News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:29AM (#17477200)
Signed up for HN (again) just to vent about this terrible news. This is a change that will be hard for me to live with, and I will probably end up selling all my Apple gear.

This is the same change/downgrade that occurs if you go to System Preferences-->General-->Use LCD Font Smoothing When Available.

I did this and the fonts on my 5K iMac display looked horrible. Just atrocious. My plan is to not upgrade to Mojave, and then within a year or so sell all my Apple gear and move back to Linux.

I don't understand Apple's thinking, but I believe a lot of people will do the same.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by jen729w on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:50AM (#17477266)
> but I believe a lot of people will do the same

No they won’t. People don’t notice this stuff. I pointed out the weird font smoothing issue in Finder to my best mate – a professional photographer – and even then she barely had any idea what I was on about.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by pixard on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:32AM (#17477208)
This doesn't affect retina devices so your 5k iMac will look the same it does now...
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:37AM (#17477224)
It does affect Retina devices. That's the whole point. I made the same change that Apple is going to make and the fonts looked far worse (almost unreadable). You can observe the same if you have an Apple device by going to: System Preferences-->General-->Use LCD Font Smoothing When Available.

Apple is removing sub-pixel anti-aliasing for all devices, not just non-Retina ones.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by galad87 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:35AM (#17477383)
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:39AM (#17477389)
Thanks. The fonts are noticeably blurrier/less defined in the Mojave capture.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by vesak on Saturday July 07, 2018 @07:42AM (#17478088)
Come on, no they're not. Those screenshots are virtually identical.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by tom_ on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:19AM (#17478177)
Maybe this person's eyesight is better or worse than yours, or perhaps just different. You might be surprised what some people are bothered by, or trained to spot, that others aren't...

Here's a possibly better comparison, because it annoyed me that the windows weren't aligned: http://www.framecompare.com/image-compare/screenshotcomparis...

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by SomeHacker44 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:19AM (#17478384)
Thanks for the improved comparison.

Zoomed in on my 10" iPad Pro the main thing I notice is kerning differences.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by vesak on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:28PM (#17479470)
Thanks, that's much better. I think it shows that Mojave renders the fonts clearly better: check out for instance 'll' in 'ullamco'. Generally, almost identical pictures though.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by eknkc on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:24AM (#17477350)
Try the beta before venting. It’s not the same thing.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:39AM (#17477391)
Downloading the beta now, but have seen screenshots of both (here and elsewhere).
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by read_if_gay_ on Saturday July 07, 2018 @04:44AM (#17477700)
I've been on the beta for a couple days (using a 2016 12" MacBook) and I haven't noticed anything. There's a visible difference when I disable LCD font smoothing in settings, but not much changes besides fonts appearing somewhat thinner.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @04:41AM (#17477695)
I installed Mojave beta on my MacBook Pro. It is the same thing. The fonts look identical to toggling off the setting "Use LCD font smoothing when available" in High Sierra. And by the same thing, I mean they look very bad in Mojave.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by galad87 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:06AM (#17477308)
No it’s not the same as disabling lcd font smoothing. Try the public beta if you don’t believe it.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @05:00AM (#17477739)
Mojave beta installed, and the fonts look equally atrocious. They are blurry, indistinct...and just bad. One of the reasons I bought a 5K iMac (three of them, actually) was to have great fonts. I am beyond angry that I will now have to sell them.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by galad87 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:02AM (#17477879)
Can you post some screenshots? I find hard to believe that fonts on a retina display can be blurry and indistinct, when the antialiasing text weight is almost the same.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:24AM (#17477922)
Screenshots available below. This is the only screenshot I took beforehand, so sorry it has some cursing in it:

http://www.technologyasnature.com/screenshot-comparison

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by galad87 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:38AM (#17477954)
Looks like Safari ignores the "LCD font smoothing" setting (I assume that was a webpage in Safari). How does the normal UI looks like?
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:46AM (#17477970)
Those screenshots were both in Waterfox. I also tried in Safari (didn't take any shots, though) and the fonts looked identically bad in that browser as well.

The normal UI's fonts are also worse -- about the same as the browser screenshots. Fonts are indistinct and blurry, and very light. All the result of greyscale aliasing only, I presume.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by galad87 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:59AM (#17477999)
Either Apple disable "LCD font smoothing" for retina displays, or there is a bug somewhere. Because in Mojave on a non retina screen "LCD font smoothing" has got the same weight as before. And on your screen it clearly doesn't.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @10:08AM (#17478531)
I hope it is a bug. If the weight were the same, it'd at least perhaps be tolerable on a Retina screen. I know the technical reasons, but I just don't understand why Apple can't leave it alone for desktop systems.
Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by sod on Saturday July 07, 2018 @04:50AM (#17477715)
They don't remove font smoothing. They switch it from subpixel level to grayscale only. Technically subpixel should produce better results then grayscale. But IMO the subpixel antialiasing in macos looks horrible. So you might not even see the difference as it looks exactly as horrible as before.

I'd be more outraged if Windows removed cleartype, because their subpixel font antialising actually works and is configurable.

Re:MacOS Mojave removes subpixel anti-aliasing, making non-r... by quipper on Saturday July 07, 2018 @05:19AM (#17477779)
Greyscale anti-aliasing is far inferior to sub-pixel. The fonts look much worse.

BTW, I did install Mojave beta and the fonts look just terrible even on a Retina display. Shockingly bad. I can't believe Apple is doing this. I just bought a new 5K iMac a few months ago. I wish it were still in the return period...but in other news, I am now selling all of my Apple equipment as it's pointless to have it. Without the great fonts I purchased it for, it's so much junk to me.