News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by aidos on Sunday July 08, 2018 @05:35PM (#17486341)
I like the idea but found it a little hard to follow the arguments. Especially difficult if you follow down the cons thread, because a con of a con is a pro of the original point.

I worry that it won’t really result in more rational outcome but I do wish it luck. Is there anyway to downvote the points for being, for example, strawman arguments?

Edit: maybe I’d parse it better if they were labelled “agree” and “disagree”?

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by electrograv on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:11PM (#17486542)
I tried it a while ago, then left when I realized a terrible aspect of its’ design was being abused: The creator of a debate topic gets to moderate it, which basically includes full censorship powers of any pros or cons you don’t like.

It boggles my mind anyone designing Kialo would have thought that to be a good idea, or that they wouldn’t foresee it being abused regularly to nudge the tide of an argument in the preferred direction by the moderators.

I’ve seen it all the time: Depending on the agenda of the moderators, one side of the argument mysteriously receives an overwhelmingly large amount of “moderation” for minor technicalities or even outright nonsensical reasons.

I’ve even seen Kialo’s own confusing design you mention here used as a way to subtly suppress one side of an argument: Take any argument beyond the top level, and it’s very easy to simply claim it is a duplicate of a top level argument. For example, if I write a con of a con, moderators can remove it saying it resembled an argument they saw in a top level pro. Or if I write a pro or a pro, they can remove it by saying it’s a duplicate of its own parent!

And this technique applies any number of levels deep in the tree. When this “moderation” gets applies overwhelmingly on one side of an argument, you can shift the entire balance of a Kialo argument quite easily without revealing overt corruption on the surface of your actions.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:57PM (#17486754)
Well unfortunately, in the large debates, really many duplicates are being submitted. Take the UBI one with close to 3k unique claims. It's really hard to suggest claims that aren't already in there.

If you have specific examples, please point us to them, but we are not aware of any really large (>500 claims) biased debates.

The idea is for claims to be canonical for each debate, otherwise you have to rewrite them a gazillion times, including their children. That's what we have linking for.

Generally speaking, if you think your claim was unfairly rejected, just hit report and we'll look into it.

Having claims rejected as duplicates, happens to us too. :)

If you have any suggestions, other than reporting, and roaming powerusers (which we will introduce soon), please let us know!

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by acover on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:26PM (#17486887)
Have you considered democratizing moderation? If many people agree that a claim is a duplicate of another claim then it's probably a duplicate or at least the community wants to treat it as such.

Also instead of removal just make it less visible. With a big arrow pointing towards the main discussion. If people still choose to discuss there then they must see value in doing so.

PS: thank you for making this

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:46PM (#17486963)
Regarding democratizing, the problem are the troll hordes out there. One person with many followers tweets out a particular claim and then you'll have the strangest things suddenly appearing at the top. It's the same reason Internet polls don't really work. And the reason we consider the default perspective ALL votes, problematic (we are building something here soon). This is especially a problem due to our topics, primarily very controversal issues. These are the type of topics that very often get edit-locked on Wikipedia because of edit wars and we deal exlusively with them. That's why we built the suggestion system (https://support.kialo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003791445-Sug...) and 5 permission levels (https://support.kialo.com/hc/en-us/articles/115003877705-Par...).

Suggested claims that were not accepted, aren't deleted. users often argue back and forth with admins on those claims, often edit them and then get them accepted. Very often it's really just a clarification or "could you please add sources" or "do you mind moving this claim over there".

Duplicates are thornier. What we have considered, is linking them to the ones that they supposedly are duplicates of, so you could see them there.

That's possible and we might do it, but we really don't get that many complaints about them. It's really just a problem in the debates with >1k claims. but as more debates grow, this might become more of an issue and then we'll build that.

Thanks for your input.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by acover on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:58PM (#17487009)
Thanks, it's interesting to learn what is a practical problem when growing a discussion website.

Is it possible to deter troll behavior by using a reputation system and investigating bad behavior? Reputation that takes a long time of good behavior to build but a single act of malice to destroy.

It also has the statistical beauty of adding a prior probability estimate to the likelihood estimate that sorts Reddit comments.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:12PM (#17487068)
Agreed.

We have a "reputation system" it's the thank count next to usernames. We have not handed out any privileges based on those yet, but will probably soon take all with a certain thank count, look at their contributions and grant them some poweruser rights, e.g. commenting into all public debates and see how that goes.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by perfmode on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:38PM (#17486932)
delegated democracy (page rank) is pretty ideal but complex
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by acover on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:41PM (#17486940)
Are there simpler heuristics than page rank? Perhaps a reputation score determines how much your vote is worth?
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by perfmode on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:27PM (#17487124)
page rank is a reputation score
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by acover on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:54PM (#17487216)
Yes, but if computational cost is a concern there are other options.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:13PM (#17487071)
I fear that's too easy to game at our scale, given the horde out there.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by perfmode on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:28PM (#17487125)
page rank in this context is morally relativistic
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @09:06PM (#17487261)
How would you apply it in our context?
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by acover on Monday July 09, 2018 @06:36PM (#17493964)
Not OP. In page rank you have a graph of pages as vertices and links as edges. In this case you'd want users as vertices and up votes as edges.

Page rank would give users a high score if they are up voted by other users with high scores.

I'm not sure if page rank can deal with negative weight edges for down votes but probably.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Sunday July 08, 2018 @05:46PM (#17486391)
I would like to add that the "agree"/"disagree" or "pro"/"cons" should have a random placement (left or right) and also random colors every time the page is loaded. "Cons" shouldn't be red.

The brain has several cognitive biases, such as giving more value to the last paragraphes it reads (which are usually at the right, or at the end of a text block). Cultural biases, such as colors (red for "alert","bad" for example) also influence judgements.

By the way, the website doesn't look easily usable or accessible to impaired people

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:02PM (#17486775)
We thought that green = pro and red = con, is kind of universally agreed upon, no?

The most common misunderstanding is the one mentioned before, a con to a con, indirectly supports the thesis, but is red.

But changing that around is even more confusing. Especially when the parent to that con is then used as a pro somewhere else (and the con now having to be labeled red again).

We consider pros and cons always to be relating to the parent directly above them. This allows them to be linked or copied between debates, irrespective of what debate they originally were a part of.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by aidos on Monday July 09, 2018 @03:17AM (#17488491)
I'm sure your team have given it a lot more thought than my drive-by assessment but a mobile constraint seems the wrong reasoning to use less clear wording. I'm sure it's something you get used to, but for me personally it jars quite heavily.

So to clarify, the below is in the wrong section, right? Even if it was under cons, as I believe it should be, the X cons Y wording doesn't feel natural to me.

https://www.kialo.com/macos-and-windows-should-sandbox-all-a...

For posterity:

>>> Getting asked for permissions by various apps (can I access the camera, can I read you photos, can I send you notifications, can I get your location, etc...) is annoying.

>>> Pros: Mobile users seem to be okay with getting asked for permissions on demand, why would desktop users be any different?

As an aside, how do I copy anything without having to trawl through the DOM or click the tweet button!?

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Monday July 09, 2018 @11:38AM (#17491015)
"Mobile users seem to be okay with getting asked for permissions on demand, why would desktop users be any different?" Should be a con, not a pro, as it weakens the claim above. Just drag it to the other side.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Baeocystin on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:46PM (#17486961)
It's also a color shift that ~1 out of 20 people don't perceive. (~8% men, ~0.5% women). Red is close to a universal color for alert/danger/warning, but green much less so for the pro. Something to consider, at least.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:15PM (#17487079)
We might add another color scheme, exactly for those cases. But the colors, other than for the sunburst in the beginning, aren't really essential (that's at least what our color blind team members tell us) as pros and cons are always on a particular side.

We finished read and navigation accessibility (screenreaders) last month, if anyone knows a great company for testing this, please let us know.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by bootlooped on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#17486689)
Being consistent is good UX. I'm not sure the cognitive biases associated with color or left/right orientation are good enough reasons to intentionally confuse and disorient users.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:04AM (#17489590)
When you want to ensure people are only focusing on the content, and that they stay vigilant about the debate, shouldn't there be UX to make sure people don't develop habits?

All debates are unique

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:12PM (#17486548)
You can "mark for review" claims that aren't clear, duplicates, etc...

Mind you, we aren't a site for commenting or opining, but for capturing and visualizing the reasoning for your opinions.

Thus to "show/capture" your opinion, you vote the individual claims and theses (in the case of multi thesis debates, like this one: https://www.kialo.com/2027). Then later you can select the different perspectives (opinions) and see the reasoning of different individuals, all in the same document. Works best in team environments, as public users often only vote 5 claims.

We tried agree/disagree, but this became problematic on mobile browsers.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by codingdave on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:04PM (#17486485)
Agreed - while the idea has potential, it should be easier to use. Let the cognitive load of using the site be about the arguments themselves, not figuring out the flow of the app.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by bootlooped on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:03PM (#17486781)
It seems pretty easy to use to me. The impression that I get is that they've erred on the side of making it simple and easy to use rather than powerful and feature-heavy. In what ways do you think it should be easier / what is too hard to use now?
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @10:53PM (#17487633)
If you want to see the full functionality, create a private debate (you'll then have admin rights) and play around in it, incl voting, moving, linking, extracting, copy branching, intermap linking, perspectives, suggesting claims and 5 permission levels. https://www.kialo.com/tour
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:23PM (#17486606)
We are open to suggestions, but the largest cognitive load, we think, comes from reading the actual arguments and thinking along, not from the way we present them.

This interface version 4.5, but we are happy to try new stuff. :)

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Sunday July 08, 2018 @06:34PM (#17486649)
Maybe you could propose alternative interfaces, and let each users chose the one that best fits them.
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by foota on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:15PM (#17486846)
You'd have to list out the pros and cons and...
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @08:17PM (#17487089)
...fortunately, we have got a tool for that ;)
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Monday July 09, 2018 @08:08AM (#17489601)
A parallel meta-kialo to debate about the platform itself, like the meta-exchange website, may be a nice idea
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Monday July 09, 2018 @11:42AM (#17491057)
These are happening...though we should have a dedicated place for them:

https://www.kialo.com/kialo-should-create-a-mobile-app-addit...

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Monday July 09, 2018 @01:48PM (#17492046)
I'm not sure why, but when I first opened your link, I had a view with a wheel. Then I clicked on something I don't remember, and the wheel disappeared and a tree replaced it. But now I can't go back to the wheel, even if I close the tab and reopen your link. Is that a bug?

I'm on Firefox, Android 8.1

Edit : Nevermind, I found the view on the menu, then "Info / Stats / Topology". For information, I never opened the website on a desktop, and the mobile version is a bit overwhelming at first sight. UI animations are rather laggy

Edit2 : Just registered to try to participate to that debate. A bit overwhelming at first, but after understanding the UI, that tool is awesome. Democracy Forum 2.0 right there :-)

Edit3 : I agree that "agree"/"disagree" is easier to understand than "pro"/"cons" when navigating the tree. An action verb makes it more obvious that we can participate, and it then naturally shows a text box to add our arguments. Also, I'm still not a fan of green/red colors.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Monday July 09, 2018 @03:23PM (#17492730)
My first debate :

https://www.kialo.com/kalios-source-code-should-be-free-and-...

;)

It's also an awesome tool to help one at building a reasoning

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by Kialo on Sunday July 08, 2018 @07:17PM (#17486856)
Argh. And support all of them on all platforms, the dev team will shoot me. :)
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by DoctorOetker on Monday July 09, 2018 @12:45PM (#17491542)
separate discussion format/protocol from visualization, then anyone can implement their own discussion navigator/visualizer...

the most obvious feature (and a more objective metric for the productivity of the scoring algorithms) would be a button or color that highlights the claim, which if swayed to garner more or less support would most influence the topmost/root claim. If you don't build it sommeone else will. The most popular and desirable interface is the one that helps the user sway the rest.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by antpls on Monday July 09, 2018 @06:55PM (#17494090)
Going the open source way is one solution : https://www.kialo.com/kalios-source-code-should-be-free-and-...
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by BeetleB on Monday July 09, 2018 @02:00AM (#17488270)
>because a con of a con is a pro of the original point.

Apologies for the pedantry, but no - a con of a con need not be a pro of anything.

Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by aidos on Monday July 09, 2018 @03:03AM (#17488446)
Ah sorry, "A con of a con stands indirectly of support of the original pro" — better? :-)
Re:Kialo – a platform for rational debate by BeetleB on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @04:00PM (#17501550)
>Ah sorry, "A con of a con stands indirectly of support of the original pro" — better? :-)

From a logical standpoint, not at all.

From a social standpoint, it often does persuade people towards the pro. However, that is a known fallacy. It is a standard tactic in persuasion.

From the movie "Thank You For Smoking":

Joey Naylor: ...but you didn't prove that vanilla was the best...

Nick Naylor: I didn't have to. I proved that you're wrong, and if you're wrong I'm right.