News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Gov.uk content should be published in HTML and not PDF by ars on Monday July 16, 2018 @04:57PM (#17545041)
> Uploading a video is trivial while captioning still requires significant effort.

No, actually it doesn't. You start with the automatic one that youtube creates and then edit it.

It takes about twice as long as watching the video (i.e. about 2 minutes for each minute of video).

Source: I've started doing this for videos I upload.

Yes, if your audio quality is bad, and youtube can't understand anything so you have to start from nothing it would be significant effort, as you say. But if your audio is clear, it's really not that hard.

If you want perfection (line breaks in logical places, not too much text at a time on the screen, captions synchronized perfectly with the speaker), the time goes up to about 4 or 5x, which is still not "significant effort".

Re:Why Gov.uk content should be published in HTML and not PDF by losteric on Monday July 16, 2018 @05:15PM (#17545201)
In my opinion, spending double the presentation time on editing transcripts qualifies as significant effort.
Re:Why Gov.uk content should be published in HTML and not PDF by ars on Monday July 16, 2018 @05:22PM (#17545249)
I guess it depends on your role. If you are editing the video you are spending way more time than that already.
Re:Why Gov.uk content should be published in HTML and not PDF by ecnahc515 on Monday July 16, 2018 @08:17PM (#17546287)
A lot of videos get uploaded without any editing whatsoever, so is it really that hard to believe anything besides that is considered "significant effort"?
Re:Why Gov.uk content should be published in HTML and not PDF by kaitai on Monday July 16, 2018 @10:26PM (#17546844)
It takes 4-5x for my videos -- not going for perfection, just making nonsense into the math words I said reasonably clearly. Jargon can be tough for the automated captioning services. They are improving, and for the version I use for teaching it seems to learn the vocabulary as I go through the class. Maybe next year it'll know what an eigenvector is!