It will be interesting to know how the circulation numbers have changed after PDFs have been made paid.
Actually now that I think about it, given the nature of their readership, the marginal value of the ads should be above the $3 they charge.
Decreasing circulation doesn't necessarily devalue their ads or job listings. Why do you think so?
From a business point of view, it may be good or bad. I wouldn't like to guess.
On the one hand, they might sell more copies. Without a free PDF cannibalizing sales, it will be much easier to convince people to buy something. On the other hand, it will decrease their circulation, which will devalue their ads and job listings.