News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by marcus_holmes on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @09:13PM (#17454723)
Do you want darknets? Because this is how you get darknets...
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by mirimir on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:43PM (#17455146)
If this applied to the entire world, sure. But this just adds the EU to China, Russia, Iran, etc. That is getting to be a huge chunk, I admit. But EU users will just need VPNs and/or Tor to escape.
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @01:52AM (#17455485)
I think it works the other way around.

If one of Facebook's users (anywhere in the world) posts a piece of copyrighted material, and that material is served to a European user, then the copyright owner can take Facebook to court for copyright infringement under this legislation. I'm not even sure the owner has to be a European entity.

European law considers the offence to occur in the browser's country, not the server's country (hence Yahoo having to block all references to Nazi memorabilia as a result of a French court case held in France under French law despite Yahoo not being a French company).

Mind you, the US takes the same viewpoint, hence them suing to extradite Mr Dotcom from New Zealand for trial in the US for transgressing US law. The fact that he wasn't a US citizen, MegaUpload wasn't a US company, and he had committed no crime according to New Zealand law didn't matter. The US still considered his breach of copyright to have occurred on US soil, so he had committed a crime on US soil.

At least that's how I read it... I am not a lawyer.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by mirimir on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @02:35AM (#17455619)
> ... and that material is served to a European user ...

But in this scenario, Facebook would be blocking all EU users, based on IP address, DNS lookup, and so on. Just like Netflix blocks non-US users from accessing US-licensed media.

So EU users could only access Facebook through Tor, or VPN services. And Facebook could still argue (and make sure that it held no conflicting data) that it knowingly served no users in the EU.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by llukas on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:21AM (#17455949)
Why are you describing situation where VPN is needed to access Facebook as bad thing?

I set up ublock/pi-hole for a reason :) If they GTFO EU then even better as EU pages won't load their spy scripts.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by mirimir on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:43PM (#17460205)
I agree that using Facebook via VPNs and/or Tor is prudent. If you must use it at all. Because, even if you obfuscate persona and location, it's still harvesting data on social connectivity. And even if everyone involved obfuscates persona and location, that's still too much data to share with a single entity.

So anyway, Facebook was just an example. To show how social media etc providers could work around the EU Copyright Directive. By blocking access to all users known to be in the EU. If there are no apparent EU users, arguably the law doesn't apply. But then, IANAL.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by strictnein on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @03:04AM (#17455688)
> European law considers

Thankfully foreign laws don't magically propagate over the internet, even if a citizen of a country happens to point their web browser at your server.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by infimum on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:14AM (#17455925)
GP explicitly stated a case where the US did the same. So for all intents and purposes the law does propagate 'magically' over the internet. Well, at least US law does.
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by specializeded on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:16AM (#17456793)
The EU isn’t the US, and the US isn’t New Zealand.
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @09:55AM (#17457263)
The EU does include France, though, and the example of French law constraining Yahoo's behaviour is relevant.
Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by fauigerzigerk on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:06AM (#17455893)
IANAL, but I think if you have a business establishment in a country then yes it may propagate in some shape or form, but I don't know the details. For instance, it may depend on distinctions such as subsidiary vs branch office.

Facebook does have a business establishment within the EU. They are selling ads in Europe that are delivered to EU users. There is no way that Facebook can claim not to be a European company in some sense.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by mirimir on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @08:47PM (#17460222)
Right. And so, to escape the EU Copyright Directive, they would need to exit the EU entirely, utterly, completely, etc.

Maybe that seems extreme and unlikely. But consider. What would Facebook be left with, if users couldn't share anything?

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by fauigerzigerk on Thursday July 05, 2018 @04:34AM (#17461717)
You'll see. They will come to some arrangement with the publishers and regulators. Facebook will not lose a quarter of its revenues and profits over this.

The problem is that not many have the clout of Facebook and Google to work out arrangements that won't kill them or fight the whole thing effectively.

Re:Latest Text of EU Copyright Directive Shows It's Even Wor... by marcus_holmes on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:38AM (#17456018)
As I said: yes, yes they do exactly that.