News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by gallerdude on Friday July 13, 2018 @08:45AM (#17522437)
Imagine we immediately changed to Japan’s system - do you think us Americans would do a good job utilizing it?

I think the Japanese system is better, I just fear that part of the benefit they have is cultural (harder to implement than laws).

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by dwater on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:22AM (#17522699)
This blog post is based on posts from the Urban kchoze blog, which has been linked on HN previously. I liked it so much I read the entire archive. One great post is about a possible remedy to American zoning: dynamic zoning.

http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/05/how-to-make-urban-ho...

It doesn't provide a direct route to move to Japanese-style zoning, but it would allow densities to increase organically based on demand in areas, which is a major component of Japanese zoning that is missing from American zoning.

If you are interested in these topics, I recommend the entire Urban kchoze archive.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @08:58AM (#17522523)
Changing to it immediately would be impractical, but a steady transition would be pretty easily feasible, outside of the political concerns.

It's not like dense, mixed-use areas don't exist in the US -- NYC being the most obvious example. They're just uncommon because regulations force them to be uncommon. Where they do exist they work fine.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by claydavisss on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:11AM (#17522608)
But voters at a town hall on live television will rightly reply that anyone who wants to live in NYC is free to go there, and anyone who feels victimized by the situation in the Bay Area is free to leave.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:58AM (#17523011)
> But voters at a town hall on live television will rightly reply that anyone who wants to live in NYC is free to go there, and anyone who feels victimized by the situation in the Bay Area is free to leave.

The problem being that there is more demand for that kind of high density living than there is existing supply. Hence the desire to create more.

By contrast, if you want to live in a detached single family home, there are plenty on offer around Houston or Portland or dozens of other cities that already have a lower population density and thus less pressure for new high density housing.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:17PM (#17525354)
The whole point is that sometimes rules are better handled at a high level, rather than a local one.

The result of local dominant zoning is rampant NIMBYism, with unsustainable and anti-environmental suburban sprawl, people unable to afford rent in the areas with the most good jobs, and widespread economic segregation.

The system is working for some definition of working, but not terribly well.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by Semirhage on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:24PM (#17525424)
You call it NIMBY’ism, they call it the people who actually live and invest in an area wanting to have the final say, not distant interests which might just be interested in developer kick backs.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:33PM (#17525524)
It's both of these things.

There's a reason we have governments at a higher level than neighborhoods and cities. Not every decision makes sense there.

We've tried city level zoning, the result is that economically booming areas fight new residents, drastically raising rents while preventing others from joining in in the economic success. It's a disaster, just look at the bay area.

Or look at the cost of sprawl in how much nature we've cut down and our per capita energy usage. What part of that looks good to you?

If you zoom in too far, people get selfish and you hit externalities. Zoning isn't unique, sometimes you need more coordination for things to work.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by Semirhage on Friday July 13, 2018 @05:11PM (#17526731)
Another way to look at the Bay is that s previously unique American cultural center has already been irrevocably destroyed by yuppies and big tech firms who felt the need to drop anchor there. Maybe some pressure to spread out the impact of that “economic success” beyond a single city is more valuable than building ArcologySF? The world’s cities don’t need to be aggressively homogenized for the sake of affordable rents for an influx of techies. It’s a big world, stop crowding into one tiny, devastated corner of it.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by closeparen on Friday July 13, 2018 @04:32PM (#17526436)
The interest of the region in a municipality’s zoning is exactly analogous to the interest of a neighborhood in an individual property owner’s land use.

Free for all zoning would be letting the people who actually own particular properties have the final say.

/s/actually live there/are upper-middle-class, white, and born at the right time/

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by emodendroket on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:24AM (#17522709)
I suggest you pick up a small-town paper talking about any proposed development at all to get a sense of issues that exist beyond just whatever old zoning laws are on the books. People have lots of reasons for not wanting that to happen -- some, granted, are silly, but not all of them are.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by rayiner on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:43AM (#17522898)
They’re all silly (often racist). In Annapolis, there is opposition to redeveloping City Dock, which is old and gross, for “historical preservation.”
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by emodendroket on Friday July 13, 2018 @10:11AM (#17523105)
I don't know anything about Annapolis and won't weigh in on that one. But I do understand why people don't want compressor stations or nuclear waste near their homes, for instance.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by rayiner on Friday July 13, 2018 @10:43AM (#17523325)
Nobody is suggesting we build a compressor station inside Annapolis. A property owner near the waterfront wants to use his property to build a hotel and retail areas in the heart of downtown. NIMBYs oppose it because of their personal aesthetic preferences: https://www.google.com/amp/www.capitalgazette.com/opinion/co...
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:11PM (#17525298)
Getting pretty sick of this strawman. Nobody's ever suggesting getting rid of zoning rules that keep polluting factories and similar buildings away from residential areas.

Like, this is very explicit in the article for this thread even, and somehow it still comes up.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by emodendroket on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:56PM (#17525709)
The compressor station thing is on the top of my mind because they want to build one in my town. Anyway there is a wide gradient; a bar isn't quite as undesirable as some of the industrial facilities, but it can still be disruptive to someone who lives nearby.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @04:53PM (#17526606)
A bar is a fair example, nuclear waste really isn't (we can't even collectively agree to put it under actual fucking mountains in apocalypse-proof vaults).

Anyway if you look in the article it talks about how you still exclude things from residential areas based on level of nuisance. Presumably a compressor station could qualify.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by emodendroket on Friday July 13, 2018 @08:20PM (#17527937)
It kind of gets to the anxiety about handing over control though. Towns do not get to decide whether they'll have a compressor station so a number have been built over community objections. I'm not really a local-government fetishist but I would be worried about how responsive a more centralized system would be to resident complaints.
[dead]
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by dang on Saturday July 14, 2018 @04:29PM (#17532210)
Personal attacks aren't allowed here, so please don't do that, even if someone else is biased.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by bluGill on Monday July 16, 2018 @09:28AM (#17541082)
I'm sorry, it wasn't intended to be an attack, I was trying to point out that someone that they are biased. How can I word that better so that someone sees what they are? (this might be an unsolved problem)
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by dang on Monday July 16, 2018 @09:50PM (#17546693)
There are quite a few options for wording that in a way that doesn't sound like a personal attack. Example: "you're saying X but I perceive Y, so I wonder if you might be biased because of ABC". Also, putting things in the form of a question—as long as it's a genuine question and not sarcastic—can go a long way for communicating openness.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:20PM (#17525377)
I'm aware that some of the reasons are understandable.

It's understandable that people want their neighborhood to stay similar to when they bought in. It's understandable that people who drive everywhere don't want more traffic or competition for parking. It's understandable that rich people don't want poorer, less academically accomplished families at their schools.

But just because the reasons are understandable, doesn't mean they're good, or that they outweigh the bad. Zoning in the US has a number of hugely negative effects, and it desperately needs reformation.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by emodendroket on Friday July 13, 2018 @03:07PM (#17525772)
I suppose my issue is that these advocacy pieces that are posted here frequently rarely engage with the viewpoint of people they call NIMBYs. If the object is to preach to the converted then that's fine but otherwise maybe it's not ideal.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by ghaff on Friday July 13, 2018 @12:55PM (#17524600)
One very common issue is that new developments, especially those that cater to younger families, tend to increase the demands on the local schools and therefore taxes for those and other services.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @02:22PM (#17525401)
"More people require more services."

Well yes, of course that's true. But more people also means more taxes to fund those services.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by ghaff on Friday July 13, 2018 @03:08PM (#17525781)
Yes, but people with families tend to cost more than they pay in taxes given that the school system is something like 90% of my town's budget.
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by TulliusCicero on Friday July 13, 2018 @04:55PM (#17526623)
90% sounds ludicrously high, you sure about that? I mean I realize schools are expensive, but damn surely there are other expensive things local governments do?
Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by ghaff on Friday July 13, 2018 @06:03PM (#17527216)
My impression was that number was higher (perhaps because there was a time a few years years back when there was some mismanagement and significant incremental funds needed for the school system). But it's still about 65% and I'm not sure that accounts for all the transfer payments.

https://www.ci.lancaster.ma.us/sites/lancasterma/files/uploa...

It's a smallish rural town. There is police, fire, library, water, DPW, etc. but we don't even have services like trash collection which are private. Schools are significant.

Re:North American vs. Japanese zoning by Spooky23 on Friday July 13, 2018 @09:24AM (#17522711)
Of course not. It's an awful idea because as a diverse, representative democracy you'll be subject to the whims of the congress.

Do you really want rural conservatives who hate cities dictating urban land use as you would today?

Do you really want democrats with tight ties to big real estate interests (key members of the California delegation, for example) dictating land use policy?

Silicon Valley is Silicon Valley because everyone fled cities in the 50s and 60s to buy the then-american dream in the old orange groves. Whatever the next phase is, it isn't going to happen there.