News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by foolfoolz on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:11PM (#17476483)
No UBI. The problem with UBI is social programs. we spend billions on safety nets for specific cases and purposes. safe nets for food. safety nets for healthcare. safety nets so parents can feed their children. this is a good thing. this helps people do something they may not have been able to do

basic income does not replace any of these safety nets. you will still have to have them. UBI is just increasing taxes

i’d rather add more safety nets to help those really in need than raise taxes to pay everyone some small amount

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by ttonkytonk on Saturday July 07, 2018 @07:49AM (#17478106)
So your safety nets for those "who really need it" are more expensive because of the bureaucracy needed to determine this. Furthermore it becomes a disincentive to accept work (as the article states) and rewards dishonesty i.e. "working the system".
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by lwansbrough on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:18PM (#17476519)
If somebody can’t find work, it would take a lot of social programs to ensure they can live. And I’m not convinced a state is more effective at spending the money than individuals are. Social programs are a huge spend and the quality of the programs leaves a lot to be desired (governments aren’t exactly known for being cost effective.)
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:19PM (#17476526)
I mean, replacing food stamps with thousands of dollars a month means the money could be spent buying food. I'm confused why you would think a UBI would not be allowed to be used to purchase food? The libertarian perspective on this is that we shouldn't tell people how to spend their money. If they can't afford food because they have no money, then give them money. Those who buy food will not starve. Those who don't, will, but they can't say they weren't able to buy food.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by jschmitz28 on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:21PM (#17476537)
I think your parent post's implication may be that those receiving UBI who are on specific government programs would not responsibly budget the right amount of money to the right need, and that there will still be cases where people have run out of money and need the same safety nets as before. If someone (or their children) is starving to death, or in need of urgent medical care, are you going to tell them that they should've budgeted better?
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by starpilot on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:26PM (#17476565)
By that reasoning, direct cash disbursement charities like GiveDirectly would fail miserably. But they've been shown to work extremely well. People in general understand how to allocate their own money better than the government does.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by RhysU on Friday July 06, 2018 @11:43PM (#17476845)
> People in general understand how to allocate their own money better than the government does.

Mwuh ha ha! Then why levy taxes for anything?!

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by AnthonyMouse on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:26AM (#17478194)
The people receiving government assistance are not expected to be the same people paying net taxes to fund it.

Although the existing system is so asinine that sometimes they are, which is just another reason to replace it.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by scotty79 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @03:06PM (#17479961)
> Then why levy taxes for anything?!

Because people owning tanks and bombs want to be paid for not using them.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by closeparen on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:55PM (#17481765)
Knowing how best to allocate money != having enough of it.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by dragonwriter on Saturday July 07, 2018 @10:38AM (#17478641)
Internalizing externalities.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by DougN7 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:56AM (#17478311)
“People in general” don’t need UBI. The exceptions are why the safety nets exist.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17478858)
Under a traditional UBI system, most people won't get money from the goverment. A UBI as the libertarians described it is basically a negative income tax. If your job pays $20k/year and the UBI level is $10k/yr, for example, then you will not receive anything. However, if your job pays $5k/year, and the UBI is $10k/yr, you receive $5k a year.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by graylights on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:56PM (#17476692)
If a person can't take care of themself then a social worker should be the safety net. Adult protective services should step in and emergency assistance could be granted. But people with patterns of mismanagement should have a guardianship assigned.

With guardianship that UBI could be directed to an organization to provide that budget management. They can issue a food stamp card, housing assistance, etc. That management could be a government agency or privatized. If privatized it would have to be regulated as a fidicuary.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:46PM (#17476654)
> I think the your parent post's implication may be that those receiving UBI who are on specific government programs would not responsibly budget the right amount of money to the right need, and that there will still be cases where people have run out of money and need the same safety nets as before. If someone (or their children) is starving to death, or in need of urgent medical care, are you going to tell them that they should've budgeted better?

None of these programs actually prevent that. If someone desperate for a job throws a dinner party to try to network and the guests eat weeks worth of their food, they starve before the next allocation whether the food was bought with food stamps or money. Anyone who wants to convert food stamps to dollars can find a little old lady, offer to do her grocery shopping and then buy the food with food stamps and pocket her cash. If the power fails and all your new food spoils, you're not "allowed" to resell your housing subsidy by subletting for a week to cover the replacement cost.

All the restrictions do is cause inefficiency. If someone wants to eat beans instead of steak or even just go hungry some days because they want to save the money for college or a down payment on a house, who are we to judge?

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by extralego on Friday July 06, 2018 @11:03PM (#17476718)
That is not the problem.

To me, it seems important to tread with humbleness here because UBI is not a product of modern science. We are not the first to consider it, and it’s never been considered quite an acceptable solution. Why is that?

The problem is, as often with economics, a problem with value and it’s ways of fluctuating across geography, networks, business and social structures in a matter of literally no time at all. Time is merely fuel to the fire.

Social programs are created by a government in the sense of a government that is of the people. Governments are not inherently just rulers of the land. They are ideally institutions built by people for the purpose of maintaining a state of civility and addressing common concern that might undermine that state of civility.

Social programs, or safety nets, serve a very specific purpose: to maintain a floor of minimum dignity (or less) considered acceptible in the sought civil state. If this is defined in terms of money, that level of dignity is then held victim to the precarity of value in a capitalist society; and that is not a floor I would be willing to touch with a ten foot pole; certainly no dignified person would expect another to either.

With commodities necessary to survive, it’s obvious how this can go wrong. We are talking about food and shelter here. Social housing is well-proven and extremely efficient. As it stands, masses of people in the US can’t afford housing at their current wage.

The best argument for UBI is as another economic stimulus, which is absolutely needed to prolong the final crash. The question seems to be who is included in the beneficiaries. So, like much of this type of thing, if we don’t agree to collectively give a shit about other people in the first place, it’s not worth wasting time over.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:20AM (#17478867)
> certainly no dignified person would expect another to either.

Um... what? The government quantifies exactly how much it will spend on social welfare programs each year. Simply dividing the budget out by the number of people enrolled (also available from the government) paints a very clear picture of how much 'civil dignity' is worth.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by scotty79 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @03:13PM (#17479999)
> They are ideally institutions built by people for the purpose of maintaining a state of civility and addressing common concern that might undermine that state of civility.

I agree but they are built by specific people - military. The state of civility is not a goal by itself just the best way for the military to get paid for doing nothing of value for the rest of the people, in predictable and stable fashion.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by daveFNbuck on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:00AM (#17478757)
Are you saying that all social safety nets are bad, or is there something that differentiates UBI from the others?
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:27PM (#17476576)
Well, the libertarian argument for a UBI says yes, you ought to tell people they should've budgeted better. Under a universal basic income, everyone would receive exactly how much money they would need to live and a little more. The extra could likely be spent on a budgeting class for those who need it.

Keep in mind, that libertarians are fundamentally against governments telling people how to spend their money. This includes the rich and the poor. The rich should not be told how to spend their money and the poor ought to be given everything they need to survive and not be told how to spend it either. Thus everyone is treated equally in the eyes of the law.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by chrisseaton on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:22PM (#17476540)
Some people would inevitably fuck up and spend all their money and have none left to buy food... so you’d still need food banks or stamps.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by thatswrong0 on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:51PM (#17476677)
You can still buy some junk food and soda with food stamps, and none of that is good for you. You could theoretically trade whatever food you buy for drugs or money to purchase drugs if you so desired. Should we force feed people nutritious food?

No, obviously not. Removing all individual agency from welfare is simply dehumanizing. Let people make the best decisions for themselves... and get legitimate help (not food stamps) for the people unable to do that.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by mikec3010 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:54AM (#17478498)
I've seen a food stamp program called WIC that had limits against junk food and overpriced brands. Also soda and chips will prevent starvation.

Dope dealers will not accept food as payment.

>make the best decisions for themselves.

And what about their children? Many of them are poor because they have kids. No one has the individual agency to get high on free money while their kids starve.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by thatswrong0 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @06:17PM (#17480937)
My point is you can’t force people to take care of themselves or their kids, regardless of whether you give them food stamps or just cash. Sure, food stamps guide them perhaps in the right direction, but there’s no guarantee those parents will use the food stamps responsibly. Bad parents will be bad parents. Those bad parents that would let their kids starve if they were given money rather than food stamps should have their kids taken away from them. But I don’t think most people on food stamps are like that.

So then the question is is the overhead worth that marginal case?

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by anonytrary on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:26PM (#17476564)
If people aren't smart enough to know how to spend their money, perhaps we need to provide better financial education in school. I don't remember having an iota of financial education from K-12 -- it was all focused around math, history, literature and science. "How to live your life independently" may as well be a core subject, because the United States is becoming breeding ground for dependent people. It doesn't seem in the government's best interest to push for better financial education, because they profit off of dependency.

It makes way more sense to have your constituents be financially educated than to "accept that they are dumb" and then just attempt to fix everything they mess up. The latter is unsustainable. UBI + better schooling should preclude the need for food programs, etc.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by chrisseaton on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:38PM (#17476622)
So why UBI then? People getting jobs should preclude the need for food programs, but it doesn’t in practice so you want UBI.

UBI should preclude the need for food programs and it also won’t in practice. What’s changed?

Why do you care that jobs don’t work for everyone, but don’t care that UBI won’t work for everyone?

If you’re a ‘people should just be smarter’ person why do you want to help people using UBI in the first place?

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by anonytrary on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:44PM (#17476643)
> Why do you care that jobs don’t work for everyone, but don’t care that UBI won’t work for everyone?

Because jobs and UBI aren't the same thing. You aren't guaranteed a job out of high school or college, so you are more likely to have some sort of basis for your claim that you need support from everyone else. On the other hand, with UBI, if you're given exactly what you need to sustain your life and can't, then it's clearly a personal problem.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by chrisseaton on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:52PM (#17476680)
> then it's clearly a personal problem

Right - so we still need a food program for people who have personal problems that cause them to run out of money - like being innumerate, or having mental health issues, or a controlling abusive partner, or just being super crap with money no matter how hard they honestly try.

You can say we’ll leave those people to starve to death, but that’s not going to get me to vote for UBI!

You’ll probably more realistically say ‘ok well we’ll help that one mother just one time with the baby starving to death because she is addicted to gambling away her UBI’ but then bingo you’re now running a food program as well.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by dragonwriter on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:58PM (#17476698)
> Right - so we still need a food program for people who have personal problems that cause them to run out of mone

We don't have one now; it might be nice to have with UBI as it would be now, but why would it be any more necessary with UBI?

Sure, if UBI is a more efficient means of solving the problems addressed by means-tested programs and unlocks economic potential forgone due to minimum wage, it might make the existing need for such a program something that we can afford to address, but it certainly doesn't create an unmet need that doesn't already exist.

> You can say we’ll leave those people to starve to death, but that’s not going to get me to vote for UBI!

But, that's exactly the status quo for people with too much income to qualify for food aid who don't spend it well. Why would losing that existing situation unchanged whole improving other areas be a reason to oppose UBI?

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by anonytrary on Saturday July 07, 2018 @03:57AM (#17477608)
> Right - so we still need a food program for people who have personal problems that cause them to run out of money.

Plenty of private charities can exist which you can donate to if you believe your money should be helping those people. A system where some people voluntarily donate has less inequity than a system where all people are forced to donate.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by matz1 on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:34PM (#17476611)
Same thing with welfare, despite the availability of various government program, some people still end up fuck up.

If someone fuck up and use up all their UBI then they must seek private entity such as church or charity.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by chrisseaton on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:42PM (#17476631)
> If someone fuck up and use up all their UBI then they must seek private entity such as church or charity.

But if this is your attitude - people who mess up should be on their own - why are you in favour of UBI? Why don’t you also think that people who can’t get a job should be on their own?

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:23AM (#17478881)
> Why don’t you also think that people who can’t get a job should be on their own?

Personally, I recognize that you need some level of money in order to take part in civic society. For example, it's hard to find a job without a mailing address, nice clothes, cosmetic products, and make up. It's also hard to put your time towards finding a job if you can't eat. Thus, in the interest of maximizing economic output and social engagement, we ought to provide enough money for people to be able to afford these things.

If you are able to afford these things, but still mess up... well, I mean, you have freely and without coercion chosen to disengage with society. To these people, I hope they are happy with their choice, but I struggle to see how they could be.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by matz1 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @10:54AM (#17478731)
How is this any difference than the current condition right now? We have many of government program but we still have many mess up, they are on their own too.

I prefer UBI because I can't choose however I want to spend it.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by JoeAltmaier on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:55AM (#17478506)
… or churches or charities or … but the volume would go way down. From a utilitarian point of view, its saving money to switch to a BI.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:26PM (#17476563)
The libertarian response would be to ... do nothing. Sure people may get hurt, but no one will get hurt because they didn't have the resources to avoid it. Every person who fucks up has only themselves to blame, not the whims of some government bureaucrat.

Just as a note, I'm not really a libertarian sympathizer anymore, but that is my understanding of the libertarian justification for UBI.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by foolfoolz on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:30PM (#17476593)
financial responsibility cannot be bought with UBI. ignoring how incredibly unlikely it is we would ever cancel social programs on a mass scale, let’s say we did. your example of people starving is good.

in that world you get to eat only if you are financially responsible. in the current world everyone gets to eat (or we try to feed the hungry)

i think the current model is way more humane. and we will never cancel social programs to have a less humane society

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by graylights on Friday July 06, 2018 @11:09PM (#17476743)
UBI is stuck in extremes.

Libertarians want to cancel social programs and replace with UBI so individuals determine how to spend their benefits. Socialists want to guarantee everyone a living wage but also want the safety nets.

Policy needs to be in middle. You need to enable people to self-manage. Must be ready to help them when there is a bad turn events. But you also need to have a humane way to deal with people that are incapable of taking care of themselves, for example mental illness. The way to handle that is guardianship, not other government programs that can also be individually mismanaged. Guardianship will surely be more expensive then UBI but it is the humane thing to do.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Saturday July 07, 2018 @11:24AM (#17478886)
> incapable of taking care of themselves, for example mental illness

On this point, I agree 100%, but UBI programs are not really focused on the mentally ill. As is, disability is a fraction of what we traditionally think of as welfare (and it's already neglected in our current society). Most welfare are food stamps, health services, etc, for people that would otherwise be perfectly capable on their own.

A UBI does not mean getting rid of programs for people that cannot actually help themselves like the severely disabled or foster children. It means not treating grown adults like children or wards of the state

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by ghosterrific on Saturday July 07, 2018 @10:37AM (#17478637)
The libertarian perspective is to not force people to give up their property, money and other assets as taxes at gunpoint in the first place.

So I totally agree that the Libertarian perspective is not to TELL (force) ME to spend my money on UBI

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by nickthemagicman on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:21PM (#17476531)
I agree. Didn't follow that logic either.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by extralego on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:23PM (#17476547)
What is the difference between the libertarian perspective and anarchy?
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by tathougies on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:28PM (#17476585)
Libertarians believe that government is necessary as the only means of justifiable force, but that the government ought to be only as large as necessary to provide the force necessary to protect individual rights.

Anarchists believe there ought to be no government at all.

If you can't see the difference still, I would recommend picking up a book. Hacker news is not the place to learn about various political philosophies.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by jnwatson on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:25PM (#17476557)
Property rights pretty much.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by krapp on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:45AM (#17478265)
Libertarians consider government to be a necessary evil, anarchists consider it an unnecessary evil.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by dragonwriter on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:50PM (#17476669)
> basic income does not replace any of these safety nets.

Yes, it does, in the same way that any other income already does, which is why those all tend to be means-tested programs.

> you will still have to have them.

No, you won't, once the UBI level is above the income level at which the programs would not be available.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by xapata on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:31PM (#17476598)
Some people prefer to sleep outside and spend their money on booze and drugs instead of food. If that's their choice, who are we to say they're misguided?

A basic income can eliminate many wasteful bureaucratic policies, leaving more money to spend on what folks want.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by DougN7 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:04AM (#17478342)
I (somewhat tongue in cheek) wonder how all those bureaucrats that’s we’ll get rid of will make a living. :)
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by contravariant on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:27PM (#17476577)
What confuses me about most discussions on this is the automatic assumption that taxes need to be raised to get UBI. Both sides seem to implicitly take this for granted, whereas it's fairly trivial to rework income tax to introduce UBI without anyone having a net difference in earnings.

Of course the real question is whether doing this would allow you to actually simplify anything, or if it's possible to simplify taxes with only minor (or desired) changes in net income.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by krapp on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:42AM (#17478255)
>basic income does not replace any of these safety nets. you will still have to have them

No, you would repeal all existing social and welfare programs, the minimum wage and employer healthcare, and replace them with a bare minimal UBI.

At least in the US, there is no other implementation that would be palatable to conservatives, business and most voters.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by DougN7 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @08:54AM (#17478296)
So what happens to the addict (drugs, gambling, whatever) that blows their UBI? Do we let them die in the streets with lack of medical care? Let their children starve?

How about the homeless in (any super expensive city that still won’t be able to afford housing there, yet for whatever reason won’t leave?

No, we’ll STILL need safety nets even with UBI.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by krapp on Saturday July 07, 2018 @09:07AM (#17478347)
Morally, you're right... we should have both. Politically, however, it would be infeasible to sell UBI as anything but a means of cutting back the existing social welfare infrastructure in order to reduce taxes and the size of government. We can't have both so long as a significant number of voters want neither.
Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by scotty79 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @03:04PM (#17479946)
> basic income does not replace any of these safety nets.

But it lessens the burden on all of them.

Re:Why the world should adopt a basic income by flashman on Friday July 06, 2018 @10:27PM (#17476573)
Here's the thing, UBI will be used to argue that other social interventions and support are no longer necessary. "We're giving you free money, and you want more?"

UBI is a convenient way for the wealthy classes to wash their hands of the poor without having to give up too much of their wealth. Not to mention it will probably be provided by a government donor corporation in the form of a cashless card with moralistic restrictions on how the income can be spent (e.g. no alcohol or legal cannabis).