News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Lazare on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:50PM (#17597755)
> The idea is very simple – if Portugal owes Ireland €0.34bn of short term debt, and Ireland owes Portugal €0.17bn

Yes, it's a simple idea. And the reality is even simpler; they don't owe each other those amounts. Rather, a large number of individuals are owed those amounts. If I, a private individual, own a $1k bond issued by Portugal, and you owe a $1k bond issued by Ireland, obviously we can't just say that sums to zero. Nor can we do so even if I happen to be in Ireland and you happen to be in Portugal.

This whole thing is a non-starter, grounded on the most absurd assumptions with no bearing on reality. If we're just going to make things up, why not just assume that all interest rates are zero; now the debt burden is totally manageable.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:23AM (#17599078)
> This whole thing is a non-starter

This is a pedagogical, not practical, exercise:

“Aim. To give students experience of researching important data and to conduct a policy-relevant negotiation exercise. [1]”

Bob the Irishman owes Billy the Belgian €1 in 10 years at 9%; Guillaume the Belgian owes Shannon the Irishwoman €1 in 7 years at 3%. These obviously don't cancel out.

[1] http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1046878116645252

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Niksko on Monday July 23, 2018 @11:47PM (#17597976)
The author is a professor of economics at what is apparently the oldest business school in Europe, and is apparently also one of the most prestigious business schools in France.

Despite this, you have concluded that in fact the author has failed to understand the nuance of the situation rather than yourself.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Lazare on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:51AM (#17598197)
> you have concluded that in fact the author has failed to understand the nuance of the situation rather than yourself.

By no means; I'm sure the author is being purposefully misleading; I highly doubt it was mere accident. :)

In any case, your blatant appeal to authority is not needed; the linked article was kind enough to provide sources, and it's the work of a moment to check them.

"Overall gross external (or foreign) debt is taken from the latest 2011 World Bank/IMF figures and includes all debt owed overseas, including that owed by governments, monetary authorities, banks and companies."

Man, I guess just because you work for a prestigious business school you might not be above making a misleading graph to advance a political argument! Who knew?

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by dalbasal on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:18AM (#17599942)
This is pure paranoia.

The "author" is conducting a learning exercise. There is no sign of a political argument, nevermind a political point here.

He's focusing on certain elements and not others because that's what he has data for, and that's what the exercise is about. The data he's got is bonds: bank bonds, government bonds & corporate bonds. That's what he's playing with, trying to see how this information can be unpacked, analyzed and understood. I haven't seen the actual exercise but I assume students might be able to do things like "how can we cancel the maximum debt with the minimum number of transactions?" The fact that this does not consider relative bond ratings, macroeconomic effects or whatever else you care about is a red herring.

Every economic model everywhere simplifies reality. Otherwise nothing is fungible/general and nothing can be modelled.

You ascribing sinister motives is you being blinded by whatever you think is the important debate in economics.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by close04 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:19AM (#17600712)
That's not paranoia. He misunderstood what this is about, jumped to conclusions, and now can't backtrack. Notice how Lazare started by rejecting the validity of the exercise as:

> "absurd assumptions with no bearing on reality"

But the argument suddenly turned into rejecting the credibility and motivation of the person proposing it as:

> "making a misleading graph to advance a political argument".

Also while his "demonstrations" kinda' sorta' make sense when viewed from the plane, it's the details that are completely off that give away that there's no formal knowledge or training behind them but a mish-mash of ideas probably gathered from the media, internet, and his personal conclusions and assumptions.

The whole line of reasoning for this discussion is that all physics problems that assume the ideal gas, the perfect sphere, etc. are unrealistic, so they are political statements. Don't feed the troll.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by raverbashing on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:02AM (#17598476)
> The diagrams above show the before and after situation, based on analysis done by students. The simulation itself took place on May 17th 2011 and involved three separate trading rounds.

> Students in the Pre-Masters Year of the ESCP Europe Masters in Management program took part in the trial run on March 22, 2011, which involved only the PIIGS countries. The key results were the following:

It's a student experiment

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by voodootrucker on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:36AM (#17598140)
The grandparent included arguments relevant to the debate.

The above comment is merely an appeal to authority.

If there are facts that support it, I would love to see them posted here, so as to forward the discussion.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by zhte415 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:08AM (#17601683)
It isn't really about nuance. Cost and return of capital, convexity of yield curve spring to mind.

It is a student project.. treat as no more.

[dead]
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by close04 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:34AM (#17600821)
That would be the state in which everyone thinks an internet connection and an audience makes them an expert?
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by cinquemb on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:22AM (#17598096)
Wake me up when BNP or DB tap this author on the shoulder to help manage their derivatives book.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by kurthr on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:01AM (#17598464)
It's interesting that you're so confident that it's impossible. How were those euro debts held by Ireland reduced by 97%? I'm going to assume you're an expert so it should be pretty obvious from the absurd source data they released.

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/31011519/EU%20Debt%20Wri...

My guess is that the largest majority of debt is held by ECB and the banks (e.g by Greece held in Germany) who had their own debts written off (e.g. Landes banks) or held at negative yields for a decade through quantitative easing.

The implication of your statements is that a significant portion of bonds are held by individuals, and yet my knowledge of the US market in 2008 would indicate that maybe 10% are held by non-institutional players.

Real US rates were negative for years 2009-2014, but maybe the ECB didn't do that, although I remember hearing they had.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Lazare on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:18AM (#17598529)
> The implication of your statements is that a significant portion of bonds are held by individuals

No, mostly banks and other large institutions. The ECB only holds about 1/5 (2 trillion out of about 10 trillion).

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by dalbasal on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:32AM (#17599116)
Did you guys look at the link?

First it's about a classroom expirement, not a monetary policy.

Second, the exercise is to learn about the exact things you two are speculating about.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by kurthr on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:35AM (#17600836)
Yes, I looked at the link. But the claim (I was questioning) is that it's full of lies and absurdities to further political ends.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by nutjob2 on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:54PM (#17597771)
Exactly - who owns and owes these debts exactly? It's clearly not the same counterparties since they would have netted out their debt long ago, in an accounting sense if not in cash.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by falsedan on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:20AM (#17599633)
I think the point is to simulate what trades are necessary for the same counterparties to be creditor and debitor for these loans/debts so precisely this could happen.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by dmurray on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:31AM (#17600022)
It becomes true if you permanently nationalize all the banks! Then virtually all the debt really is issued and owned by governments.

That's not too far off what happened in the relevant countries after the last financial crisis, but far enough off to make a big difference (e.g. it would defeat the purpose of leaving one or two "good" banks per country that did not get nationalized)

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by jessedhillon on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:11AM (#17598063)
In its most basic form, the plan would be that Portugal would stop paying Irish bondholders and vice versa. Each country would make the former creditors of the other whole from the payments it no longer makes.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Lazare on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:04AM (#17598237)
That's an interesting idea, however note:

1) There's a reason why an Portuguese pension fund might hold Irish debt rather than Portuguese debt; for example, wanting to hedge and diversify, earn higher returns, or have lower risks. Forcibly swapping the debt gives them an investment they didn't want, and doesn't really "make them whole".

2) It costs just as much to pay back a Portuguese pensioner who owns one of your bonds as an Irish one; this swap does nothing for government finances. Which is why this also is totally not the plan being discussed.

The article talks about "The countries can reduce their total debt..."; you're talking about reducing the exchange rate risk of the debt. There's no real overlap here.

Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by jessedhillon on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:11AM (#17609331)
Your (1) is a good point. Regarding the rest, there's no exchange rate risk between two euro-zone countries.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:10AM (#17598505)
There isn't even any exchange rate risk as both Ireland and Portugal are in the Euro.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by garmaine on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:07AM (#17599269)
Nope; if a country leaves the euro it suddenly matters which banks’s name is on your debt notes.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:33AM (#17599371)
That's true although we haven't seen any country leave yet.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by icebraining on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:09AM (#17600259)
Does it? Aren't they Euro-denominated anyway?
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by garmaine on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:10PM (#17602359)
No a Greek-issued euro debt instrument would become a new currency decoupled from the euro with a floating exchange rate if Greece left the euro, for example. That’s what all the hooplah a few years back was about.
Re:The Great EU Debt Write Off (2012) by Pamar on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:49AM (#17598422)
Maybe he is "alluding" at dismantling the Euro?