Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:45PM
(#17559923)
Government is and has always been about law -- creating law, executing law, interpreting law, and enforcing law. Healthcare doesn't have a natural, direct relationship to law like prisons and courts do.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:49PM
(#17559963)
> Government is and has always been about law
Government has always been about the legitimatized application of force; the use of law as one of the key components of the legitimization of force is very old, but not essential to the concept government (it's essential to modern, and even many older, norms or models of government, though.)
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:15PM
(#17560198)
The principle of the rule of law says that all parties, even the government itself, are subject to the law. This would imply that any application of force on the government's part must only be done in the service of the law.
This is how government ought to be, and has been at least several times in the last 1000 years. The Magna Carta is famous for first codifying the rule of law principle.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by genericid on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:32PM
(#17560350)
If the principle of rule of law meant that a democratically elected government cannot use its powers to take care of its citizens, it would simply be a bad principle.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:41PM
(#17560430)
A democratically elected legislature's job is to write the will of the people into law.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by AngryData on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:47PM
(#17561921)
So if the people's will is guaranteed basic medical services available to all, I don't see what the problem there is.
Re:‘Star Citizen’ Court Case Reveals the Messy Reality of Cr...
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:19PM
(#17562527)
There needs to be a distinction between fundamental government functions (those that exist to establish the rule of law) and those that were created by law.
It's the fundamental government functions that should never be outsourced.
(If the people's will is that government take care of other matters, no problem. They can choose either way, provided the resulting laws are not unconstitutional.)