News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Systems Languages: An Experience Report by pvg on Friday July 06, 2018 @03:13PM (#17474285)
Misrepresenting this cycle is just using FUD to activate a constituency to circle wagons. It's not helping anyone (as we're seeing from both sides of the political spectrum, which have gone all-in on this tactic lately).

It's a offhand remark in a post that's not about any of this. You're going out of your way to interpret this small thing in the worst, flame-inviting way.

Re:Systems Languages: An Experience Report by kbenson on Friday July 06, 2018 @03:24PM (#17474353)
> You're going out of your way to interpret this small thing in the worst, flame-inviting way.

Which supposes a different way to interpret this. Feel free to provide a different interpretation or this very short and straightforward sentence, and I'll definitely consider it.

Also, to be clear, I'm not positing that the author intends to cause the stated effect, I'm stating that the meme does this by it's nature, and the meme is also self-propagating by its nature and this same effect. The wording I used (that you quote) can be interpreted assigning intent to the author, which was not my goal, so I've changed them slightly.

(I would note the change with a note on the original, but I think these comments are sufficient to document it).

Re:Systems Languages: An Experience Report by pvg on Friday July 06, 2018 @03:39PM (#17474482)
Feel free to provide a different interpretation

I don't have to interpret it at all, it's not an important part of the post. And no interpretation requires some weird political swipe.

Re:Systems Languages: An Experience Report by kbenson on Friday July 06, 2018 @03:51PM (#17474581)
> it's not an important part of the post.

I feel any statement about about what a group of people are doing, especially when it can be taken derogatorily or dismissively, should be accurate, or at least with some basis provided. It was in the article, in my eyes it's fair game for criticism, even if the only criticism is that I wish people would pay attention to whether it's true, as the criticism in this case is.

If someone described C developers as "wild cards that think all our security concerns are overblown" I think a lot of C developers would feel rightly misrepresented.

> And no interpretation requires some weird political swipe.

I compared how the meme works to how memes in politics are working to divide, as I think that's the most obvious parallel that is easily visible to most people. Notice how I didn't promote one side over the other, as it's a common tactic in politics in general, but more visible at both extremes.

Re:Systems Languages: An Experience Report by pvg on Friday July 06, 2018 @06:33PM (#17475643)
My point is, it's an absurd amount of verbiage and offtopic thread derailment and hot air over some dumb joke that is basically irrelevant. You've written some bizarre grumpy rustacean equivalent of 'this site doesn't scroll properly on Android'.