News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avinashv on Saturday October 02, 2010 @06:57AM (#1750220)
I am a large-ish apparel and textile manufacturer in India, and do the majority of my export to the United States. I am pretty well-versed with the kind of market you want to get into. My email is in my profile--get in touch with me and we'll talk. I doubt that I personally can supply you with what you need--we operate on volume--but I know plenty of people who can get you what you need.

A few things to keep in mind, though. I have just typed these in no particular order off the top of my head. I'm going to shy away from offering marketing advice and stick with what I know best.

(1) This is probably the worst time in history to enter this market. Cotton yarn is at all-time highs (70-80% increase over this time last year), and it's hard to get deliveries even if you can pay. The average Joe has no idea how many people between the cotton farmers and the store are struggling to maintain the shelf price of a garment. A great example of this is the fact that everybody in this thread is suggesting that you get your t-shirts from China. This is bad advice--China has increased labor costs and has tremendous yarn shortages for cotton.

(2) The small-volume t-shirt business is all about logistics. Getting t-shirts made and printed is extremely easy (getting them made cheaply is a little more involved). Arranging for the logistics of sizes, colors, styles etc. is complex and expensive if you don't have access to good storage.

(3) Please, please, please don't use CafePress/Zazzle etc. The quality is terrible and their prices are pretty outrageous.

(4) I take it you have very little experience in the industry. I suggest you spend some time doing your homework. I wouldn't worry too much about the chemistry behind dye science, but you should really be familiar with some basic knitted structures, your yarn options, dyeing options and you should have a solid knowledge of your printing options. Look at value-addition treatments to garments.

(5) Get a firm understanding of getting your t-shirts manufactured. If you are looking for poorer quality (but better price), Central America is a good bet. They use cheap dyeing methods and open-ended yarn, but because of some political help, they have amazing prices for USA importers. If you are happy to pay more, then import from Asia. You will not get duty-free garments (think countries like Egypt, Jordan or Kenya if you want duty-free), but you can get excellent quality. You also need to understand the duty structure of importing apparel into the United States.

(6) Most people who export to the United States quote prices for putting the container-packed garments onto the ship. You are then responsible for shipping, insurance, duty and trucking from the port to your DC. Trucking is painfully expensive. Take lead times from various countries into account. I also highly doubt you will be importing even a 20' container's worth of t-shirts in one go, so you need to investigate the route of partial container shipments.

I hope I didn't put you off--every industry has challenges. This one is still really fun and exciting, especially if you are new to it. There's a lot to learn.

[edit] I should add: I'd be glad to review your sourced costings for you once you get them from wherever in the world and make sure you aren't getting ripped off, assuming you are willing to share them.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avner on Saturday October 02, 2010 @10:31AM (#1750496)
My father works for the largest thread company in the world, Coats plc. I ran down everything avinash told you in the above post with him and he says its good advice. E-mail me and I can put you in touch with him -- He can put you in touch with the right peope in places like Egypt, Kenya. According to him, its all about volume in the textile business and quality control (i.e. silk printing etc) can be very hard when you outsource your production to a third world country.
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by elptacek on Saturday October 02, 2010 @01:13PM (#1750840)
After re-reading the question a couple of times, I get the idea that oldmanstan may not know how to sew. There's a step between "sketching the artwork" and "making the garment" -- designing the sloper. As an apparel manufacturer, is this a service you provide, or do most of your customers bring you a set of base patterns?

If not, oldmanstan will probably need someone to take his artwork and turn it into a base pattern. Not that t-shirts and tanks are particularly difficult, but patterns can rapidly become more complicated when elements like pleating, draping, pockets, cuffs, collars, hoods and so forth are part of of the overall design.

To me, this is the absolute most fun part of designing a garment. It's pretty much all I think about -- to me, exciting design is all about clever seam placement. Textiles are a medium. A well-designed garment brings out the best of the fabric. So, oldmanstan, if you want to take a whack at that part, you can email ME, and I'll send you some book recommendations.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avinashv on Saturday October 02, 2010 @04:58PM (#1751327)
Basic t-shirts (the kind that he wants to print graphics on) are in--basically--two silhouettes. Basic, and fashion. Basic is the boxy fit that you'll find on tees from Cafepress or Woot.Shirt, for example. Fashion fits are a bit slimmer, have smaller sleeves and a different fit on the shoulders.

It's a bit silly to experiment much beyond the cut of the neck. Besides various v-neck and crew styles, I wouldn't venture out too far. The "pattern" (the technical term for the shape of the garment) of a t-shirt is a solved problem. The trick is designing innovative artwork in printing, clever usage of embellishing stitches and garment washes that give a certain look.

If you want to see innovation, then you're right on the mark with clever seaming. Use a saddle stitch over your shoulder and sleeve seams in a colored polyester thread, and then put the garment through a pigment dye treatment. You'll get a beautiful contrast stitch on a washed-look garment.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by luke0x on Saturday October 02, 2010 @08:06PM (#1751696)
What books would you recommend to the randomly interested?
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by elptacek on Sunday October 03, 2010 @12:14PM (#1752952)
Here's a book: http://www.amazon.com/Patternmaking-Comprehensive-Reference-...

And here's a website: http://vintagesewing.info/

And a good book on textiles: http://www.amazon.com/World-Textiles-Visual-Traditional-Tech...

There are some other books I've read over the years (a couple of them very rare), that I can't seem to find references to. But if you need beyond that, feel free to email me.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by luke0x on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @09:05PM (#1762280)
Very cool, thank you. =)
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by jessejmc on Saturday October 02, 2010 @08:25AM (#1750303)
This is the kind of post that makes HN awesome. A person can ask for help and get a response from someone experienced in that area.
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avinashv on Saturday October 02, 2010 @05:02PM (#1751342)
I'm glad I can offer the advice. I'm not in a field I would have expected to have seen on here, but it's cool that people are interested.
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by bjrk on Saturday October 02, 2010 @02:17PM (#1750995)
I just wish the questioners would take the time to ask more detailed question and follow-up with replies themselves.
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by reedlaw on Saturday October 02, 2010 @08:29AM (#1750310)
This is a very good post for me, although I'm not in the clothing business. I'm wondering at just what point will it be cheaper to ship a partial container load to a US storage location and then via USPS to the customer than air shipping from Asia directly to the customer? I'm selling items worth over $80 each and the shipping is typically $30 from Asia via DHL or UPS. If I only had about 1 cubic meter's worth of merchandise to sell, would I be better off using a partial container shipment?
Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avinashv on Saturday October 02, 2010 @05:01PM (#1751336)
1 cubic meter is not worth partial containers. You're definitely better off sending it via air. It's only a few dollars a kilo to air something from Asia to the United States (there are obviously some minimums).

[edit] Talk to shippers for both air and partial containers. Offer them back their quote at 50% and negotiate from there.

There are plenty of boutique garment laundries in LA that air garments from India, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh or China and process them in small lots in their laundries and sell them on the LA fashion scene. If you see a washed t-shirt selling for over $75 around there, that is a good indicator that this is what is happening.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by Mz on Saturday October 02, 2010 @10:55AM (#1750537)
This thread (and especially this post) are interesting to me because I have considered -- on and off since I was a teen -- designing/making my own clothes (to meet my special needs) and, recently, toyed with the idea of doing something like that as a business (and all but dismissed the idea out of hand as just too much trouble).

Any thoughts on finding/making cotton-silk blend knits (for women)? I rarely can find this but it is awesome when I can. Silks are too expensive and too fragile for my lifestyle and rarely come in knits. They shrink horribly when washed and just don't stand up to my lifestyle (which is rooted in keeping everything clean enough to stay well in spite of my medical condition, and dry-cleaning is not acceptable as I react badly to the chemicals). Most knits are cotton-polyester, not acceptable in my book. I don't wear polyester....etc...etc.

I have gone so far as to look over a few websites that I felt had good online shopping interfaces for clothing. Most of them suck big time. I tend to prefer to shop in person for clothes, in part because most online clothes shopping is so bad.

So I have played with the idea a bit. I looked up a site called "French Rags" because I know they do mass customization and they sell knits. But it turns out they use a yarn blend I don't want (IIRC: cotton-acrylic). Good quality affordable clothes is really tough to find. Nylon and some spandex is also acceptable for me. But polyester is absolutely unacceptable, most other synthetics are not really very acceptable, and 100% cotton wrinkles so bad and therefore is too high maintenance. Most of the clothes I buy is 95% cotton, 5% spandex or 90% nylon and 10% spandex. I don't own an iron but can't afford to show up at work all wrinkled -- it's a violation of the dress code. Knits with a little spandex generally avoids that issue altogether.

So, I have thought about a DIY approach to solve my problem and also thought that the amount of work involved, well, it might make sense to do it as a business rather than jump through all these hoops to dress one person.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by avinashv on Saturday October 02, 2010 @05:23PM (#1751394)
You have a lot of things here, so let me attack each thing step-by-step:

> This thread (and especially this post) are interesting to me because I have considered -- on and off since I was a teen -- designing/making my own clothes (to meet my special needs) and, recently, toyed with the idea of doing something like that as a business (and all but dismissed the idea out of hand as just too much trouble).

Don't give something you are passionate about up! Please contact me if you need help getting off your feet. I will be happy to help you with as much advice and direction that I can.

> Any thoughts on finding/making cotton-silk blend knits (for women)? I rarely can find this but it is awesome when I can.

Cotton-silk is difficult and expensive to process. In knits, you'll only find this in the high-end. Zegna does the best big-name cotton-silk knit fabric that I have seen on a garment. If there is a store around you, go to their polos and take a look.

Why silk? If you want a soft hand feel, look at modal. It is a stronger fiber than rayon, significantly softer than cotton, and processes about as easily. In today's cotton market, it is only marginally more expensive. A cotton/modal blend is magnificent.

> Silks are too expensive and too fragile for my lifestyle and rarely come in knits. They shrink horribly when washed and just don't stand up to my lifestyle (which is rooted in keeping everything clean enough to stay well in spite of my medical condition, and dry-cleaning is not acceptable as I react badly to the chemicals).

If you are talking about woven silk shrinking, then you are doing something horribly wrong. If you are talking about knits shrinking...well, that's difficult to explain. Shrinkage is controlled in fabric finishing by "setting" the fabric while holding it at the dimensional stability you are after. Most garments that are 100% cotton in the US/Europe will have between 7-9% shrinkage in both length and width. This means the dimensions will shrink by that percentage after the third wash.

> Most knits are cotton-polyester, not acceptable in my book.

100% is by far the most common yarn to knit with. Cotton and polyester have to be dyed in different processes, so to make a solid color (dyeing both cotton and polyester as opposed to just one or the other) is more expensive than starting off with cotton yarn and just single-dyeing it.

Incidentally, the whole "heather is the new black" phase in the States confuses me. Most cheap heather garments are a cotton/poly blend and suck. Look for 100% cotton heathers--they are dyed at the fibre stage (before the yarn is spun) and are significantly better garments.

> I don't wear polyester....etc...etc.

Polyester, when processed correctly, gets too little credit. It has better drape and appearance than cotton, and is orders of magnitude stronger. It obviously has different uses.

> So I have played with the idea a bit. I looked up a site called "French Rags" because I know they do mass customization and they sell knits. But it turns out they use a yarn blend I don't want (IIRC: cotton-acrylic). Good quality affordable clothes is really tough to find.

I don't know French Rags, but a good-quality store wouldn't use blends like that. What is affordable to you? I can make recommendations.

> Nylon and some spandex is also acceptable for me. But polyester is absolutely unacceptable, most other synthetics are not really very acceptable, and 100% cotton wrinkles so bad and therefore is too high maintenance.

Viscose/rayon, modal, bamboo etc. all count as synthetics. All of those are significantly superior to cotton in all aspects of feel, coolness and drape.

100% cotton doesn't wrinkle bad if you get well-processed fabric, and understand how to iron clothes properly. The key is medium-high heat and plenty of moisture in the form of steam. If all else fails, iron your clothes with only 90% of the dryer cycle. On all good steam irons there is a button that squirts water. If you've ever wondered what it is for, then this is it. If there is a hard crease, just squirt it with water and run the iron over it with steam and the crease will be gone.

I don't own a single "wrinkle-free" shirt or pair of pants. I buy good quality dress shirts and pants, and only wear 100% cotton (100% linen shirts for the summer). If you are willing to commit to 7 minutes of ironing per garment, then there is no reason that you shouldn't have crisp clothing.

Plastic-based synthetics are harder to iron than cotton.

> Most of the clothes I buy is 95% cotton, 5% spandex or 90% nylon and 10% spandex. I don't own an iron but can't afford to show up at work all wrinkled -- it's a violation of the dress code. Knits with a little spandex generally avoids that issue altogether.

Ah, no iron. Buy one [1], since they are cheap and handy.

Spandex knits shouldn't make such a big deal. One trick is to use a setting on your dryer (if you use a dryer) usually labelled something like "perm press". Make sure you use 2 dryer sheets for anything over a 5kg dry load and plenty of softner, and then take the clothes out of the dryer the moment they are done and hang them up. Your clothes, after a night, should lose their creases just through gravity.

Protip: good quality suit jackets and blazers should never touch an iron via this method. Don't let that ugly iron shine ever appear on your clothes.

> So, I have thought about a DIY approach to solve my problem and also thought that the amount of work involved, well, it might make sense to do it as a business rather than jump through all these hoops to dress one person.

It's a great idea. With the kind of upscale market that you are looking into, you could definitely look into getting value-added garments and fabrics sourced from duty-free countries.

Good luck! Please let me know if I can offer you any advice on starting up. My contact information is in my profile.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dap...

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by Mz on Sunday October 03, 2010 @06:13AM (#1752459)
Thank you very much for your lengthy, detailed reply.

A few comments:

I don't know that I would say I am "passionate" about it. I am tall for a woman and have a genetic disorder and happen to know a lot about clothes (which might, actually, indicate I am passionate about clothes :-D ). When I am thin, it is quite hard to find clothes that fit properly. Men have "big and tall" shops. Women get "petite" and "women's" departments -- ie short or fat. Tall women -- especially tall, thin women -- get somewhat left out in the cold. When I am quite heavy, it is actually a bit easier to get clothes that fit me. I had a serious health crisis about 10 years ago which led to a diagnosis of a genetic disorder in my mid-thirties. The diagnosis empowered me to begin getting well for the first time in my life and I have lost several dress sizes. I expect in the near future to be thin enough again to have real difficulty finding clothes that fit well. Additionally, what I wear and how I deal with it plays a very large role in my ability to get well and stay well.

By trial and error, I have found that certain fabrics are tolerable and others are not. For example, I am actually allergic to wool and needed a good deal more medication than normal anytime I wore a lovely wool jacket I owned at one time. I finally got a clue and got rid of the jacket. We also gave up our washer and dryer and wash everything by hand. I considered getting an iron or steamer but decided against it. Every single thing I own has to be kept to a ridiculous standard of germ-free cleanliness in order to keep me well and off medication and I just don't think an iron and ironing board are worth it (at least not right now) when I know I can just get around the need to iron by shopping carefully. I have gotten off 8 or 9 prescription drugs and escaped a personal living hell. It would be difficult to convey how utterly miserable I was while accepting conventional treatments for my condition. Whatever hoops I have to jump through to stay well and off medication are well worth it to me.

But it is quite challenging and this wouldn't work at all if I didn't know a great deal about clothes. I have yet to write anything in particular on my health site about the whole clothing issue. I keep meaning to but I also think explaining to other people what I do with regards to clothes would be just another reason for most people to reject my approach to dealing with this genetic disorder because most people don't have the knowledge I have about clothes. So I have thought that offering a solution rather than just information might be something that would go over better.

I don't own a single jacket or blazer. They are too hard to keep clean. Most are dry clean only and I can't do that. I find that an undershirt works just fine in the cold weather here (it's pretty warm where I live). As a bit of an aside: The dress code at work is "business casual" and most men there show up in slacks and either a polo-style shirt or button down shirt. I can only think of a couple of occasions when I have seen the highest ranking men in my department wear a jacket or suit. In contrast, some of the high ranking women wear jackets and suits on a routine basis. To me, this just screams "I'm a second class citizen and I need to try harder because I was born with the wrong genitals". I don't think I have any realistic hope of climbing the corporate ladder and would rather go do my own thing anyway. But if I were trying to climb the corporate ladder, I would be doing my best to come up with a female equivalent of how the men typically dress and would avoid jackets on principle. As it is, I avoid them just because they are a nightmare to keep adequately clean for my needs. Nonetheless, even if do build a successful e-business and can live in shorts most of the time, I expect there will still be times when I need to dress appropriately for meeting people in a capacity related to my business. And I like dressing nice. So I don't expect this need to ever go away completely.

For a little bit of background related to me and my experience with/interest in clothes:

My mom apprenticed with a tailor for a time when she was young and she learned to sew so her kids would have nice things even though there wasn't much money. I stood for fittings and had most of my clothes custom made as a child. I don't have the money to pay people to custom-make my clothes as an adult. In my teens, I realized how spoiled I was and that I would be moving out soon. I began to toy with the idea of learning to sew or knit or something and making my own clothes. But I never did learn, even though I did try. It just didn't work out. I think my medical condition makes it problematic for me to handle the materials in the production stage. I think that's a factor in my failure in that regard.

I had about 20 books on clothes in my teens/twenties. For a time, I wanted to be an image consultant. I even gave a class on it once and used to help friends go through their wardrobes and taught my ex to dress well. I was a homemaker for many years and I used to think that if I got a job, I would finally be able to dress well because I would have some place to wear nice clothes. Now I have a job and I have found that is not true. Most of the stuff in magazines and on store shelves would violate dress code at my office. I have a tendency to attract attention, often unwanted attention, and have found that although other people seem able to violate dress code right and left and get away with it, I cannot. It gets noticed and I get pulled aside. Anything too tight/revealing or whatever and I'm in hot water. Meanwhile, other women can show up looking like hookers and no one seems to say a word. So I think there is a serious disconnect between what women need to wear for business and what is available and most women probably are less painfully aware of it than I am because dressing "normally, for a woman" doesn't get them into the hot water it would get me into. Women at work mostly either dress too sexy for the office or they wear suits in imitation of "how men dress for work/business" when that isn't, in fact, what the men are wearing at my office. I think women need another option, one that isn't "wearable art" (and to hell with practical concerns or comfort) and also isn't some attempt to imitate men.

But I also don't know that I want to put in the hours this would require. I just want to be able to get dressed in the morning but am frustrated by how challenging that is.

Re:Ask HN: I want to start a clothing company. by bardebes on Sunday October 03, 2010 @05:24PM (#1753651)
Hi avinashv

I was looking for your email but couldn't find it. Just wanted to ask you a few questions regarding getting cloths made for a business.

send me a message at [email protected]