Also instead of removal just make it less visible. With a big arrow pointing towards the main discussion. If people still choose to discuss there then they must see value in doing so.
PS: thank you for making this
Suggested claims that were not accepted, aren't deleted. users often argue back and forth with admins on those claims, often edit them and then get them accepted. Very often it's really just a clarification or "could you please add sources" or "do you mind moving this claim over there".
Duplicates are thornier. What we have considered, is linking them to the ones that they supposedly are duplicates of, so you could see them there.
That's possible and we might do it, but we really don't get that many complaints about them. It's really just a problem in the debates with >1k claims. but as more debates grow, this might become more of an issue and then we'll build that.
Thanks for your input.
Is it possible to deter troll behavior by using a reputation system and investigating bad behavior? Reputation that takes a long time of good behavior to build but a single act of malice to destroy.
It also has the statistical beauty of adding a prior probability estimate to the likelihood estimate that sorts Reddit comments.
We have a "reputation system" it's the thank count next to usernames. We have not handed out any privileges based on those yet, but will probably soon take all with a certain thank count, look at their contributions and grant them some poweruser rights, e.g. commenting into all public debates and see how that goes.
Page rank would give users a high score if they are up voted by other users with high scores.
I'm not sure if page rank can deal with negative weight edges for down votes but probably.
If you have specific examples, please point us to them, but we are not aware of any really large (>500 claims) biased debates.
The idea is for claims to be canonical for each debate, otherwise you have to rewrite them a gazillion times, including their children. That's what we have linking for.
Generally speaking, if you think your claim was unfairly rejected, just hit report and we'll look into it.
Having claims rejected as duplicates, happens to us too. :)
If you have any suggestions, other than reporting, and roaming powerusers (which we will introduce soon), please let us know!