Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by tlb on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:36PM
(#17491945)
Why do people keep comparing assets ($) to GDP ($/year)?
If you want to compare the two, 1 year isn't a reasonable term. You can convert a rate into a current asset value by multiplying by a P/E ratio, anywhere from 10 to 20 these days.
Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by logfromblammo on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:56PM
(#17492114)
One way to compare would be to say that all of Norway could earn as much money, just sitting on ass all day, every day, as 3% (safe withdrawal rate) of Mexico, working 43 hours a week (actual stat from OECD).
Alternately, compare to a country with lower GDP.
"Norway (5.3M people) makes as much sitting on its investments as Latvia (2M people) earns working 36.5 hours per week."
This has the advantage of comparing a Scandinavian country with a Baltic nation, with cultural and geographic proximity.
Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by cperciva on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:48PM
(#17492047)
News media love to do this on a personal level too. Every month CBC runs a story about how Canadians' household debt (mostly mortgages) is 170% of their disposable income.
It isn't completely meaningless to compare these, but the units need to be right: Rather than "170%" (which scares people because it's more than 100%!) we should say that household debt is equal to 20 months of disposable income.
Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by ucaetano on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:48PM
(#17492051)
Yeah, I'm genuinely surprised and sad when I see posts like these make it to Hacker News, it just show how ignorant most people are about fundamentals of economics.
Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by Basketb926 on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:33PM
(#17491913)
Norway's Sovereign Wealth Fund has as much capital stock as the total flow of Mexico's Entire Economy. Obviously Mexico has a heck of a lot more capital stock which is required to create such a large economic flow.
Re:Norway’s Sovereign Wealth Fund Is the Size of the Mexico'...
by sct202 on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:34PM
(#17491925)
This is kind of a bad comparison to make since they're comparing the value of Norway's fund versus the output of Mexico's economy (which would be more like revenue in the context of a company/investment).
The Mexican economy generates $1 trillion of value per year.
The Norway Sovereign Wealth fund has $1 trillion in capital.
Over the past 2 years, it seems that Norway's fund generated an average return of about 10% a year.
That means Norway's fund is "equivalent" to a $100 billion GDP country, about 1/10th of Mexico.
If you want to compare the two, 1 year isn't a reasonable term. You can convert a rate into a current asset value by multiplying by a P/E ratio, anywhere from 10 to 20 these days.
Alternately, compare to a country with lower GDP.
"Norway (5.3M people) makes as much sitting on its investments as Latvia (2M people) earns working 36.5 hours per week."
This has the advantage of comparing a Scandinavian country with a Baltic nation, with cultural and geographic proximity.
It isn't completely meaningless to compare these, but the units need to be right: Rather than "170%" (which scares people because it's more than 100%!) we should say that household debt is equal to 20 months of disposable income.
ITT Edit... lots of people complaining about the comparison (like me).
[1]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RKNANPMXA666NRUG
> $190,000 for every one of Norway’s 5.2 million citizens
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_wealth_fund#Largest_...