News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by zcid on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:24AM (#17476992)
This comment seems to be unnecessarily inflammatory. Your link points to nothing that appears to be political or "affiliated with the GamerGate crowd".

And why would you even bring up the philosophical leanings of the group running this GitLab instance (assuming you are correct). It has no bearing on the discussion at hand. Why try and run the conversation off the rails?

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by confounded on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:06AM (#17477123)
From their repos, it’s clear that this particular software community has a strong agenda; rape, incest, and anti-black racism.

The site contains the source for other sites that provide paid email/file-sharing services explicitly to “the date rape appreciation society”.

I’m very glad that they pointed this out. FOSS code and FOSS communities are successful when their work is used, shared, promoted, and contributed to.

I’m all for freedom to be edgy, but this is a dangerous and expressly hateful community, openly devoted to radicalzing young men into hating their own species.

They’re only joking, until they’re not.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by onyva on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:37AM (#17477952)
Second that and thanks for speaking up.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by cannonedhamster on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:12AM (#17477145)
Their logo on sapphire.moe gitgud.io under their services section is a veiled reference to Vivian James, the redheaded clover in hair wearing icon of GamerGate. That's the reference. Also Micheal Sulsenti, one of the people who runs the sapphire.moe account is a self proclaimed "Gamergate leader"
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by mintplant on Saturday July 07, 2018 @04:42AM (#17477696)
> And why would you even bring up the philosophical leanings of the group running this GitLab instance

In case someone is looking for a new repository host for their next project, so they can avoid inadvertently getting mixed up with a bunch of drama and hate.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by badsectoracula on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:13AM (#17477903)
That is kinda ironic.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by unethical_ban on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:20AM (#17476977)
But more importantly: who gives a damn? And what source do you have, if someone did give a damn? The linked site only shows several open source products and services.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:28AM (#17477001)
> The linked site only shows several open source products and services.

Clicking on the "Projects" link brings me to a page that includes racist epithets against Jews and Blacks.

That's why I give a damn. Seeking out any service that aims particularly to shelter that kind of language speaks volumes to me about the author's character and state of mind.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by ehsankia on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:43AM (#17477047)
Project link brings to you all projects hosted on the whole instance. I'm sure if you dig enough, you can find awful projects on any GitLab instance and even GitHub. The author of the linked repo themself has no other projects.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:47AM (#17477061)
As far as I know, GitHub makes a good faith effort to remove explicit bigotry. It would be unreasonable to demand perfection -- what I think is important is the intention.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by badsectoracula on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:40AM (#17477039)
What if the authors of the service are of the opinion that their job is only to provide the service and not to play the role of a thought police?

By checking out the "Projects" page, only the "Moonman Doom" mod for doom - a shitty mod that you see from 10 miles away that only 10yo at best would take seriously, assuming 10yo today know and care about Doom and modding - fits your description. Checking out 11 pages of projects (there is more but i got bored), everything else is the same stuff you'd find on GitHub: game engines, lisp implementations, web projects, games, etc and none fit your description (at least in their own description).

> speaks volumes to me about the author's character and state of mind

Guilt by association much? The only thing that speaks about someone's character and state of mind is their own actions, not the actions of others (and no, association is not an action).

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:45AM (#17477051)
I clicked the "Projects" page out of curiosity, not because I have 10-mile vision. You don't need to be particularly farsighted to see the slurs on that page (and now that I check, the repo README), either.

> Guilt by association much? The only thing that speaks about someone's character and state of mind is their own actions, not the actions of others (and no, association is not an action).

The last time I checked, I wasn't a court. I'm a private citizen who chooses to use projects and products based on a broad ethical code. One of the elements of that code is not supporting people who seem to be, at best, ambivalent towards associating with bigots.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by badsectoracula on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:01AM (#17477111)
> You don't need to be particularly farsighted to see the slurs on that page (and now that I check, the repo README), either.

My point is that nobody would nor should take that project any more seriously than the drawing of a teenager who is trying to be "edgy".

> The last time I checked, I wasn't a court. I'm a private citizen who chooses to use projects and products based on a broad ethical code.

Sure, you can act as you like as long as you understand that your freedom ends at the point where someone else's start. However this code of yours is not shared by everyone so you cannot expect people to not find it dodgy that you are making accusations about someone based on something they didn't do.

> One of the elements of that code is not supporting people who seem to be, at best, ambivalent towards associating with bigots.

It is your code, but to me that sounds like "you are either with us or you are against us" :-P.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:32AM (#17477207)
> My point is that nobody would nor should take that project any more seriously than the drawing of a teenager who is trying to be "edgy".

Like I said in response to 'ehsankia, it would be unreasonable for me to want to police the language of edgy teenagers everywhere.

The original question was "why I gave a damn," and I think I answered it: I find myself concerned when I see projects and products hosts on venues that are aggressively receptive of bigoted language (if not bigotry itself, and that's a big if).

> that you are making accusations about someone based on something they didn't do.

I stated my observation based on something they did do: choose to host on a service that appears (on principle) to be happy to host epithets. That makes me question their character and state of mind; it's neither hard evidence nor an accusation.

> It is your code, but to me that sounds like "you are either with us or you are against us"

I stated my beliefs in the first person intentionally. There's no "us," only me.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by badsectoracula on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:43AM (#17477244)
> I find myself concerned when I see projects and products hosts on venues that are aggressively receptive of bigoted language (if not bigotry itself, and that's a big if). [...] I stated my observation based on something they did do: choose to host on a service that appears (on principle) to be happy to host epithets. That makes me question their character and state of mind; it's neither hard evidence nor an accusation.

I understand. I still think it is offtopic and not worth the mention (as predicted by others, this discussion is derailed with the only ontopic bits of interest being near the bottom of the page), but at least i see your logic.

> I stated my beliefs in the first person intentionally. There's no "us," only me.

It was a reference to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You%27re_either_with_us,_or_ag...

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by golangnews on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:45AM (#17477050)
Association with and tolerance of racists and fascists has consequences.

https://gitgud.io/moon-men/moonman-doom

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by gsich on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:23AM (#17477180)
you are probably taking this stuff too serious.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by whymauri on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:26AM (#17477190)
I can see why you feel this way because I have similar feelings towards Voat, an alternative to Reddit that has unfortunately attracted a horribly racist crowd. But jumping to the conclusion that the author is somehow disturbed, especially when you can probably use this site without ever seeing that content unlike Voat, is a bit much.

You might be right, but you might also be assuming a lot about someone who was just looking for a GitHub alternative.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:41AM (#17477239)
I would have gone with "potentially receptive towards bigotry" rather than "disturbed," but I take your point.

I am indeed making an assumption, and maybe I shouldn't do that. But as a practical matter, I find it increasingly difficult to take things on the Internet at face value. There are enough interesting things out there that aren't associated with bigotry, and so it's a harder sell when projects (perhaps inadvertently) are.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by gsich on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:12AM (#17477144)
a good flame never hurts
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by xj9 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:36AM (#17477028)
> speaks volumes to me about the author's character and state of mind.

this is a source repo. the only relevant topic is the code. its free software so it honestly doesn't matter who the author is.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by confounded on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:56AM (#17477097)
Perhaps not to you, but clearly to others, it does.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by xj9 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @03:12AM (#17477471)
if a nazi and an $acceptable_political_alignment independently write programs that accomplish the exact same task, there is no technical basis to claim that one program is accomplishes the task more effectively than the other because of the character of the author. there are a lot of ways to approach a code review, but starting with "i don't agree with your politics, so i'm going to assume you don't know how to write code either" is very unprofessional.

note: i'm not defending whatever politics the gitgud people have. i'm objecting to the idea that you can base a technical critique on non-technical details. let the software or the math or whatever stand on its own. identity politics are really stupid. i really don't care who is behind the code as long as i can read the source and use it to get my work done.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by confounded on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:54PM (#17479894)
Your feelings are clear!
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:40AM (#17477042)
This claim is equivalent to me selling asbestos soda bottles and claiming that "the only relevant material is the sugar water inside."
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by iosDrone on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:57AM (#17477290)
More like selling soda bottles on Amazon, which also sells copies of the Turner diaries and Mein Kampf. You should really lighten up.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by woodruffw on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:14AM (#17477328)
I actually have a problem with Amazon selling (some) copies of Mein Kampf as well: Neo-Nazi groups have been caught selling their own editions as a way to raise funds. That, to me, seems like a cut-and-dry example of a Bad Thing.

Like I said to 'ehsankia, it's intent that interests me.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by iosDrone on Saturday July 07, 2018 @02:55AM (#17477429)
Yeah, I was referring to academic editions, and the fact that you have to contort the analogy proves how stupid the argument you're making is.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by cannonedhamster on Saturday July 07, 2018 @01:15AM (#17477154)
You only need to look at and google the owner of the site. Micheal Sulsenti. https://sapphire.moe/company/ https://www.vocativ.com/news/224320/gamergate-leadership-mod... Or look at the Vivian James logo for the site under services. https://sapphire.moe/
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by popman on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:45PM (#17479283)
> Or look at the Vivian James logo for the site under services. https://sapphire.moe/

Where? I can't see it on that page now.

Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by cannonedhamster on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:23PM (#17482006)
They've removed the logo since I posted it.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by labster on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:24AM (#17476993)
I didn't even realize that Git Gud was a real thing when I was playing Cards Against Downtime at the Perl Conference. I just thought it was a weird card.
Re:Show HN: Pesky Adblock – Blocks site access to visitors w... by discreditable on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:30AM (#17477011)
Its origins are in gaming. http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/git-gud