Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by DannoHung on Friday October 01, 2010 @01:04PM
(#1747704)
Your reasoning for point 4 is horrendous and terrible. You are advocating for the return of snakeoil. There are already problems with homeopathic remedies and "magnets" and all this other crap that gives people false hope and leads them to avoid making medically difficult choices while lining the pockets of shysters.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by philwelch on Friday October 01, 2010 @01:18PM
(#1747755)
Seems like snake oil is a problem either way. FDA testing for efficacy before approving prescription drugs is a totally different ball of fur--unless you expect legitimate physicians to write prescriptions for snake oil?
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by sprout on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:38PM
(#1748059)
You can suggest someone take anything they want if it's available without a prescription. You just can't say on the label that it's effective.
What exactly is being argued for if not that prescriptions should be allowed even when efficacy is unsure?
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by pyre on Friday October 01, 2010 @01:22PM
(#1747764)
But what is the cost of trying to legislate these people away?
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by msbarnett on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:53PM
(#1748122)
> But what is the cost of trying to legislate these people away?
Consider that many other first-world nations also legislate away drugs that aren't more effective than a placebo and yet still spend a significantly lower percentage of their GDP on health care.
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by pyre on Friday October 01, 2010 @05:14PM
(#1748774)
The costs are not always felt in fiscal terms. There is also the cost of an increasingly complex set of legal codes. There is also the cost of broadly-worded laws being applied in ways they were never intended to be applied, etc.
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by borism on Friday October 01, 2010 @06:49PM
(#1749086)
true, but maybe you should start with cost in fiscal terms and then go to solving all other mythical problems that bother you?
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by pyre on Friday October 01, 2010 @08:34PM
(#1749313)
You're claiming that we (in the US) have a simple legal code, and therefore it is inconceivable for someone to commit a crime without knowing that what they were doing was illegal? (i.e. 'complex set of legal codes' is a 'mythical' problem)
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by pyre on Saturday October 02, 2010 @12:58AM
(#1749775)
I would really like a justification for the down-votes. I have no one providing discussion as to why I'm off-base. All I have is a post that I consider to be bordering on 'troll' (i.e. calling all concerns outside of the fiscal realm 'mythical') getting up-votes.
Re:What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no ...
by borism on Saturday October 02, 2010 @04:32AM
(#1750071)
Maybe because you're completely off-topic? Like previous commenter noted there are many countries with much more complex "legal codes" than US, yet their healthcare doesn't cost as much.
Though if you have any evidence that cost of US healthcare is so high because it's so over-regulated, then you're free to provide it.