However, you can define meaningful algebras in which division by 0 is not only trivially allowed, but also equal to infinity. This is possible by extending the complexes, for example. More generally, see [2].
Note I’m speaking strictly of the math here. I can’t comment on this usage in physics specifically. But there’s no issue with defining 1/0 = ∞ if the rest of the theory remains fundamentally consistent.
______
No, ∞ is not an element of the real or complex fields, that's correct. But it is an element of the extended real and complex number systems, according to the following rules:
for all x ∈ ℝ:
1) - ∞ < x < + ∞,
2) x + ∞ = + ∞, x - ∞ = - ∞,
3) (x / + ∞) = (x / - ∞) = 0,
4) x > 0 ==> x(+ ∞) = + ∞, x(- ∞) = - ∞,
5) x < 0 ==> x(+ ∞) = - ∞, x(- ∞) = + ∞
Infinity is not just an artifact of limit notation, because the algebraic rules defined here formalize the analytic theory underlying calculus. This set is distinct from the hyperreals for a number of reasons (most importantly, it's not a field). But just because it's not a field doesn't mean it's not a coherent algebra. Which really circles back to the original point: you can usefully define an algebra such that division by 0 is not undefined.In particular, note that by augmenting ℝ with +∞, -∞, we can derive (x / 0) = ∞ from the third rule. This behavior is only very slightly pathological because 1) it's (mostly) contained to the infinities, and 2) it still mostly preserves the order, completeness, addition and multiplication properties of the real numbers themselves. It's just not a field because we cannot do some propositional things that follow from Peano arithmetic (e.g. cancellation) and we can't e.g. take square roots of infinity.
To make this point even more technical, we can choose to define numbers as cardinalities of sets under Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory instead of under Peano arithmetic. This allows us to neatly define arithmetic involving infinities via operations on infinite sets.
Physicists have very good intuition but sometimes making their statements mathematically rigorous requires extra work. I think a good example is in the history of field theory. Over time the intuition was made into something more formal. The article in the OP discusses renormalisation.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projectively_extended_real_lin...
There are several places in physics where you encounter infinities, the most prominent case probably is the aforementioned uncertainty principle, which leads to 'loops' in QED and need to be countered by renormalization[0].
> 1/0
Infinity
Q.E.D.
unless you want to claim that javascript is occasionaly illdefined.
lim (x->0⁺) 1/x = ∞
> There is a duality between zero and infinity, expressed in the elementary identity 1/0 = ∞.
I understand what they're saying here - but I was always under the impression that, rather than yielding infinity, division by zero was undefined. Wikipedia [1] says that this is true "In ordinary arithmetic", but goes on to say that it is "sometimes useful" to think of a "formal calculation" involving division by zero as evaluating to infinity. A formal calculation seems to be one that ignores whether the result is well defined.
Would anyone care to comment on whether the mathematical perspective above carries over into the physics domain?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Division_by_zero