News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Children Beating Up Robot Inspires New Escape Maneuver Sy... by godelski on Sunday July 08, 2018 @09:35AM (#17483718)
It seems to me that there were several different factors in the Radio Lab experiment. I think a few of the important distinctions include:

1) the furby was intentionally designed to look like a cute thing. Oversized eyes, fluffy, etc

2) it verbally protested. Which is the big thing they were stressing in the episode.

3) the children were alone and not being pressured by someone else in the group. They were also aware they were being watched.

Re:Children Beating Up Robot Inspires New Escape Maneuver Sy... by fossuser on Sunday July 08, 2018 @10:21AM (#17483921)
It also makes me wonder about the interview questions they talk about in the article.

If they asked the kids, “Do you think you were hurting the robot?” I think most kids would interpret this as a leading question (especially after getting caught and taken aside).

I’d guess they’d answer yes because they think it’s the answer they’re supposed to say and they think they’re in trouble.

Re:Children Beating Up Robot Inspires New Escape Maneuver Sy... by amag on Sunday July 08, 2018 @10:24AM (#17483933)
> 2) it verbally protested. Which is the big thing they were stressing in the episode.

I think this is key, kids tend to test where the limits go. They will push farther and farther until they are told they have passed the limit of acceptable behavior. I have kids and I know that just telling them 'no' may not always be enough, but it's a start.

Re:Children Beating Up Robot Inspires New Escape Maneuver Sy... by Klover on Sunday July 08, 2018 @11:49AM (#17484339)
That is what I kept thinking while reading the article too.

1) The YouTube link from the article mentions that most children let the robot pass, while the article reads as "100% of children are evil for no purpose".

2) Another comment mentioned the survey results possibly being skewed, because the children give the answer they expect is the correct answer. I think that's at least plausible.

3) Only a small section of observed children were interviewed: 28 total, because of a high list of selection criteria, according to the second paper linked in the article.

It all feels strangely written.