members are Jewish men. They're constantly taunted by skinheads online and have expelled trolls attempting to hijack their events.

PS: You have a good point about naive ignorance - but the form of malicious and hateful ignorance we both identify as toxic is still borne out by statistics to be more common in the Middle East and North Africa than it is in the west. Due to it being sanctioned by multiple governments there, it affects me personally (I am actually not allowed to visit certain countries) and geopolitically in the form of strife/taxation, and migration (European Jews wearing kippah are now facing street harassment in prejudiced neighborhoods). I do not believe that saying this makes me hateful, I would love to wave a wand and get along with whoever may hate me for bad reasons - I am just assessing the practical level of anti-Semitism that is out in the world and how it ends up actually affecting my non-digital life. Trust me, the vast majority of anti-Semites are not taking the lead from white nationalists.