News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The childless, aging future by patrickg_zill on Sunday July 22, 2018 @05:51PM (#17589119)
Growing up in Canada (now living in usa) every student was propagandized about how population growth was bad, etc.

Now we are told how much immigration is indispensable i.e. more people are needed.

Were we lied to?

Re:The childless, aging future by CapitalistCartr on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:51PM (#17589324)
In Asia, population growth is a problem. Canada can benefit from more people. Vast tracts of empty land; vast, still-untapped natural resources; 37 million people in 9 million square km.; sound infrastructure; educated, productive populace.

India has about 1.3 billion people in under 3.3 million square km. with 1/6 Canada's per capita GDP. Population is a huge problem for them.

If Canada were to double its population in this century, they'd probably be better off. If the World does, we'll be screwed.

Re:The childless, aging future by patrickg_zill on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:07PM (#17589377)
The actual arable land is much less, however. As well as habitable land, that is, places most people would feel comfortable living in year-round.

Agricultural yields per acre or hectare are often less than in the USA, as well.

Re:The childless, aging future by reustle on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:48AM (#17591618)
> Vast tracts of empty land; vast, still-untapped natural resources

You say it like it's a bad thing :)

Re:The childless, aging future by Chyzwar on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:44PM (#17589301)
Uncontrolled population growth is bad (Africa) - infrastructure, ecology, political stability. Lack of skilled workers is bad (technology) - innovation, productivity, economy. It is not one of another. It depends.
Re:The childless, aging future by cup on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:50PM (#17589320)
"Uncontrolled population growth is bad (Africa)"

What do you even mean by this statement?

Re:The childless, aging future by squirrelicus on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:05PM (#17589372)
Let me give him the benefit of the doubt and suggest he's not talking about direct population control. I think this is reasonable because, well, nobody suggests this.

By giving food and economic aid to African countries (the small portion that actually goes to the people after the dictator filter) we subsidize their birth rate in an unsustainable way. Specifically, if the Western counties that support them have an economic crash, for example, and become no longer able to support them, they'll be left with mouths they can't feed. Mouths they never could feed on their own. It will be a tragic loss of life.

Re:The childless, aging future by Nasrudith on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:43PM (#17589506)
The thing is population growth is sensitive to needs - people reproduce more for their needs whether more farm labor or "social security". Giving people security paradoxically causes people to reproduce less if they can be sure that three survive to adulthood no need to go with eight children unless they have a farm.

Essentially humans are K/r adaptive - if they are risky they go r (quantity). If they are safer they tend to go K quality.

Re:The childless, aging future by icebraining on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:38PM (#17589484)
I agree that the dependence on outside help is dangerous, but I don't see why they could never feed themselves. Africa is still a fertile continent, and it has a much lower population density than Europe or Asia.
Re:The childless, aging future by DoreenMichele on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:14AM (#17590536)
If you want to understand it, read Diet for a small planet. It is famous for being a vegetarian cookbook, but that's only the last half of it. The first half is a political piece about how no country at that time was incapable of feeding its own people -- assuming they stuck to traditional local diets, had peace, etc.

Starvation is often caused by war. It is often essentially a means to beat one side without going to battle.

When aid is sent, it may rot on the docks or be resold to fatten the pockets of local corrupt politicians.

When it gets distributed at all, it is typically Western fare. You now have locals who could afford the traditional local vegetarian diet craving hamburgers and French fries that they can't afford.

When loans are given to developing countries, the need for hard currency to pay it back means locals raise beef to sell to other countries to pay the loans while people go hungry at home.

Etc

And I have just realised this book is part of why I didn't really want a handout while homeless. This book is why I understood I needed earned income of my own, not charity, and how insidious charity can be in destroying your ability to make your own life work.

Re:The childless, aging future by icebraining on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:10AM (#17591490)
Thanks for the suggestion!
Re:The childless, aging future by mnm1 on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:03AM (#17590503)
Giving aid to counties essentially guts the local economy. Local businesses cannot compete and therefore the local economy never develops. The people become entirely dependent on outside help even when otherwise they would develop their own economy and self-sustaining systems. When you take that aid away, there is famine and death. Foreign aid is one of the biggest causes of poverty currently but slowly people are starting to realize that giving aid and gutting local economies is much worse than not giving at all. There is an excellent documentary on this on Netflix I think but the name escapes me right now. I think they even convince Bono that what he is doing is causing more harm than good (giving fish rather than teaching how to fish). It definitely is.
Re:The childless, aging future by Broken_Hippo on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:00PM (#17589770)
There are issues with both things. Population growth is bad for ecological reasons, and there have been fears of simply not being able to provide food and clean water for the earth's population. Family sizes didn't really go down immediately once we figured out modern hygiene and medicine practices (many children died before modern times).

We have a better handle on much of this, in part due better ways of turning ocean water into fresh drinking water. Of course, we are still suffering from pollution and waste issues that theoretically would go down as the population drops.

On the other hand, we have uneven population growth, so some places are still exploding (Africa and some asian countries, for example). Birth control isn't readily available to all, neither is some modern hygiene and medicine. Population growth is still a problem for parts of the world.

On the other hand, other populations are shrinking and people aren't having enough children to simply replace their parents. This creates all sorts of issues in itself. Partly because of manpower issues: Who is going to take care of the elderly? Will we have enough doctors, nurses, and farmers in these areas? And things of that nature.

Some countries have addressed this through sex education, teaching both how to avoid pregnancy and how to get pregnant (and things that go along with that). Others have not. The best-bet solutions would be things like more service jobs and more automation where humans don't need to physically work, robots for care, and more open immigration policies so countries that are having overpopulation issues can freely relocate to countries with shrinking populations.

IT wasn't that you were lied to, it is just a complicated situation that has changed over time.

Re:The childless, aging future by slavik81 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:50PM (#17589318)
That doesn't match either my experience living in Canada for thirty years, nor does it match the history I have read.

Canada has had an the immigration rate of ~0.7% of the population since at least the 1960s. It's long been among the highest in per capita immigration rates among countries of its size, and it is one of the few western nations in which public support for immigration has remained consistently strong.

Re:The childless, aging future by civility on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:10PM (#17589181)
A lot of people go around predicting calamity... They’re usually wrong. Generally not liars, just evolved monkeys who are trying to avoid problems.
Re:The childless, aging future by xapata on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:15PM (#17589408)
Calamity prediction may be right in estimating odds, despite being wrong in outcome. Wearing a seatbelt is still wise, despite never having crashed a car.

Do you buy insurance?

Re:The childless, aging future by AFNobody on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:00PM (#17589153)
More population is bad for ecological reasons.

More population is vital for economic reasons.

Its two competing philosophies. (i.e. Do the financially practical things for an individual/country vs. the wisest thing for the collective species)

Re:The childless, aging future by kelnos on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:22PM (#17589641)
I think saying "for economic reasons" doesn't really paint the whole picture.

It's not just about "growing the economy", it's about ensuring that the economy is strong enough to support the population as it ages people out of the workforce.

Re:The childless, aging future by AFNobody on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:00PM (#17590035)
True, it is that too.
Re:The childless, aging future by forkLding on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:00PM (#17589768)
Objectively, I think Canada does need more population growth, be it either immigration or more children from Canadians.

I think people under-estimated the impact of working educated women and modern financial constraints on having more children and thus projected Canadian growth more aggressively than it is so not a deliberate lie.

Immigration in Canada is definitely needed as we've been under the replacement rate for 40 yrs and it will be very hard with such a small population albeit declining and maintain the country in terms of taxes, pensions etc.

Re:The childless, aging future by sonnyblarney on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:23PM (#17589865)
"Immigration in Canada is definitely needed as we've been under the replacement rate for 40 yrs "

I find this bizarre.

If people are not having enough kids than the 1st-order solution is to 'have more kids'. Not 'bring in others' - that would somewhere down the list of solutions.

There are plenty of things that can be done to encourage this, but they're not even trying. It's not even a policy. In Quebec, they have socialized early stage childcare and that seems to have actually made some of a difference.

"Objectively, I think Canada does need more population growth,"

As a Canadian, I don't see for a moment why this is true.

Most newcomers go to Toronto, Van or Montreal - Toronto has doubled in size since I was a kid and it can take 4 hours to drive from end to end: a sea of identical looking homes, malls and Starbuckses. Vancouver has become one of the most unaffordable places in the world to live. It's like SF but with much lower wages.

Contrary to reasonable intuition - in the last 30 years, as we have increased 'diversity' in our population, paradoxically our industrial base has become less diverse. We are no more than ever dependent on basic things like banking, making cars, exporting natural resources and construction. In addition, our ability to make sophisticated products has gone down. Switzerland and the US lead the pack with creating high-end exports like software, financial services, drugs, machinery. UK, Germany, France, Japan do well there. But Canada has gone down on the value chain. This is illustrated by the weird trade paradox Canada has with China: China buys raw materials from Canada and sells finished goods back to Canada, but usually the mapping is the other way around for 'rich/poor' countries, i.e. US buys raw materials from 'some poor place' and that 'poor place' buys iPhones, software and machinery from the US.

I think we really need to think about sustainability in population and it starts first with families, and then includes migration as a secondary but important factor.

Re:The childless, aging future by mnm1 on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:11AM (#17590523)
You can't possibly expect to compete with Switzerland and the US on technology when salaries are two to three times lower in Canada and housing costs like Vancouver and Toronto exist. Immigrants might be willing to work for less but I doubt Canadians will especially when they can drive a few hours south and make two, there, or more times the salary.
Re:The childless, aging future by sonnyblarney on Monday July 23, 2018 @01:09AM (#17590708)
"You can't possibly expect to compete with Switzerland and the US on technology when salaries are two to three times lower in Canada"

Maybe if Canadian companies paid competitively the talent would stay.

Point being, that's an issue of equilibrium.

The problem in my mind is product leadership. Canada has ample technical talent, but few are thinking in brand, product marketing terms etc., also, there's a weird open relationship with the US. The US provides stability, and opportunity for people to develop, but they have to leave so. So the US-CAN symbiosis basically turns Canada into a 'nice suburb' where things are generally very good, but there's nothing very important happening. The talent/exceptional things happen south of the border.

But in the context of migration, it's definitely an odd paradox that as 'cultural diversity' increases, that 'industrial diversity and sophistication' decreases. They may not be drivers of each other though ... the later may be a function of globalization, NAFTA etc..

Re:The childless, aging future by forkLding on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:18AM (#17591516)
I wasn't talking about technological change etc, moreover the USA and Switzerland has a higher immigration rate than us and a bigger immigrant population either by number or proportion (https://www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/opinion/were-missing-the...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_the_United_St...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Switzerland).

I was talking about how elderly people would get increasingly less of their pensions or benefits if there are less young people to pay govt. taxes in the future because of a declining population below the replacement rate as you can see in Japan. I think you're a bit politically charged in thinking that I was talking about cultural diversity or industrial base, it could be just encouraging more White European immigrants if thats what you want, note that I even said increase more kids from Canadians in my first comment, doesn't have to specify the immigrant population but rather needs to resolve the number of workers per elderly person as I was trying to look at an objective economical data perspective and to increase labour supply via economics.

Moreover, continuing on my argument, Canada has an aging population and more seniors than children (https://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/what-the-census-tells-us...) and it will be hard to maintain productivity with an growing aging population especially if estimates put one in four canadians will be above 65 by 2031 although it can be a flawed projection.

Moreover, most Canadian immigrants have to meet quotas as either having some kind of skill or some kind of degree before being able to immigrate, refugees is still a small number so if not economically productive, its not because of lack of skills (https://www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/opinion/were-missing-the...)

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/amp/opinion/were-missing-the...

Re:The childless, aging future by sonnyblarney on Monday July 23, 2018 @03:25PM (#17595201)
Neither the US nor Switzerland have a higher immigrant population in the sense that Canada does.

The US has many more migrants but they make up a little less of the population.

Switzerland has an altogether view on migrants - they have a high rate of 'foreigners' but they are ultimately ex-pats. Canada brings in people to settle, Switzerland brings in people for labour.

I have no idea what you are on about regarding 'charged politics' or 'white immigrants'.

As someone who actively hires immigrants in Canada from all over the world, I'm aware of the system, their level of education etc.

The solution to Canada's aging population is mostly to accept that we are now living a very long time, and most of that time is not productive, which means slightly lower standard of living. Second - more babies and the policies that ensue.

Immigration is a helper to the above, not a primary solution.

Re:The childless, aging future by forkLding on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:30PM (#17596203)
The reason why I emphasize immigration is because it is much harder and more expensive to increase the supply of babies via policy as the current trend we've seen is of less babies as people become more educated and it takes a much longer time to raise kids until they become productive and their lives may go in the wrong direction in the growing-up process. Its much more easily just to bring in skilled immigrants or immigrants with money and to settle them in Canada and then either get rid or integrate them dependant on their actions.
Re:The childless, aging future by tzahola on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:08PM (#17589173)
Don’t rock the boat!