First, because it's impossible to actually validate anything. If you read a quote from a politician, you can only evaluate the quote's accuracy by considering the publisher's track record, and the politician's previous behaviour. Videos and audio are often not available, and can possibly be faked rather well now or in the near future.
Even if some sort of proof were possible, the workload would far outstrip any single person's capabilities.
Analogy: You don't ask your spouse for collateral when they want to borrow your car. Because you know and trust them, and they are invested in a good, continuing relationship with you. It's different if a stranger comes up to you on the street and asks for your car keys.
That's why societies' have come up with a sort of collaborative verification: get together as a group that trusts each other and split the workload. Or even allow people to specialize, and pay them for it. You can do your best to verify some subset of their work to assess their reliability.
The New York Times, as but one example: they have a 150+ year record of processes and individual commitment to get their facts straight, and they are open about their failures. Publishing stories about "XYZ runs a ring of pedophiles from a DC pizza parlor" would destroy their value almost instantly, so their incentives are aligned with yours.
This is textbook propaganda, so perfect you could use it as classroom material.
Furthermore, we hear so much about social media filter bubbles, but it doesn't seem to occur to contemporary reporters that if they write stories based on what they see and hear on their own social feed, it is going to be equally skewed and subject to a massive preselected availability bias of their own making.
If you wanted to effectively manipulate the news, you'd organize massive protests and disruptions right outside every news station... Well, now this is the default mode for much of what you hear. Every time you read any story about online sentiment that is not explicitly statistical and honest and precise in its conclusions, it's pretty much bullshit from top to bottom for this reason.
Now, before you say this doesn't apply to "real" news in the "real" world, I remind you that the topics they haven't been able to shut up about for 5 minutes is Trump's tweeting, Russian trolls, and the online anger of a supposedly pervasive alt-right, and that they blame everything from Brexit to Charlottesville on that. This includes people who are frequently misquoted, misconstrued and misrepresented at a level that, if it isn't malice, is chronic and incurable professional incompetence.
Their incentives are not aligned with mine, because to me, truth and skepticism are foundational values.
---
So where to start? Let's start with the person who made the allegations. She is likely a literal psychopath. She ended up getting charged with attempted murder for trying to kill one boyfriend after the case was over. She somehow managed to get that reduced to 'contributing to the delinquency of a juvenile' and a handful of other minor charges and served 3 weekends in jail. 3 years later she went all the way and stabbed to death a different boyfriend. She's now in prison serving a 14 year sentence for murder.
What about the district attorney? He was literally "race baiting." He was running for election in an extremely close contest where the black vote was critical (the person who made the fake allegations was black, the victims were white). He apparently felt that going hard after these kids would help him get that vote. He won the democratic primary and then the general election by 833 votes. Fortunately it didn't really matter. It was revealed that not only did he lie in order to try to get the kids convicted, he also illegally withheld evidence that would have completely exonerated them. He was dismissed and disbarred after being found guilty on some 27 different ethics and other charges. That he's not in prison is a travesty.
It doesn't even end there. Apparently the lead investigator in the case, Mark Gottlieb, had it out for Duke players. He had a long history of disproportionate force, allegations of perjury, disproportionate response (e.g. arrest when the typical response was ticketing), and so on specifically against Duke players. And there's no doubt he was up to games during this investigation. He ended up killing himself.
The reason I mention all of these things is to emphasize how much of a shit show this case should have been from the get go. Again I just do not believe that the NYTimes would have been unable to dig up evidence to this end. Yet they did not present it this way, or even as remotely questionable. And in fact even tried to demonize the players in other articles - apparently one of the players and some friends had, at one time, gotten into a fight with another group of guys where somebody got punched! What a social deviant! Rolling Stone got much more flack for their case because it was an exclusive, but the complete lack of journalistic integrity by the Times exhibited in this case is something I find in no way less excusable.
---
The 'moral' of this is that the New York Times put their own social preferences and biases ahead of the raw truth of the story here. Even if they were genuinely unable to dig up the evidence on the case, they lost any and all notions of objectivity in their reporting. And that's dangerous in today's highly polarized times. And maybe more importantly this and their numerous other failures have in no way negatively affected their "value". People tend to be rather happy to excuse even quite egregious behavior and wrongs when it comes from sources that they want to believe. And that's really what I was getting at in holding institutions you agree with to the same standard of those that you don't. Imagine in some parallel dimension an equivalent of Fox News or whatever was running a story inciting a mob against the players, while the NYTimes ran an article objectively discussing the dubious merits of the case and increasing indicators that the case may not hold up to scrutiny. And then it turns out that the players were innocent. How would you view the reporting of our parallel dimension Fox News? Yet, of course it somehow seems so different when it comes from a source that we want to trust.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duke_lacrosse_case
[2] - https://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/30/sports/duke-players-pract...
I can't help but think that we ought to bring philosophy, formal logic, reasoning, and rhetoric courses down from select majors in higher education, and into primary education. And it ought to start young.
In particular it seems there are just two issues that could help people detect BS so much more easily:
- 1. Avoid emotional responses. If you see something that tugs at the heart strings, or hear of an awful story, there's a good chance it's fake or an outlier event being portrayed as something regular. This [1] is one of the most famous examples. What that's actually an image of is not cosmetic testing on animals, as it was portrayed as in social media, but the spaying/neutering of a large number of cats rescued from abusive conditions. The reason I say there is a "good chance" it's fake is because appeals to emotion are specifically geared at provoking a response people might not otherwise engage in.
- 2. Hold new things you expect to be true to the same scrutiny you'd hold new things you expect to be false. This one is really hard, but exploiting people by confirming their biases is perhaps even more effective (and dangerous) than exploiting emotional response. And a subpoint of this issue is that while honest mistakes are indeed a part of life, when there is a pattern of honest mistakes - they're probably not honest mistakes.
Granted educating people on critical thinking and emotional control is going to be an uphill battle, to put it mildly, but I think it's a wiser strategy than instead engaging in behavior that's predictably going to result in people calling each other shills. In an era of increasing political polarization, this is doubly dangerous.
[1] - https://i.imgur.com/SIMvJ6Z.jpg