News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by stretchwithme on Friday October 01, 2010 @01:57AM (#1746173)
The author says google is pushing out new versions of the browser automatically now. I was pretty sure I didn't enable the automatic updating feature but when I checked "About Chrome", I was informed that the browser had been updated. Seems to be no way to disable this either. Am I missing something?
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by modeless on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:48AM (#1746264)
This is how Chrome has worked since forever, and it's a good thing. Asking the user for confirmation for security updates leads directly to users running known-insecure versions of software. If you don't want auto-updates, use Chromium.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by 1337p337 on Friday October 01, 2010 @06:02AM (#1746552)
...Or a different browser.

Seriously, though, Google is used to web development, where they control the software and the machines running it. A new version of GMail rolls out, and everyone gets it. Like in the case of Buzz, this isn't always good, but it makes developers' lives easier.

But desktop applications are a different game. Almost any time you take control away from the user, it's bad. New version of the browser introduces a security flaw? Sorry, you've been automatically upgraded. Hate a new feature? See previous answer. Security hole found in the Google Updater daemon? Oops, we gave it admin privileges and ran it without telling you.

Has Google created so much good will over the years that people don't scream about this the way they would about similar behavior from Microsoft/Apple/DemonizedCompanyOfYourChoice?

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by patio11 on Friday October 01, 2010 @09:37AM (#1746952)
Users of b2c software are incapable of making decisions about their security, and should not be asked to.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by sesqu on Friday October 01, 2010 @12:27PM (#1747545)
An update procedures takes up noticeable amounts of CPU time and bandwidth. Automatic updates means your system slows down arbitrarily, often with no indication as to why. Users are able to make observations at the level of "since I installed software X, my computer doesn't work properly anymore" and interpret that as a virus infection.

Maybe they can't weigh the downsides of new and old versions, but they can weigh the downsides of now and later. Usually they go for later, which is a different problem.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by 1337p337 on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:13PM (#1748213)
A pretty dim view of users, but does that mean that Chrome is not for technical people? It's for an audience that is too dumb to be capable of understanding auto-update? (This audience, incidentally, does not exist: users aren't that dumb.)

In either case, the Right Thing was discovered long, long ago: sensible defaults. Users who don't understand the software needn't worry, and those that know what they're doing can make the appropriate decision.

It bugs me to no end when developers take this parental tack with users, as if we were not only responsible for producing the software, but also for ensuring the user doesn't do anything to harm themselves. Put an are-you-sure dialog box in the way, but don't try to force anything on your users. Even if you know better, you're over-stepping and your second-guessing of the user is misguided.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by modeless on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:51PM (#1748673)
> Almost any time you take control away from the user, it's bad.

Right, that's why the App Store has been a huge flop, and its closed model isn't being duplicated by everyone who's making an OS these days as fast as they can run their copy machines.

(Yes, I know that the App Store does prompt users for updates, but in all other respects it's a much more tightly controlled system than PCs, and users love it.)

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by 1337p337 on Friday October 01, 2010 @10:43PM (#1749531)
Prompting, rather than running a daemon that does it automatically, is the entire point of what I said. Adding functionality isn't taking away control unless you have to color outside the lines to disable it.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by gaius on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:22AM (#1746322)
Imagine the howls if Microsoft had done this...
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by drdaeman on Friday October 01, 2010 @06:17AM (#1746574)
Howls of joy because we won't have any IE6 systems left? ;)
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by edanm on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:32AM (#1746338)
It's not about Google vs. Microsoft. The world has simply gotten smarter about such things, and most people now accept auto-update as a good idea.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by rmc on Friday October 01, 2010 @10:37AM (#1747137)
It would be brilliant! If MS did this then IE6 would have dissappeared long ago!
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by rmc on Friday October 01, 2010 @10:36AM (#1747131)
I use Chromium installed with apt. All my software on my computer gets updated automatically :)
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by aj on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:07AM (#1746193)
Yes, that is a feature that Google has hardcoded into Chrome. You CANNOT disable auto-updates or even make it so that you are asked for confirmation.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by masklinn on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:28AM (#1746231)
Of course you can (disclaimer edition note: but it's not necessarily for the faint of heart, and isn't officially supported. On their updater and update policy, Google manages to be worse than Apple on Windows, which is already pretty fucking bad).

1. On Windows and OSX (at least), the actual updating is performed by a single service running in the background for all Google applications (the Google Updater). This service is installed and/or activated by all Google applications, every time you install them (or run them, in OSX, not sure for Windows). I'm sure you can find how to do the same in Windows but my know-how is not good enough, but in OSX you can disable GUS forever by uninstalling it, emptying its directory and then setting it write-only. This way, it's not possible for GUS to be reinstalled.

2. A good enough outbound firewall (I'm partial towards Little Snitch on OSX) will allow you to block connections to the update server, and make GUS unable to query it, and therefore to update Chrome without your consent.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by barrkel on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:39AM (#1746246)
On Windows, Autoruns from SysInternals (http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb963902.asp...) works fairly well for finding out about these things that happen automatically, and disabling them, as easy as unchecking a checkbox. There's at two categories relevant to googleupdate: CurrentVersion\Run, and Task Scheduler.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by barrkel on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:59AM (#1746471)
Too late to edit: there's a third one, in Services, on my machine gupdate1ca54[more hex digits] - it also links to googleupdate.exe.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by aj on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:47AM (#1746263)
Ugh, of course, there are work-arounds. But if you re-read my comment, I said it is hardcoded in Chrome. I was talking about Chrome.

Another point: Your method will disable all google updates (google toolbar, google talk etc) which is a good side effect imo but not necessarily desirable by all.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by barrkel on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:46AM (#1746359)
It's not hardcoded in Chrome, at least on Windows it's not. I'm currently running 4.1.249.1045, which I gather isn't particularly recent, because I seldom use it except for Facebook and other sites I don't trust to be logged in to for general browsing.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by aj on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:05AM (#1746383)
Please do check and tell if you have the Google Updater service running and that it is working fine?

Else, please tell how you managed to turn off automatic updates in Google Chrome?

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by barrkel on Friday October 01, 2010 @04:57AM (#1746464)
Google Updater is not running. I turned it off with Autoruns, like I said in my other comment.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by aj on Friday October 01, 2010 @05:01AM (#1746474)
Then how is that NOT a workaround? You are simply putting forth an argument which does even pertain to the point I was making.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by barrkel on Friday October 01, 2010 @05:07AM (#1746488)
aj, you said expressly, twice, "that is a feature that Google has hardcoded into Chrome. You CANNOT disable auto-updates", "hardcoded in Chrome".

Your statement is factually incorrect. That's my point.

It is not "hardcoded in Chrome". It's a separate application altogether, and it's soft-configured in Windows, not hard-coded into Chrome. The fact that it's soft-configured in the Windows registry, using documented APIs, means that it is easily disabled; there's even a utility written by MS employees, on the MS website, for such software configuration. I take hard-coded to mean that there's code built in to Chrome which tries to auto-update on startup, in an unavoidable fashion. But there isn't. It's not hard coded.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:51AM (#1746271)
That's a very bad "feature". On some connections I pay for every MB downloaded.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by beej71 on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:04AM (#1746292)
I agree it's questionable from a money standpoint, but not updating your browser is questionable from a self-preservation standpoint, as well.

(But I also agree that should be your decision to make.)

The compression Chrome uses on the diffs is pretty hardcore:

http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/software...

So you can at least be reasonably certain that your browsing bandwidth dwarfs the Chrome updates, FWIW.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by fauigerzigerk on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:15AM (#1746303)
I don't understand why they're taking that decision away from me. They could just enable auto update by default so most users would always be up-to-date unless they have a reason for disabling it. There are some good reasons other than money as well, such as privacy and security. I don't want my computer updated in any shape or form when I'm on an airport or in an authoritarian country for instance.

I don't know whether a Chrome update is dwarfed by regular browsing. The link you posted shows the size of one particular diff update they did. That's a completely worthless measure. The worst case, no doubt, is that everything has to be replaced and that would be 10MB.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by darren_ on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:48AM (#1746363)
Security-wise I'd be very surprised if Chrome updates weren't signed; MITMing of auto-updates isn't exactly new (see EvilGrade). So I doubt it's an issue there.

That said, I agree that there should be an option (not a prominent one) to switch it off.

Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by wazoox on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:24AM (#1746222)
Fortunately, the auto-update feature doesn't work on my Linux machines.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by russss on Friday October 01, 2010 @03:48AM (#1746361)
Chrome's auto-update feature on Debian-based distributions at least consists of it installing its apt repository in your sources.list. Which is fine by me.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by jan_g on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:50AM (#1746269)
Same here. Everything is managed via Synaptic update manager and Chrome gets updated only after I hit the button 'Install updates'.
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by DennisP on Friday October 01, 2010 @10:27AM (#1747108)
Then why is my Chrome still on version 3?
Re:Google Removes Cookie Control from Chrome by bostonvaulter2 on Friday October 01, 2010 @02:27AM (#1746229)
If you switch to linux it won't auto-update.