It's the same thing with the OS. There are always tons of complaints after a new release of iOS.
> ...I'll just use another one.
Yep. And you'll spend your time looking for another one and then you'll spend more time transitioning over to it.
> Most people don't think "Oh man I love Instagram v50.1.2",they just use Instagram.
Nope. Instead they think - "Oh man, Instagram sucks after that last update, but what can I do about it??" and then they give up.
If I really really hate an update, I don't spend more than a minute transitioning. I just look at the "Apps like this tab". Another feature that is not there natively in Windows/Linux and requires third parties to make subpar lists.
If new software was really so terrible, people would be abandoning apps, not complaining about them which is what happened with Linux and to a lesser extent, Windows.
Yes they are. The definition of empirical is that you can observe the evidence. This is easily observable.
What have you presented besides your own anecdotes?
> "Apps like this" on Windows/Linux
It's called Google. The same thing I use to find iOS apps because Apples app store search and recommendations are horrible. None of the app store searches are really any good and I'm pretty sure Google is the number one place that people usually search for things. I don't know anybody who opens up their app store to search for an app.
Anyway, argue all you want - you're wrong. People care about updates that mess up their stuff whether you can bring yourself to acknowledge that or not.
The total reviews will be less than ten percent of the installs. The negative reviews are a fraction of that percentage.
As such you cannot observe via reviews what the majority of the users think of the app.
Then, by the definition you have just given, app reviews aren't empirical.
Sorry, but none of your badly formed, hand-wavy reasoning has proven that wrong. Also, nobody is arguing that "the majority" think something - I'm arguing against your completely anecdotal and un-evidenced claim that it "rarely" happens.
What evidence do you have that it rarely happens? None that I can see so far...
It's like surveying a small percentage of an electorate by asking them who they'll vote for for and deciding the result based on the survey.
Anyway, once again... where is your evidence that this rarely happens?
My evidence can drawn from the fact that ten percent of people write reviews. A fraction of that are negative. If an occurrence happens say five out of a hundred times,that's a rare occurrence.
Please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use the site as intended, or not at all.
What do you get from laughing at other people?
EDIT: Your reply has been flagged which is not something I wanted. I do have evidence, yours.
10% is a huge sample size for any survey. Look at how it's calculated - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sample_size_determination
or just plug in your numbers here - https://www.checkmarket.com/sample-size-calculator/
EDIT: Someone is also flagging or downvoting your comments. Not me.
Where is your evidence for anything that you’ve said? Where is your evidence that it's polluted?
People who are fine with their apps don't write reviews.
Ten percent of the user base (at most) write reviews.
This includes the people who want to complain more than the people who don't.
In this ten percent a fraction of reviews are negative.
A fraction of ten percent of the total users feel negatively about the app.
This is a rare occurrence.
If you feel I've misquoted any part then I apologize.
This is obviously incorrect since you can see positive reviews, many of them in fact, on many apps. I myself have posted positive reviews... not sure when you thought I agreed to this.
That alone pretty much kills your whole theory. Sorry but I still don’t agree with you and I think you’re really reaching here. Most importantly though, you have presented zero evidence in favor of your claims.
People like sharing their experiences with others. They’ve been doing it for thousands of years. Go figure.
Care to try again?
"I've seen 3 star reviews so it must be true, because I've seen 3 star reviews, personally"
Was there a salient point that you were trying to make or are you just going to continue to misrepresent definitions of words that you can easily look up for yourself?
Empiricism is a view of epistemology, that cannot be reduced to a definition in the Oxford dictionary.
If you look at the link below, you'll see just how murky the field of empiricism is.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/logical-empiricism/#EmpVe...
I'm sorry for assuming you were speaking with any depth when talking about empiricism. If your base entire arguments on dictionary definitions then it's no surprise this conversation is going in circles.
I’d love to hear you make an argument that will shed light on things from your knowledge of the “murky the field of empiricism” though. Let’s hear it!
So far all of you’ve done is point out what it is. I don’t think you really explained how it helps your case at all. How does it invalidate the easily observable fact that you can see plenty of people leaving reviews for apps that they are just fine with?
You said people don’t leave those types of reviews but there they are. So what are you going to say that makes them somehow disappear? Really, I’d like to understand. Do we really need Plato though to explore this? I think if you really understand something you should be able to explain in pretty simple terms.
Most people don't think "Oh man I love Instagram v50.1.2",they just use Instagram.