D) Your child spends his/her high-school years mowing lawns, doing part-time jobs, etc, in order to save some money to help pay their way through college. You encourage them to do so. The money earned is put in a jar. You take that money, replace it with an IOU, and use it to pay for household expenses along with more frivolous things. Now it's college time and you scramble to find the money to pay the IOUs.
I am naively assuming that what backs the value of a t-bill is the US government's ability to accrue future tax revenue to pay it back.
What is it that makes a t-bill owed to Social security an investment rather than a tax deficit when it comes time to cut a social security check?
The above is roughly how the system works now, makes sense right?
Of course, you'll see various peopl with an axe to grind calling it a pyramid scheme for the pass-thru payout. And claim that the government is "raiding" the trust fund by selling it t-bills, or say that the trust fund is backed by quote "worthless IOUs". I didn't know t-bills were so disreputable! But aside from the silly rhetoric, it's a pretty sensible strategy.
It shouldn't be a surprise that the people who administer the program 40 hours a week actually kinda know what they're doing. Unless you come to the conversation pre-equipped with ideology and blinders.
There's a macroeconomic issue, as well--if you just let that money sit in an account for years on end, the money supply gets fucked up. Money just disappearing into a hole is essentially deflationary, and deflation is catastrophic. Then, when the money comes back out again, you have inflation (possibly hyperinflation if the amount is big enough). Better to hold onto that money somehow while still keeping the money supply relatively constant--in other words, invest the money somehow.
For very similar reasons, it's much more difficult for the government to carry reserves of funds from year to year than it is for them to carry a debt.
You used the word "lent". Note that that is different from the word "given with no expectation of repayment". Care to revise your second sentence in light of your first?
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSPEK14475620090601
"Chinese assets are very safe," Geithner said in response to a question after a speech at Peking University, where he studied Chinese as a student in the 1980s.
His answer drew loud laughter from his student audience, reflecting skepticism in China about the wisdom of a developing country accumulating a vast stockpile of foreign reserves instead of spending the money to raise living standards at home.
Economically, China is playing Chess, the US is playing Checkers. China is more than willing to sacrifice one or two generations of people to gain global dominance. The people controlling the US economy think in periods of 4 or 10 years.
even more obscene than this fiction is how the Federal Reserve prints money, lends it to the banks, who then lend it to the Treasury and collect 3% for doing so. Its such an obvious subsidy of that whole sector, without which would look much worse.
The point is US T-bills are considered one of the safest investments in the world but when people start talking about SS for some reason they pretend that they are worthless.
The dollar may not enter a hyperinflationary death spiral as some believe it will, but its days as the default world reserve currency appear to be fading fast.
And in a short 5 years the direction changes because 2015 is when SS outflow is expected to exceed inflow and they have to start using some of the interest income off those bonds. In 2025 the inflows and interest income become insufficient and the SS trust fund has to start selling the bonds and by 2035 the assets are themselves exhausted.
The 2010 OASDI Trustees Report http://www.socialsecurity.gov/OACT/TR/2010/tr2010.pdf
No, there's no fiction - legally it must be paid back. That's why Social Security debt is included in the gross national debt.
The first addresses the "accounting fiction" aspect.
The problem of course is there's no "there" there. Any funds collected today by payroll taxes, and not used for today's benefits, are lent to the general fund and spent. There are no funds being saved for next year's benefits, much less the current tax payers.
Now, it is true that the Social Security system then holds "assets" in exchange for that cash, namely, government bonds. But this is just accounting fiction.
Imagine you are a new parent and wish to save for your child's college tuition. Here are some scenarios:
A) Every pay day you put some money in a jar. When your child goes to college you take the money out of the jar to pay the tuition.
B) Every pay day you spend every dime. When your child is ready to go to college, you scramble to find the funds to pay the tuition.
C) Every pay day you put some money in a jar, then you replace the money in the jar with an IOU, and spend the money. When your child is ready to go to college, you scramble to find the funds to pay the IOUs to pay the tuition.
There is no substantive difference between B and C.