Re:Interview with Eric Lundgren about the questions surround...
by gandreani on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:02AM
(#17559044)
This is probably the most realistic theory I've heard that explains planned obsolescence.
I'd then argue that there's still some malevolence in there and that would be the maximum lifetime they calculated. Clearly the older stuff lasts longer so they miscalculated how long the new stuff should last and at some point it becomes the new norm. "Oh yeah, washer's aren't supposed to last more than 7 years"
Re:Interview with Eric Lundgren about the questions surround...
by ggm on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:06AM
(#17559077)
yes the malevolence is there, but it can be contained. in high price whitegoods (odd name, but there you go, the high price ones are now satin finish metal!) there is a huge story about long-life. European fridges have been driven to insanely thick insulation, far exceeding Australian standards, and there is a structural side to this: the units are very rigid, but have remarkably thin metal skins.
If we said that 95% of the product must be demonstrated to be capable of lasting 15 years, and could test it, we'd be driving to airframe resilience engineering: the jumbo jet is designed to work inside the metals fatigue point almost indefinitely, modulo cracking.
Thats not how we make consumer goods.
Re:Interview with Eric Lundgren about the questions surround...
by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:59PM
(#17562018)
I'm sure this is very common, but note that there are well-documented cases of gleeful-hand-rubbing[1].
Re:Interview with Eric Lundgren about the questions surround...
by dorfsmay on Thursday July 19, 2018 @10:20AM
(#17566508)
Refrigerators functions haven't changed much, but their prices seem to go up over time, yet their reliability and life expectancy goes down. Also parts are priced such that it's cheaper to buy a new one if you expect a second faulty part within the would be warranty time of a new one.
Its actually the same with the washingmachine. They made them from thick steel because manufacturing costs hadn't driven to the quality of build and design which worked with thin sheet steel. Once they got over a million, and developed tighter tolerances, and understood in-field lifetimes, they could use thinner stock because they could stamp a pattern into it which added 3D shape-driven strength, and avoid 3lb of steel cost. I know we like to imagine them rubbing their hands with gleee at the future sale from it rusting out, but they really dont: they are driving down front cost, and if this reduces lifetime at end, thats a cost shifting problem they are not maximising to. If they were told to reduce input cost but preserve maximum lifetime, they might drive 1mm of steel back in, or thicker dip-time or better paint or move to less rust prone mix of metal or any of 100 things.