Re:Getting Started with DNS over HTTPS on Firefox
by tptacek on Saturday July 21, 2018 @10:12AM
(#17582040)
This doesn't make any sense. First, it's plainly obvious that we could design replacements for essentially any protocol. Second, the fundamental design problems that would motivate and be corrected in a new DNSSEC are obvious:
* Offline signers was a mistake, since virtually all leaf authority servers are online signers due to the NSEC debacle.
* A protocol with less than 20% saturation in 2018 that expects to be deployed would be based on a modern signature scheme, not RSA.
Just altering those two elements of the design would allow for a radically improved protocol.
I'm 41 years old. The DNSSEC design being promoted right now was started when I was still in high school, during the phlogiston era of cryptographic protocol design. It is lunacy to believe that it is the best thing we can come up with.
* Offline signers was a mistake, since virtually all leaf authority servers are online signers due to the NSEC debacle.
* A protocol with less than 20% saturation in 2018 that expects to be deployed would be based on a modern signature scheme, not RSA.
Just altering those two elements of the design would allow for a radically improved protocol.
I'm 41 years old. The DNSSEC design being promoted right now was started when I was still in high school, during the phlogiston era of cryptographic protocol design. It is lunacy to believe that it is the best thing we can come up with.