News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Friday July 20, 2018 @03:12PM (#17577972)
They are re-living their 2003-2004 period when the IBM PPC G5 CPU was way too hot and power hungry to put in the PowerBook and it needed water cooling in the PowerMac. Back then their solution was to switch to Intel CPUs. Now it's probably going to be to switch to in-house designed ARM CPUs.
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by charlesism on Friday July 20, 2018 @04:15PM (#17578538)
It's a terrible argument, but I agree it's probably how Apple views things. If they're willing to sacrifice build-quality, ports, and a decent keyboard all in the name of thinness... I suppose adding a fraction of an inch of headroom in the bottom case is unthinkable to them.
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Friday July 20, 2018 @04:53PM (#17578829)
Analysed in a vacuum yes, it's a terrible argument. But if you look at it through Apple magnifying glass it makes sense. They are locked on the objective of making their devices thin enough to be able to shave with one of them and whatever Intel is doing is no longer fitting this concept.

One other thing Apple is aiming for is to go back to fully controlling the development and integration of their products. This means the HW and the SW. It worked just fine for them with the phones, admittedly a segment where no major architectural/compatibility changes were needed.

We'll get to see if they can pull it off in a segment where the compatibility is a huge burden. Microsoft tried and failed perhaps for this very reason: no control over the HW. Also an even bigger burden of legacy (likely the biggest of any SW company). But Apple already managed to transition from 68000 to PPC to x86. They'd really set a hard to beat record if they manage to move to ARM even if just for the regular laptop lines (Air, MB) and not the Pros.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Friday July 20, 2018 @03:29PM (#17578124)
> in-house designed ARM CPUs.

What could possibly go wrong!

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Friday July 20, 2018 @05:06PM (#17578941)
With the CPU design or the transition to a new ISA? Lots of things can go wrong at any time even by doing nothing. But Apple does have a team of pretty good engineers that managed to design what's probably the fastest (best?) ARM cores on the market, and with good enough perf/Watt numbers. So I doubt their biggest hurdle will be to design a CPU.

It will be to split the "MacOS" ecosystem in 2 and maintain two branches for x86 and ARM. And while they also have a team of pretty good software engineers with x86 and ARM experience they are already having major quality control problems lately. Having to maintain a dual ISA MacOS will be a challenge. Then they have to provide the legacy compatibility in order to convince people to buy into something with little to no support for most of what's out there today.

But you know... we could use some diversity in this space. I wish them all the best.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Friday July 20, 2018 @05:20PM (#17579031)
@394549, I don't doubt that they can do it, as I was also saying a couple of comments above this one. But at what price? The difference is that now they have big QA issues before having to maintain the 2 branches. Their software (and possibly the software team) a decade and a half ago when they were moving to Intel was in a lot better shape. Unless I'm looking at this through nostalgia goggles. :)
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Friday July 20, 2018 @05:26PM (#17579081)
They were also moving to a well established architecture from their own bespoke one and now they’re going the other way ...
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Friday July 20, 2018 @06:37PM (#17579567)
ARM is a well established ISA. The customization Apple might bring to the CPU architecture will make no difference to a user as long as the compatibility is there.

The problem is that as established as ARM is they really don't have a meaningful presence in the desktop/laptop ecosystem. You have probably tens of thousands of apps for the mobile space but even if Apple magically adapted them for a non-touchscreen, keyboard and touchpad world the vast majority still won't cater to the regular or professional user wanting to buy a laptop, not a glorified tablet. And that's a hard sell. Why am I buying a MacBook if all I get is an iPad with a keyboard? And don't get me wrong, having used both iPads and CoreM ultraportables (Apple or otherwise) the iPad offered the better experience more often than not. But if I compare it to the regular CPU it just can't compete. The productivity with mobile apps is not where it should be to convince a normal buyer to switch, let alone a more demanding user.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Saturday July 21, 2018 @05:05AM (#17581346)
> The problem is that as established as ARM is they really don't have a meaningful presence in the desktop/laptop ecosystem

Yes. Not established. That’s what I said.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by close04 on Saturday July 21, 2018 @06:02AM (#17581478)
"Not established" and "not established in a specific segment" are two vastly different things. So no, most definitely I didn't say what you said, or what you think I said. ;)
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:53AM (#17591635)
Aye, but you said what I meant.

Look at another way - Apple moved from PowerPC to Intel. It's not that Motorola ISA weren't well established but they simply weren't as well established and didn't have access to the same mindshare in terms of high performance hardware and software engineering.

So in this sense it's a step back the other way - except for perhaps Intel seem to be stuck in the mire these days.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by 394549 on Friday July 20, 2018 @05:15PM (#17579000)
> It will be to split the "MacOS" ecosystem in 2 and maintain two branches for x86 and ARM. And while they also have a team of pretty good software engineers with x86 and ARM experience they are already having major quality control problems lately. Having to maintain a dual ISA MacOS will be a challenge. Then they have to provide the legacy compatibility in order to convince people to buy into something with little to no support for most of what's out there today.

They've done that twice before (68k -> PPC, PPC -> Intel), and IIRC, seem to be preparing to do it again (Bitcode).

I think the biggest risk for Apple is that they may not be able to keep up with x86 on the desktop performance front. They have a much smaller market to amortize the R&D over than Intel does.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Friday July 20, 2018 @05:27PM (#17579089)
The biggest risk for Apple is they’ve become a shiny things company and don’t really have the engineering stones for doing this kind of thing any more
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by edbaskerville on Friday July 20, 2018 @03:52PM (#17578348)
Many things could go wrong, but the Apple codebases and engineering processes should be pretty robust to architecture changes at this point. NeXT went from 68030 to Intel/SPARC/others, and then to PowerPC with Mac OS X. OS X went from PowerPC to Intel. And large chunks of it are shared with iOS on ARM already.

(Fun fact: even classic Mac OS was running on Intel at one point before the 680x0-to-PowerPC transition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek_project)

So there's good reason to think that they could pull this off.

Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by charlesism on Friday July 20, 2018 @04:17PM (#17578559)
I have very little confidence it will be a smooth transition this time. Apple now is not the same people, and not the same culture as it was then. I don't see them sweating the details over Mac hardware.
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Friday July 20, 2018 @04:13PM (#17578518)
That’s an awful lot of hope
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by lostlogin on Friday July 20, 2018 @03:40PM (#17578234)
A lot. But imagine what could go right. The thing I most want is battery life, but I hope that isn’t squandered by translating it to thinness.
Re:Apple fans returning new MacBook Pros with Core i9 by rusk on Friday July 20, 2018 @03:43PM (#17578271)
> imagine what could go right

.